• 検索結果がありません。

ローカルガバナンスと新たな公共性(上)

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

シェア "ローカルガバナンスと新たな公共性(上)"

Copied!
23
0
0

読み込み中.... (全文を見る)

全文

(1)

ローカルガバナンスと新たな公共性(上)

著者 山本 隆, 村上 真, 森 裕亮

雑誌名 社会科学

号 73

ページ 59‑79

発行年 2004‑09‑20

権利 同志社大学人文科学研究所

URL http://doi.org/10.14988/pa.2017.0000007478

(2)

!"

# $%&

'()*

'(+,)*

- $./ 01234$56

7 89:;<=>?

8 @ A

B2CDEF;G$HI3JKLMNOP<QRSTUVWXY;

B2CDE$Z.[W\]^]_$`aLbcde+U\fgh$ijdk l<mVWXn$op<qr$+smV\t4duvw!"3UV\

xyz:;<{|3b}$~€$‚ƒ;$„g…<†A‡ˆdsX

\‰Š\‹ŒŽ\‹^$-‘$’“”d€‚$;•–—

˜™’3Dš›œsXžŸh ¡¢ $<£œ\¤YUW d¥$ops¦§<$£X]Lb¨©‰ª\^«$¬­®¯°±²³´U\

µ¶·hU;A\sW¸¹2º“»¯°<¥omV¼^½¾¿<¥\

$ÀÁÂGãmVWX

­º°Ä“hÅw;»ÆÇȚÉ\ÊË\Ì}ÍÎ}…<b}\]_\

Ï]_…ÐÑ8WV‰Š$OÒ$`ÓdÔÕ3<A\OÖ<‘<dAרUVWX

(3)

!"#

$%&'()(*+,-.%&/0123456789:;<=>?@ABC DEFGHI6J'()(:&KL7MN7OPQR4S TUV4SWX;1S<&/

4?4 ,YZ[S'()(!"\5H&/

]^G _`abcd6e,fg%&/hi%&jk 4S ,lm%&nopq,rIos7tu:&

vw,hx4dbXGyz,{|%&}P~€]‚ƒ,

„…4d</†‡ ˆ‰&cd6e,Št4S‹Œ4d<

fX&/

Ž ,lm%&nopq

Ž ‘A%& pqH&5

’z“”•–—a<€˜€™š>›œ4ž8Ÿ ¡

¢£[S<&/’z“”•A¤¥<S¦§¨©ª«TU

¬­7GHIH<M&®¯H&89OPQR:I°'1SˆI' ()(±²€™³´¥I,°4S<&'()(89”µ¶GH&·

¸¹S<&/0º:IJd»089”µ¶H&¼]7½¾0¿À ÁÂ4‰1Ã;</

º\¥<SďGÅ4ÆF&:bÇÈÉPÊË Ì¨ÍÎÏ w7ÐÑҀ˜€™·<bÓÔ,Õ<S€˜€™Ö×,¥(Ø;?4S<&/Ù :1èÍÎÏw7ÐÑҀ˜€™·€˜€™EÚ7ÛÜ7ݰŸ,ޚ

ßI–Y&01€™@Aˆ<S†5Ml5àF'1&á*G â 〘â㝛ä?1S åæçèé'1?[d<b/4?4€˜€™

êMëìÒ¨íî·ïð—4ñòâãkóô°¢£õ7osö

÷òÁÂ4SÖ×,øùÆ'1Sîd/0Ö×½¾7*¤úûü€˜

Ÿü€™Ÿ';íýþÒζ¨ BC·ˆ‰&u½¾ 7*¤‰??&€ŸGH&/

íýþÒζˆ‰& y”ö÷ö

÷­ µÎ¶7¤€7,Xd¨ÍÎÏw7ÐÑҀ

ÛÜ Ë Ì

Ž ËÌ

˲?Ë̔TU©˜õ

Ì

(4)

! "#

$%&'()* +,-./01123456789:;<=

>?@ AB3CDE;FG

H>FGI1/JKLM3N=EEO PQR3STE1UV;89:T1QW3XYZ[\]

^01_YQR3[\]`01"abc!defg3hijkl mE1no;1p;"abc!defg3qrstAu;v wx]yzW3{|}]1*~€‚ƒ

F1„…†‡ˆ‰Š ‹IŒŽG;‘>H 1[Q(67;’“IG_Y[Q;”#1{•6732–]QR3—

5G0˜™š›œFGžŸ I1¡r¢£¤n ¥ FG¦>^F[Q(;&'‰f+1I¤nj§¨©F1

;§ª”«¬­;®1&'¯ d‰;°±²³3¬­F´µ¶|30}]

FGH·¸¹º»;”#5

;`>¼½/1¾¿ÀŠ‹;ÁÂÃ;ÄÅ3ÆiÇ1È ÉÊ"#˜Ì"#ÍÎÏ67""#3‚ƒH;Ðц

‡ˆ‰IÒÐEÆ|ÓIF´¾¿À`Ç1 ÔF1

ž67;ÕÖר;riÏÙ"Ê;"Ú3ÛØE1_Y[Q1j§ÜÝ;abc

!defg/`Þß:1‰f àáâ㠊äåuæç‹;ÕÖQRèl`C éêÚ3ëÑEìaàfgížî03ïðE/01ñòÔ/

;67óô3žõºböÀ+÷C.ø1 ¥ùúûŠüýä¶þ‹;W uæ3ëÑE^r_d*‰`_Y•:Ú1}1ÕÖ(;

&'67î0I

Y1‰» b Š‹1_YF².j§¯ d‰1 öfg†‡ˆ‰>F‚ƒÈ`Ç1öfg†‡ˆ‰;

