• 検索結果がありません。

環境意識と生活観・自然観 : アジア3国での調査結果から 利用統計を見る

N/A
N/A
Info
ダウンロード
Protected

Academic year: 2021

シェア "環境意識と生活観・自然観 : アジア3国での調査結果から 利用統計を見る"

Copied!
37
0
0

読み込み中.... (全文を見る)

今ダウンロードする ( 37 ページ )

全文

(1)環境意識と生活観・自然観 : アジア3国での調査結 果から 著者名(日) 雑誌名 号 ページ 発行年 URL. 大島 尚 「エコ・フィロソフィ」研究 2 71-106 2008-03 http://doi.org/10.34428/00003384. Creative Commons : 表示 - 非営利 - 改変禁止 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/deed.ja.

(2)           .             . Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫ަ{{ޠظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r‫ޠ‬ ԭĊɚ‫  ۮ‬Ȳʟ ʇ ‫ޡޤ‬. \EkX.  Ӟȟǭ‫\ݡ‬%ĮöXUPSŵԅx˳tLk[ǍӘԀW‫؜‬Ɠ9%ԭĊŗĖXUPS‫ݎ‬ǍӘ ԀW֒ϰxlLrFU45%ԭĊԀÂÅ´[ϲ֏iTUr6rut@U9ȯ4&ԭĊԀ ÂÅ´T\%ԭĊŗĖXŵԅxlLrFq5WĮö[‫؜‬ƓxƧƇ‫؜‬ƓUDSĒֱR>% Įö9ŵԅx‫ۃ‬оFtq5W‫ݎ‬ƧƇ‫؜‬Ɠx͇ŷD%ƧƇ‫؜‬Ɠxʄ<@U9‫غ‬ц[Lk[ϧ Ą U B u t & ؐ î ‫ ޜ‬2003‫ \ ޝ‬% ԭ Ċ Ԁ   Š´ [ ‫ غ‬ц ժ x В ‫ ێ‬Ԁ Τ ӭ U ˻ Ә Ԁ Τ ӭ [ ‫ ޥ‬Շ ‫ݨ‬Xŭ>SЋ‫ؿ‬DS4t&В‫ێ‬ԀΤӭU\%ѕԀW‫ش‬ŷnŵԅ۴ŭ[D<iWV%ԭĊԀ WВ‫ێ‬xȫ‫ݐ‬Ft@UXqs‫غ‬цxʄ<l[T%LU6]À}‡Á[Lk[ž³šŸ ŷn%ȊӗѺτƚɾժUDSnjȄ9ƿs֏yT4t+ͨūЗ‫ޝ܁ޜ‬ƿ˘,[D<iWV\ @uXʓFtUֽ6rut&ÌΤ%˻ӘԀΤӭU\%Įö[‫؜‬Ɠx‫ش‬ɦDS4tĪ̄%̩ ˊ%‫ڂ‬ą̧%Ī‫ݠ‬%ۙ˸˻%‫˻ׯ‬WVXņ:8>t@UT%‫פ‬ӼԀWƧƇ‫؜‬Ɠx٘ӼFt l[T3t&Ӟȟǭ‫\ݡ‬%ö‫ܘ‬9ĤŵWӠџxоkS:L֒ϰUDSӠES4tl[T3 t@U8r%Įö[ӠџXɾFtėr8[‫ش‬ŷnȫ‫ݐ‬9˼‫ر‬UBut&J[ȜǍX%ѕԀ W‫ش‬ŷn%ΣLWŵԅ۴ŭΤ˖[ʄŖWV[В‫ێ‬ԀΤӭ[iT\‫ܥ‬Ө93s%ö([ٰ̤ xȫ6tq5W˻ӘԀΤӭ9˼‫ر‬UBut[T\W48U̇wut&  Įö[Ӟȟĩ‫؜ٵ‬Ɠx٘ӼFtLkX\%BhChWӄё‫ر‬Ǿ[‫ل‬ɦ9˼‫ر‬T3t&L U6]%Ӟȟǭ‫[ݡ‬ɪ̩xӘ‫غ‬Ft@U%Įö[Ӡџ9ӞȟXƺfF˧‫ݒ‬xԝt@U%Ӟ ȟĩ‫؜ٵ‬Ɠ[ɪ‫؜‬XɾDS҃‫̧ڙ‬9UlW4%ɪ‫؜‬DW4@UXɾDŞְ̗9UlW5 @U%ü‫־‬lǏГX‫؜‬ƓFtU45Ī‫̧ݠ‬x͝Q@UWV93?ruq5&D8D%ӄё ‫ر‬Ǿ[‫ل‬ɦ9Əϰx͝QLkX\%Įö[͝QĢij‫ظ‬c[۴̯l˼‫ر‬UBut&ɫ‫ظ‬ԀX \۟ŮW‫؜‬ƓT3PLUDSl%Ģij‫ظ‬UԍɱuW4q5W‫؜‬ƓxĦF@UX\Ȁ݁9ç ̢But&jDv%Ģij‫ظ‬x͆͸DLÒT%JuX́EL‫؜‬Ɠȫɱxʄ<@U9ƏϰԀT 3 t U ֽ 6 r u t &L M D %Į ö [ Ģ ij ‫ \ ظ‬%Ȅ n и Χ %Ӡ ‫ ב‬Ӟ ȟ W V X q s ȯ Г T 3 t & Ģij‫[ظ‬ԢՒX‫ܙ‬DS\‫@ޟ‬uhTXȯ<[Ȅܵж‫[ګ‬٠ϹžÉ—9؉ՌBuS:L& hL%‫ذ‬њԀWĢij‫ظ‬UϪњԀWĢij‫ۛ[ظ‬4U4PL‫ص‬Ҧ8r[‫ٳ‬٥lȯ<WBuS: L&Ӟȟǭ‫ݡ‬U[‫ۏܙ‬T\‫ذޟ‬њԀWĢij‫ظ‬XlUR<Խɚn֑ѵ9˘:‫@ڕ‬DLUFt Ü˞l3t&ÌΤT‫ڼޟ‬ʼ[Ӟȟǭ‫ݡ‬XQ4S[‫ٳ‬٥T\‫֑ޟ‬ѵԀWӼʒx֘>t{{ [Ȅ(9—ÉŠšŸUDSٙrutȜǍ9ȯ<WPS7s%{{٨Ȅ[ø˯[Ӽʒ[3 sΤ9‫ޟ‬ˡ‫[ݏ‬ȊӗӞȟǭ‫<؜[ݡ‬ϜxʬNJFt[T\W48U‫ؼ‬wuS4t& @[q5W‫ג‬ο[lUX%ϝԢՒT\%{{[ö([ӞȟXɾFtĢij‫ظ‬XҪҦxˡ S‫ޟ‬Ӟȟc[ٰ̤UӠџXɾFtֽ6Τ%‫פ‬ҫ[‫س‬ΤWV[‫ܙ[ܘ‬ĥx%٠Ϲ֒ϰ[ŭϭ 8rαr8XFt@UxԊԀUDS4t&ɾ‫ٺ‬ȄUDSÅ„³ÉÁ%ÛȄ%Ϊϝ[ަȄ xۣ`%ǏE‫ڐ‬ǭŠɱXɾFtǽթ8r%ަȄXś‫ی‬DS‫س‬rutŅǑU%ȄXqsӯW tŅǑXQ4SЋ‫ؿ‬D%Ӟȟǭ‫غݡ‬цc[տǂxQ8j@UxԊ͞DL&. 71.