¿âÏJ‘2–.i>H beÀ+Š ‹

>´}./01_Yœ;öfg;ö À.ø 3WE_Y¯ d‰; F;1 F;éêF1 j§; ;–FG>;`>j§:3Er¿â1

bↇˆ‰Ërj§:Š‹

í*~€Š ‹ñò;“:Á 67ÜÐ9Å1

Š !‹"" Š‹ ‡e H;Št‹Šü‹

Ð;1Á ‡e 3ÆÅ1® 1}1"

aö ¾¿ÀŠ‹ÁÂÃ;ÄŅñòË6

(5)

!"#$%

&'()*+,-./0123"45-6'789:7;

<=>?8@A;BC,-45=D8EF'G"HIJ'(GKLM N OPLQR8S*MN T,45U#VW-'XY,-Z[\

]8^'G8 _`1ab;'(

cd7: _`K'e`fghi j]1MN OP8 k'lm"no,-MN OPLpqrs1-&tuvwxyz'o"

{:|%'7}7L]776'($~_€A|%tuvw xfghi 1‚1ƒ„2…2†‡S†‡,ˆ‰0

Š&Q ‹Œ-ŠŽ--"8;&LJ'(

C‘’MN 1'“<”•8–s'—˜ƒ&’%-s%+-:

-(2™š1›’MN –sœ$'1-&:žA8#FŸ

;& ¡"¢:%'(£š¤—¥"¦§;¨¦§©ª8«G"

¬­®¯°±-"6&(<%{²>³<./´

’µn¶8·{¸ˆ‰’%'¹z'ºM»¼½x¾¿xxÀÁ¶à VÄÅ"ƁA;'(GKL;—˜wÇ"¤ÈŠŽAɶAz'- 7|$Ê$-MN PË8ÌL1HÍ;{rs1-LÎ*

"…"6'J'(

GKL-ÏÐ,-эÒF1fgÓi_7:fghi ÔÕÖ;×

*'G"'(fghi 1£ØÙÚ£šÛÜÝÞß"45=

>àáâãz'äeÞ ¼ åJ'(æe`fghi 12ç 菐´ÛÜ45=>§*<é_h;2™š

êëìíîï"ðñ, òz';óôJ'(

;7;cõKL-45]{J'(ö¨$8F÷'fghi Ô Œ1¤

øù;úûcüýÏÐÙþÀ Á

776'(fghi 1†F:%'ÏÐMN šþA´<

o;MN ´tiä¾i À?¶Ã8z'M N PË 8®z'HI¶7:#'($fghi Ô Œ1Ï,Þß 0š~Ói_œ?8z'G7:{#0†1MN T ,-Q MN 8;'(<%1$º Å MN OP !"£š†‡<%1BC,-'G8© ;

ÛÜ ÀúÃ

!ÀÃ "#!

(6)

!"#$

%&'()%*+,-./$012'()3 45678&9:;<=>?@AB<CDEF4 GH$ (&=I&J K@LMDEF4 <NOPQR/Q&3456S5TUV5WU XYZ[\]^_`abX3456bc%def/$

)gab7hQ34YZ56i jk&ablm$3456G nop h-$34qSrsmtuvwxyz&3456n{

G$b|%/ h- (&345T}~def/$2

=I'()%&ab3456b$J€_34‚i78(def/

ƒ&„…†/ !2xF%‡ˆ‰iŠy‹Œ‚X34}Žn_

‘&g’“”•–—˜™8š›œžŸw–—V ¡ƒ22'.¢„

`f/$2 2`£ $&g¤¥)¦%34‚i§¨b©(

ªW&«bŸw¬­y‹®¯ „`xƒ&3456S°x)wk

±²&7Šx*³´%Nµ¶$†$·&iЏ¹56S 5T}~ º»x -}~‚¼(½,./$

`£&)34¾}~ -¿$ÀÁ§SÃÄÅ('/$/)2.3 4ƾ~¸ÇV)ÈÉÊËÌÍV34Îj¾ÏÐ «ÑÒ-34ÃÄ%Ó ÔS_&34§Õ}~ÖרNÙÚ&34¾»„&Îj¾ÆÛÜÝc&

Þß_%²fà„` áâx)ÃÄJãäå%ÓÃĕ@æ(34 56SçèxéêN'-$<N34ÆÉÊËgëì%íîïð(ÌÍ f/&†/¹¾~¸Çñòóáô½$&õ‹_ö÷øñ&†ùö÷‚

úÖ ¸Çx$†…&¾~¸ÇGû¾f/$ì 34 Îj¾½$&üh4býþ&ÉÏÐ Ò-&‡ÎjqSÖ

× <-$OQ&ñ 7&}~deŸ ±²$O4 % Ó

2&)34¾}ÃÄ +,$&3456Süªm$}~

‡Ð$g8)ü%&)2.‚f/34Îj¾X&}~É -)( ˆx34&ƒ<ÌÍf/$†&

÷ÌÍXYZÏÐ ./3456S(;%™34}

@ UÙ

!"#$

%

(7)

!"#$%&"'()*+,-.

/01 23456789:-: !1;<=78>?-@ABCD EFGH%&0IJKL- IMNL OPQ-=78>?

RSTUV!-1W=XYZ[\UV]^1_`abcdUV]

^1efghiAj3UV]^1klmno UV] ^1pqmrsUV] ^I tu,- =78>?v.wIx178 y =0 23 z{|qmrs78}~v.w9 €b-1=78>?=0 2‚ƒ>?9w1qm„…;†<$‡ˆ‰Šd9 ‹ŒIcd!$"- { !Ž‘I !L- /01’b-1=78>?I=

DEFGH6[\$I,1'(“?1”'1•–$,— 45-qmrs 6˜{1™š›6=qmœ-.!ŽžŸI

 ¡,1@ABCDEFGH1¢£¤DE¥Gh¦I§›¨

©ª «9$.1`¬­®b¯-Il°w0r?1=0‰Šd6±

²-­®b!n³­®"-´µ.¶·¸¹º»¼½…¾!$"-

¿ÀÁ Â@AEÃÄAÅÆG!=¶·½¸¹

Â@AEÃÄAÅÆGÇ~„…!78ÈÉ$ÊË6ÌÍ- Â@AE ÃÄAÅÆGΨ$ÏÐ!-1™ÑÒÓÔÕÖ64רÙLÚ-w1¶·

Û6ØÙLÚ- Ü&ÓÔÝÞ=ßàá1âãàáäÉ-w1=

"-åæçIèé-êë3- ™ìí1¡îï ðIñòóôõ ö6÷-w1øîï ùö6ú 4û$!üýþ-

Â@AEÃÄAÅÆG{¶·¨ìí!-1ç!âÉ-w1 È.O-3- åæ1 a b!™9$b!

läÉ6-w1äÉ ç¸¹1Oåæ ×é"- ÓÔ¨ ¨$9w1™IåæbH 6& $,1‰–6$éÚ-}‹m† 12`1`1™

¶· ]^

! =78>?!-1]^¿ ¤>?!¦] =78>?^ 1<6rL

!""

(8)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0123 4/01&56789:*+,-;<=3>?@A-=BCD EFGHIJK=LMNO56,-PQRSTUVWXYZN[\

]^O_`abcdefg!U78*+;<=hJOHH!

OX'ijk[lm=no56pqrN&Wstuk [=vwO'o56T&xy`bRz{|}~€rCTU

‚ƒ„B…e†‡6ˆH‰QŠ‹=!€„B…Œ$T&?@Ž

&‘’N“”•–|—.2&H8˜™

šo›œ˜ržŸTUN ¡>

¢o£&¤¥`¦”§`P¨©ª«¬­®¯…r°±²‘’N

!³´OžŸrUM¬­®µ¶N·&¸¹º»=¼½O!N>b

¾©Q=¿ÀÁ`¥|ÂÃÄÅÆroÇÈÅT&¸¹N¬­®µ¶ÉO ÊP¨Ê‹ËdaP¨©Ë̾©Ír[\¬­®µ¶&¬­6ˆ

K&¸¹pqr¿ÀN΀€!ÏÐÑ҆ÓËÔ՛œÖf¬­×Ø ÙÚÆº»N>ÛΒo¸¹pq>!ÜÝuN>¸¹$

=ÞWo!T&²¸¹ßàá=vw>âãHäåCµ¶æ

¬­‘ÖçT±èŸé!ê#$ëìÆº»&íîN>ï`SðQpqæ ñòróCNrU!ôÎ!T&

Î&d©õ`a¾Q. 2ö÷&øù¬­®µ¶N]^>² d©õ`a¾Qúû«üCC“ý¸¹…Hþ¸…¿&OPRz©

P|ÌCµ¶Îr=Î& ®š

=Î6úYZ=“!%

N#æ&–}r‰’+ZGrÃÚ"#$olm=n oTU¸¹…&e®×Ø=¶µ¶Îª

›œ¸¹…&RzË{|}_`aóCTU

“r N>&²ï`SðQíˆr56qN>K&

gï`SðQiN=>oï`SðQi

¥`‹¦Ê©QN'o().K2

.2

! ".2#$ %!&! "

'( )*+,-

`©Ë¨©©.2.Ë 2¤¥`¦”§`P¨©N<

(9)

!"

#$%&'()*+,-"./0123456'(7)*+, -+"./89:;<"=>?34@ABCDEFGHIJK"

?34LMNMO2PQPRSTU". VWXYZ [0\]X0 R^_`a"bcZd NeP40\]fgh]4ij?34klm NEn89:;<opqros^tLu?34Lvwxyz{W ^tX| }~€q‚ƒ"4W34Xq„…†‡ˆ‰Š4q

‹ŒXŽMN

'‘’“”•X–W—˜™š›XœdQP89:;<ž4q/

'(!Ÿ X| 89:;<X¡?¢|£†¤¥¦4§¨

?N©R7ªXu«?'(¬­‡ˆ®{Wq£LkI‘’¯°

6‘±!²¯³=‚ƒ°´µLM34X¶·89:;<¸'(

!Ÿ ¹Xº?»¼½„¾¿q1‡ˆ"'ÀL N

P89:;<¡aÁÂ4Ãeq ÄLÅÆÇ0(È"./ N ÉÊXq„ÅÆÇqrËf(È(”4q„Ìn0\]4ij"Í1eÎe qÌÏÐÑÒXӄÔÕ©Ö®{WNÖ·—89:;<¡a4רÙÚÛÜ ÝÞß<"àá?ÅÆÇMNVÅÆÇ'(!Ÿ"âd{Wq 89:;<XA BD"GH'(!ŸâKãä " NFX'(!Ÿ"âdåæXçè žé"ÌÏXê?(Èk./ N'(!Ÿ"âdåæXçè'("

žéÌÏXë/'("CìíîïçðñÌÏòóôõö÷øù

Ÿ!²¯X–úûºiüuýþd©9Ý<¯÷øX–

„ÌÏ'‹Œ4qN3–X xLËfq"?ÅÆÇÔ W N

33L1W9qCLqúûRq1W 34LMN ÌÏXœd1eÎeqß 99<„4·34 LN

9<b

<.

+Þ <

<

Þ X–W—<4 Û

ӄ"?4 34—£{'kLM„<4b

± ˜™š

(10)

!

"#$"%&' (" )"*+

,-./"0123 456789:;"& <

=> ?@AB,%CD

EFGHI<JKLMN OPQ%R3 S9JKLM"T-UVWXVYZR[S\]VJK^_ `abcd7 VefR[SghVijkV\lJK89%mnV&opbcd7V qrDs%9EFGHI"09tu1vwx y z{|}CWXiT-U~`abcd7"m€cp‚ƒ89

~„,

EFGHI 3S…†"‡ˆ‰ŠV‹Œ JKLMRŽ

…"opbcd7‘R’rB“"”•,opbc d7<–V&—˜™Rš›œV"`abcd7"!JK"ž‡ˆYZ V‡ˆ‰Š Ÿ7 ¡,9

EFGHIR<‡ˆYZV‡ˆ‰Š¢&£¤"£u¥¦8

‹§¨ ©ªV«¬^_­N O®¯1

°<;Œ±ˆ"«²VC³´±L&‡ˆYZV‡ˆ‰ŠR[S9µ¶,9

–V&·£h¸5p¹Rº»¢&¼7>N O½Ž¾ h¸¿À ·ÁV­ ÃÄ"ÅÆ¢­8ǘ"09 ȗRJK É"ÊËÌ,<³´­,9&

¢ÍR³´­,¢ÍÎÏÐ,¾ÑÒ89ÓÔCÕ89

Ö ×Ø qef

EFGHI8"qr efD89Ùr+«

à7ác)&âãÍN±O

N !O"#$ $ %& '$(

NO

!$) *+, - + , ,./0$'11222&%1+1 13 4+1

N5O"# $%&$%

$$) *+, - +, ,./0$'11222 &%1+1 13 6

(11)

!"#$%&'()*'&+,- #./0*'&+123456789:

/#./;<981=>?@:5ABC#:/D#.BEFGH I

#I:0

J KL4MNO%'PQ

RSTUVWKL4MNO%'5:XYZ[\+]8

^'GXYZ[\+_`ab:c"d#e]9:/0b f5^'GXYZ[\+g5hc?ijklgD5mnoRp%I:

qrstu:vw;xQy9zb:c{|]89}~:/0

XYZ[\+€5‚:qrƒ„…†‡%\ˆ‰Š‹ijŒb

Ž‘’“}”•/‡%X–}—˜W’“}™šq›5‚7/Š‹ij sœzVW5mnžŸQž ¡z¢£¤¥¦§}¨©ªz0 ]XYZ[\+«¬5b­I:?ij;oRpO4KL423 4#®¯]8F°±;nªzD²³;´zbRSTU:c0¨µ?y¶Is

œ·¬¸ij]8ƒ„…_`aq›5‚7/¹O*U;q›º»¼½ }¾¿™šÀ¢:/b:c=#qrƒ„…ÁgbÂÃ::/Db:

c0<cz²³}KL4MNÄ%]8KL4MNO%'_`ab:cÅÆ#b 8•/#./0dÇst;q›ÈÉÊËz¢Ì6IÍÎ;#ªIfIn:/d

#?qrÏÐW qrÑÒÓÔÕ

q›3%Öר×ÙÚ4 Ûܬ

q›ÝÞß%Ú ƒ„… q›àá }Á´â/z¢5ãä5f<b5IåcDb:/0

æ MNO%'çèbÄÚGMNO%'

RSTU<czMNO%'²³PQ}éêâ/ërìVçèstç èÊËíbMNO%'îï;ðn:/d#MNO%'ç譝z~

‚]I:b:7I:bˆñâ/0

ò&–4ØMNO%'}cfón:f<b9ƒ…?:89/ôÆ MNO%'õö¦ â/÷Ú;õ}ø¦â/z¢5aù}

â/úû5üýâ/Dþ;MNO%'^‡%?õ;5‚:z

Ó !""#

$%% "

$&'%%#( ) *+'+ & !!!

(12)

!"#$%$&'()*+,-.&/01/1*234 56*789:;<=>)&?"*@1

*A9BCDE@*FAGHIJKLMN) OP*QRBSTUVUVW@1CDE SXYZ[F1"\9]^_`abc?d"

efgSTUVWhi9jk+l+"STUVmnop":;qrPE srPtuvwnxyz{|}h)F1"~€‚Hƒ„

nv1…†)19jCDE*HIJKL

‡ˆ&xj)‰Š*‹:9dŒ !Ž*‡ˆd

‘P‘’dj“'(”{•*–—"CDE‰Š˜™)

*‡ˆ‰Š9š›Pœ$œž9+l+"

CŸ ¡¢£H$¢¤4}¥¦9jk§¨©Nª «

„n)UVP¨¬­®¯°)±"9

²?j³*A9B´µ¶@ª«9·¸)¹º¢»

4+j¼½P¾4j¿*ÀÁPÂÃÄD$¹º¢ÅW)*FÆÇ ÈÉÊË/ÆjÌ

Í ÎKÏEÎ$¡

Ð =>

Î$¡ÑÒjÓÔÕv_DӜÖ×kØÙÚ$‚žÛX~

*ÙÜK%Ý$ÄW/1Þßàá9F19BÑ Ò»âãäå*æ)çè*\9{2éêëìÌjíî fïðñ}òá¥*=>óÙ*‰ôŒÓÔÕ_`iW*Ù õö÷øá/*)*‰ô2@1*Î$¡kØÙ Ñùú*ÙÓÔÕ_`_ûõö*üý&þ9

Ú$‚žÛX~9~+,*jå99k {Ú$‚žÛ³ WÓÔÕ*9=9 Î$Ÿœ\j"}ª]«

ª«

(13)

!"#

$"%&'()*+,-./012"34567 89:;<=>?&@A4B7CDEF1GH7IJ9GH'KLMN 9OP1QRS9<TJUVWX&489KLMN9YZ<T*

UVWX&[\4]UV^X 9QRI_`1a784KLb c 9B7defghij"j9_`T4kl'KL*B7mn1 o7

ip72"34UVWX&qr'st:QR1u7Svw -567x0yzSUVWX&9{n4|Z9{n'T }~€‚b c7}ƒ„"…†" ‡UVWX

&bc7}ˆB‰Š‹ŒŽ7}]‘‡

UVWX&obc7}’“”•‡$=V–—#&b c787}|˜™š›œ !"#b c79|Z<T

2"34J=>?&@A9_`1žSQR1Ÿ 7UV WX&1 ¡89 ¡¢n'=>?&@A9_`Z9z£¤p

¥¦S91§SUVWX&[\4¨S8<UVW kl©ª «b¬­®c

¬²4@A'@A³´µ1ŽSi¶9œ:CDEF1·¸7i¹<T89@º

»¼4;½¾@K¿š›ÀÁ87ÂÃ?Ä?3ÅÆ¶'<02"348Æ

<9¬ÇÈ9=>?&@A9˜LÉ@º9»¼1¹yz1{zÊ7¬ ¬ËÌÍ b c ¬ËÎÏb c ¬ËÐÑb! c:b"#$

"%&%'%bc () *$c

¬²9=>?&@A9@º»¼4Ò;½¾@K¿Óš›ÀÁ87ÔÂÃ?Ä?3Å9

šÕÖ×:'8'=>?&9Ø¢˜LÉ9”&–Å12"¯jUV^X 9”&–Å 2"¯jUVWX&9”&–ÅÙ_`*×Jš›ÀÁ42"¯jUVWX&

+,9.Úx0:ÛÜ1Ý <T¬²9Ø¢˜LÉ9š›ÀÁ4s9]މOØ¢

ß´b! co1.Õà7i]š›ÀÁ'‰OØ¢˜LÉ9á1â7iS‰

O˜LÉ1ãä7i' åœ1-ZæÉb ! c1çè*×i:éS 2"¯jUVWX&ê†"342"¯jUV^X J-ë7ìØí$"%&()

‰œî#ï"ðœî#ï"ñòXï?"î#ï"1ó¶iš›9ôÖ+,1-- o2"34567 $1õö

$

"#$"%&%'%bc !$+#,- , $.,"/$

õöcI4UVWX&9{n1|Z7'"

;9øù01*!& 2b÷’õöcI4{n1úZ7

<4„"…†" ‡UVWX&ûüý79UVWX&‘‡UVWX&þ 79UVWX&“”•‡$=V–—#‡”&–Å79UVWX&B7@L‹79U VWX& !"#79UVWX&:

(14)

!

"#$%&'()'(*+,-./012%345%6 74 89: ;<=>?@ABCD45%6

EF'(*6;<=: GHIJ/KLM45%1 ;<N- OPQR12%6HISTUVWX%Y3: Z)[/K \)[/K ]

^K_[/K*STU`Da%Y3bc45%6

dF3efg)3hij>U2%ki +,-./lmn*1 opUqrX%Y36

sF)op12%6Y$: tuv"5kO12 3hi$k wxy$z +,-./{|}~by$kO12%6

F12%6+,-./: CD€‚k56+, -./: &'()12%6:ƒ„)…†‡ˆ45#$‰O *Š)

‹k`ŒU+,-./ŽX%Y3:1h%6

 +,-./ !

89: YB4k+,-./‘4 w’l“”•34 –—^˜z

™š†‘X%›K=œž34Ÿ "#¡¢%6Y+,-./£•

589:¤¥5%6+,-./: Z)J/K \)J/KU¦§

X%x¨©S”•12%6+,-./: ª«¬­x¨12 •‹ G Z®'(Wy$5 ¯r)12 w’y$%°±12%6~by

$k: tu ²³´µ¶·¸l¹4 `º»¼4 –—^˜

5½¾¿À35%06kÁ +,-./: –—^˜3š†‘4 Âk !‚•35BY312 Ã$kÄ12%35BY31:5Y 3OÅÆÇÈ45%6

YB4k+,-./ÉÊ: Ë̕5ÍΕh•#5%6;<=

ÏÐ: ¥•:YËÌVW•5ÑҋÓz 89:

ÍÎ: Y$+,-./ÔÕ¾Ö4 ×45ØÙÚÛ4ÜXY312

%03X%6

89: +,-./34;<=03;<=Ýޟ "# 7$U 8é;<=3×kZeäêè

äè

äè !!"#äè$ äè

äè äè

(15)

!"

#$%&'()*+,-./012345 6789:;<!0%=$()*+,>[email protected] FGHIBJ0DE6&KL/M6!

N9BCDEFGL6=OPQRSTUVW$

XXYZ[\]^_`a6b' cdeDEFGfghij 66&-./kL!0%=$lm()*+,7 <nj FGOghij6!op54op5SPQRlq$rsRt uvRwx/yz()*+,/{|i}6b'=O%()*+,

$~Z,€‚ƒ€Q,€„=0@h…†6%„'0()

*+,6TUlqO‡ˆZBC/&„‰>Š‹e‰eb'6&Œ6 -./XL%eb'!

NHI6&$ŽZ‘bX’“eX=”•6HI ()*+,=$:–—$˜Z™š/›œ|ž'Ÿ ¡/E6¢

£i}¤¥¦§5¨ZeDEBC/© 6&ª6«=$e‰E6¬

­Z®¯&e°‘/&e!

N±²B„'$BJL6$³´Sµ¶/·¸ ¹L O

%BJ6& =Oº»¼()*+,½¾6XT«Ze¿=!

ÀÁÂÃOBJhÄ$’“Å6‹! ÆÇÈÉ Ê7oËÌ<

7< !"##$ %!& 7<

'#(#)) ))

))

()*+,

ÒÓ ÔÕÖ×[ Ø¥ BC

F G Ù ÚÛ FG DEFG

BCÜÝ ™Þ HI

àƒáQ,*·¸ ™ÞBJYâ BJ

ã z ä¶ åæ DE

çèé7<)"

(16)

!"

# $%&'()*+,-./01&'( 23.//4 56%!#781

9 :;< => ? #@ABC>

D @ABC>#6

> ? EFG#HIJKLMNO#PQRSTUVW#

#X Y>#Z[S\]^0_#781P`aSTLMNOUbcde^

fg78h^)ij^klmj\]nokpq!rs^#

U78tNO#uv#wxky1

0jwx#z@ABC>{| }~,-./#78 @ABC>{|

Z[S> ? @A€C‚!ƒ7/k„m1@A

€CE…†#‡ˆ‰Š`aNOK-‹ŒSŽ6#k‘!#’“

”/t•j#78hE…S–—k˜™šx›kpq!j3œJœ#ž

Ÿ 7¡“!…†S¢‡ˆS£¤8.¥”/t_#¢#781

@ABC>#{|E¦§¨œ©¢œª«¬7#‹­®¯Z[°

k±-_#781/ °²!#³´Sµ¶S·¸k¹!NOº NO»¼#&½¾¿781@ABC>NOºNOÀÁ Âuvk!à ĥ_#78t1@ABC>#ÅÆC>ÇÈÉ4E@A€C#‹ŒÈ

‡ÊË.¢R̀?ÍÎÏÐÑkÒÃ78t1

ij@ABC>ÓÔÕ֢רkÙÖ7KhÚۄS78_##E@

ABC>6#ÜÝÀÁÞ#ßà…SÆá âSÆá ãäS¢jR ÌxoRÌåæRÌç>èÏk‘!Ã781@ABC>éÀÁ#&½¾

¿kê!1@ABC>#×ëNOK)ìºNO»¼#Þ¢/.#©í7

#&½¡“Äî78t1E@ABC>#Û|#zïðÈ/ñ¢È/òóS¢&½

¡“£¤78tÈ.ÃEœMMJµ¶0?èô< õö¢h@

ý ? @ABC>þj¢…Â(fg

fg !"#$f!g %&

fg'() # **

fg* fg fg

(17)

!"#$%$&'(

)*+#$%$)'*,-./ 0123*+&( --4#56 789:-4#;<=>8?@

ABC$DEF !"(

G:HI- JK-4#LMNO PQ RSTUV RSW XYZ"([\]^ _-`ab#cC$L defW XY&'8(ab#cC$LdefgRSh&+

\]^ ijMNOklmno pq&rsg ito puvwx,A%aCy^Nzo

pg{+|}~9(*€*-'*,?k

‚V\4$ƒ!8„ab#cC$Ldef…†"[‡S8 ˆ&' 23 !"(? n… ‰ŠZ" !8„‹Œ$%f^$ƒŽ

fMŽfMŽf ‘’“f!”G•G8‰Š–—8@˜Z"

!"()'*,-4# MNO=>8™Z" !"(

-šlV›1)*+œV›1Sž,Ÿ †¡¢Z£¤8{

+&¥¦F !"(

H§--4#LMNOh¨©=>ª¥¦

ˆ!8„¡¢ «¬/G[k‚ ­¬)*+®V¯BC$°C^$

¯BC$)*+g[±²³´¡¢Z«¬*+&W ŠFµ¶Z·

9(-k‚šl ¸ ¹º, »¼½*+&

&<(¡¢ «¬‹¾V°C^$¯BC$¿$À¯BC$ ÁÂÃÄ 9ÅÆ®V¯BC$g{+F) ¡¢ÇÈÉZ+& !"(

-ʬˀ€¸ rÌnÍÎÏo

pÐ9€(

-h&+?/ ÑÒZ|Ó ÔÕÖ×ØÙ€F*8&Z

?/ ÑÒZځ0Û*Ü8& !"[- ÝgÞjßVL®

V›:? ABC$Z?àV›1Sžá¦âãÍF,8& !/

šläå æoºçèp

o !!"p "

nÍÎÏʬËëÑÒZìÑÒÎÏ*+&+íVîP,ŸÑÒ ZâãÔÕ*êwíVï[žŸðñZ"[âãÔÕ òóôõö âã 789:÷$

O f$f)*+âãÔÕ øNB#g{+FžÓ”&'ùú½ûY!"(

(18)

!"#$%&'

()*+,-,./!0*123&' 4567 !"895%,./!0

*:;&'<%/!0*=>?@ABCDE=>F6&GHIJK HLMNOP AQR#SG1T:U1V2W/!0

*X=>YZ#[\9]^X_`#abcd e%&'<%fghijk,lmn CopqrW<<

)st+uvCDWwHLG5xyW3]HL5%z{W'

XW|}d~€#d2k%‚ƒ„

…`#2†‡23&G=ˆW‰Šd‹Œ5Ž‘

#%<W&M’“23&'

)”•)Xvs4–—˜&5%xy™š&'X

5 ›œP+!ž :U#ŸG WHIK¡]L5 \¢

›ž› ž›ž5£¤5+!=ˆ#¥¦

2 5i.:U#]\§¨©HL3&'4

–X_`mn:;ª«¬‚­®¯°‰iš±²W³´HL 5%?C*4–Xµ¶E|}#·2¸¹=.

vº !"#dW&'W»¼P)œ½s¾¿À+#z{Á 2™ÂÃÄQÅ#ÆÇ2ÈÉW'

Ê •s¾/!0*ËHL?@ABCD

<%WÌ¡MÍiÎÏÏÐÑÒ²ÓuÔÕÖ 5’“Wz{ÁHLרWÌ¡M5]&'sdc–

•s¾Ù1Ú#›ÛÜÝÞß,.àábâ ãž5%äå&æ5›Þßi.#Ã%çèHLßéeêë :;HL555%ÝìíŽ#îï%5#

25%<<ðñò­Þßóô¾&i.õ;WöËá÷W'£

<#]\5ž5%

s•s¾Køù›?@ABCDž5%

úû#5<W'ü]L

•s¾Üâòã

âã

(19)

!"#$

%&'()*+,-./'0"102345 678 9:0;02<=;>00.?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMN6O

?DEF-PQRS<TUV@;02WXYZ[DEF\]^_`aI bcHIJKL6de0&'()*+,-fg6h?ijklImnV

@& 02'opq%&rP1st0;WX5=;

02#=;>

uvwGBCDEFxy0MN6z{|;5=;>

}~G0.5HIJ6KL|;.02G#o}B€

‚ƒ6„2…†n|;.02}‡.ˆm`IQ‰fŠIkI‹j

Œ5;Ž6‘|;[’:}G)“|;”•d^6–—|;˜:G

#oR™6š—|;02›œ0;>}HIJKL—ž

5Ÿ:; ¡#¢£5fg6c:;@/<¤¥V@0;>

kI_IG”¦5Ÿ:;§E¨©5Y0”¦(ªBCDEF«¬­®

BCDEF}ijklImnV@& 02¯Y°±² 6³´0;µ¶·¸>

¹º»¼ ½µ¾¿À¸

µ¸ !!"# $%&'!& ! (&) µ¸*

µ¸ µ¸

”¦(ªBCDEF «¬­®BCDEF ijklImnV@&

§E‹ÄÅd^ Ɓ‚ƒÆÇ02 mk5Ÿ:;

Œjk,-HIJ KL>

*ÈÂÉÊË1ÌÍ Â6ÎÏ|;&Ð

ŒjkˆÑkŒjk ,->

ÒÓ^dÔG‡„

ÕÖ<fg6×Y ØÙ<[†%#\ž6

›Y>

Úg^#±Û

ÁI ŒÁÜÝj‹ÞßÄ

àááâÂ> aiãˆßÄÉÊ

ËÅä> aiãˆßÄÁI _ßÄ>

()¢£{ä àEÇåæçÇ5$>

ÕÖ./ŒjkG

‡„#0>

èéªê5$´V@

&ëÕ^ªìíî> ïð#ñòóôõö6“

qp÷uV@&ëÕ

^å()^ªì>

(20)

!"#

$%&' ()*+,)-./0%1234$5&4$6)789:

;78 <=>%?&@A3&;BC DE6FGA3HIJK>G&

'ELHMNOPQ%RS3&;BTC(UVWXY Z[\]^]T U_ K%`ab;CG(!;G cde)fg hiG&

'jk)lm()*nAop#A&qr9st ; Nu'NG&

'+,)lm9Gv ; (!;B

w # G x

3yz{|HKTA3I }~%3€9‚

ƒ„…;}~†#N&‡3ˆ‰ Š1‹%!Œ;CG9(€;BŽ

}~G$vS‘’e“ ”%@A‘’e“

•–—S9-˜ 3€3&;CG%™š…;G&'CG›T'A‘

’e“ -˜G&'CGGœ!vb3‘’e“GT ˆ +,)

ž Ÿ%? …;œ (!;CG"#$¡¢£Ÿ%¤¥¦ 3&;C HI6G±)’в¬³°

ŸI´gJ µ¶eD E6

^]·FF¸¹º»(

¼½¾¿¸À%Á'¢

¢XÃÄÅ Æ Ç%123Èq ;É mB

¢XGÊËG ÌÍ¢

XVβ%ÏÐ;S uœ\]ÑÏÒÆÇÓ vÔÊ˂ÊË%Ó 'BÕ>7Ö×#

ØÙ‚ÚÛ ÜÝ9 TCÞÐO ;B

lmßà Gcre)fghi áIK>%œGx;’

º JâÊ˂

F;ãäÑå‚ æÞB º»=<ç=â>

èé<êë>ìíî ïTA3ðé ñÓ%

12òóôAõ3ö 'Õ>B

fghi p#A&Õ

>

÷ŸëøI6)78

!;&Wùúe|H

<zÕûB

üe“!;&ý

õeþyzÕB seº º ž@¬á°B

’Šfg Ë ~ Å Ÿ | H

’e“9ýe fg Ë~PQ%

ÏÐ3$TA3… 3 ’eîÑ9T Ë~

%A3&;B

’e“ Ë~

e¬T 9¡cdGÖ

$)†%œO A3&;GA3°

fg%ºpB

u “œfg Ë~ýePQ%

ÏÐ)&BŠ Û

%123Ñå%…

;CG9GÖ)

;B

³• ¢£G

Ñå fghiNNv;

µG Õ|ÑåB

<ê GF

;<ê

˜…;fghi%

12³Î€ ÑåB

+,(¹Jyû

H = 6(Be(²9

!;ÑåB

¹ ¬°

(21)

!"#

$%&'()*+%)*,-./012345&678%9

$:;)*+%<9=%<>?@ABC./012DEF GH34 IJ#$*+<9=KLMN+ IOPQ>

R)+STU*KL VWXY#ZM$+ [\0]^_

^`a>M++ % :bM$*+=

cd \efghij \efKL

klmn<9Le>KLopq+*-rstuC 9vwxyr&zq{|}f~7IO&'€‚ƒ„+M$*…€„

†5<9‡ˆ=%-{|}f~7IO5+ ‰Š>ƒ‹Œ

&Ž nMI"#$‘0’“&#v”•+–M—ƒ‹ Y$€

˜&#v”•+ ™š$*BA%T•>ƒ‹€›œ0ž0Ÿ 0~70

¡~ ¢£¢=++¤$¥¦§ƒ‹+ Y¨B©§

ƒ‹&Y ª¡+ «€qv”•+ KL+ ¬q„†>™š$*

+<9=z˜­®¯˜Mv”•+z<°¡± :²³´U*+

>µ¶·b*¸¹º» 9=9¬q./)*²¼M$*+µ

¶T•½¾>£¿12op&ÀÁ

1r&' $U*ƒÂ#$£¿Y129+>./Y1ÃÄW¡ ™v

#$%z9= ½yÅÆÇÈ1r>É#$=

oÊËÌÍÎp>9.&I"ÏÐÑÒÓfB+*Y$ƒ‹

+ Y¨&' $&ŽÔ’“ACÐÕ֋¡&š*:b×

oËÌÍÎp+ „† „+M$T• 9=

#*klmØÙÚ>Kme•Û. ÜÝ./<>Þ-ß½£¿12 ³àz³Æz./&Èá) U*+5ß½./<9=klm

<>%ß½./&â„)*++ ãä ¼*råØrs>€æ½qª¡

çè%&éêë#$.ìAíî#$€ïðMI"#$.ñ ª¡<9:bM$=%.ñªr+ òžŸó>GH>.ñôžr õ

~ö<9+ %÷H>.ñø•ôžr&ùz>E)+%

&v”) )€ U*ÜÝ./&I"Àú.ôž2ûM$ üÖ ýñþ op

op !!"#$!"%#&!op '!

Ã0Æ o(pÈ1‹ãù(

(22)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01234&56789' 8:'6;1'<=>-?@ ABCD;1EF+G#1/HI JK;1'LMNOP.3MNFQ751#(ERS3-LTUV6 WX/<86YZ[#1'\]S- !^(+,SA_23 4EW56'

`)a6-MNFQ bcdefghijkl&'mnoW 7-pq-5fghijrs6WJtEu )vwxyz#1/{|`}6 E~1'5AWL{|€801‚1JtEu7E~1'56 - S Sƒ„…†X#0‡ˆ‰7Š#1')‹ - EFŒŽo‘8:':'\]’“”aS -MNFQ7•–fg hijrs—{|€8Z˜™v&š›œ‘W56 ž8:' 51#&š›œ‘W56A'MNFQŸ ¡o¢£'/‹-¤g¥¦

§¨©ªA'›œ‘76;1'«‹ -{|€8¬­fghi jrskl8:'MNFQ®¯7X¬(8:'6-L{|°±

²³´µ[016¶z™v·&56 ¸¹(8:'/7B-ˆ

º{|»b¼g½/F¾™v¶zfghijrskl&'/‹ - L{|°±p/®¯701#Ÿ(‘W5676;1'„‹7-¿ÀÁ ÂÃgÄÅ8:'ÆÇÈ/7JtÉÊËÃÌÍÎ&'8:'c-5 58 ¿ÀÁÂÃg—"tÏ ÐÑÅ&'ÉÊËÃÌÍ7¤g¥¦§

¨©ªÒÓÔÕÖ6×D;1'{|»b7"#Ø&'ÙÚÛ¼ÌÍZ˜™v ÜÝ&'ŸÞ’-ß#àJtEuáâ;ã'ä‰åŽ-./-æç 7è&'éêÔëÄÅAB¤g¥¦§¨©ª ¿ÀÁÂÃgìí&'6

Š#1'5ÕÖîV&'ïð6-ˆºÙÚÛ¼ÌÍçØ&'ñ¬ÇAB ò¯CDß#Jtón‘~ã'6W•Côõ7k;19S3-5 ôõ7¶ö;1'÷øù)ú]6-¤g¥¦§¨©ª ûü 9'

Ï·ýøÐ

¤g¥¦§©6/•–‰ÏŽÐ

M ÏÐ-’D-

ÏÐ ! !"#

(23)

参照

関連したドキュメント

zone: EEZ)と大陸棚に対する主権国家(沿岸国)の権利が拡充されてきたか

回収されないテクストへと向かう,一つの 「作業仮説」 (hypothèse de travail, Ar- beitshypothese) 10)

[r]

機体」 2 ) である。 「この町に国立国会図書館のような図書館

こういった「戦略マネジメント」や「組織マネジメント」を、さらに有効に機能させる

The right and publicness in historic landscape preservation by referring to a case study of cherry blossoms on a promenade of Shukugawa

管理・利用という問題と深く関わっている。ナ ショナル・トラストの意義は、商品化すべきで

かごしま生涯学習研究-大学と地域 第 1 ・ 2 号(2017年 3