(3)     . ‫ޡޥ‬.     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. ٠Ϲ[Τѕ.  ϝ Ԣ Ւ \ %Ȳ ʟ‫ ޜ‬2007‫ޝ‬9  Å „ ³ É Á x ɾ ‫ ٺ‬Ȋ ȓ U D S 2007 ʼ 1 ϒ 8 r 2 ϒ X 8 > S ‫؜‬PL٠ϹUǏE٠Ϲ‫ݖ‬ԊxӢ4S%ÛȄUΪϝxɾ‫ٺ‬X‫؜‬PL٠Ϲ[֒ϰXlUR:% Å„³ÉÁ[٠ϹžÉ—UǍwHSŭϭx‫؜‬5l[T3t&Å„³ÉÁ٠Ϲ[ΤѕU ܼ‫֒ؾ‬ϰXQ4S\FTXțǚDS4t[T%@@T\Џ‫ر‬XUVkt& ‫ޡޤޠޥ‬ń³ÉÁ٠Ϲ  ٠ϹȊȓ\Å„³ÉÁŗȇ&͈ԴƝx͐ūDL˯XĔʎxˢ̩ŴX͐ūD%¦É‘ž } ѕ‫ ޜ‬J [ ɰ [ ɰ Χ [ Û T ٗ Ӡ Ϊ 9 l P U l ϑ ‫ ڼ‬X 3 P L ö x ͐ ū ‫ޝ‬X q s ɾ ‫ ־ ٺ‬x Ӏ ɦ &  Å ­ Á Θ \ 1037 ö ‫ ޜ‬ӥ ̉ 500 ö % ȿ ̉ 537 ö ‫&ޝ‬ ‫ޡޥޠޥ‬ÛȄ٠Ϲ  ٠ϹȊȓ\ÒѨ%ϩʨ%ؑʨUDL&ÒѨ\%‫ڼ‬ʼÛȄ[ÛTlUsw>֑ѵӼʒ9؅ D < %Ǐ μ X Ȳ й р Ϸ W V [ Ӟ ȟ ǭ ‫ ݡ‬9 ј Ԋ B u S 4 t Ȋ ȓ T 3 t &h L %ϩ ʨ U ؑ ʨ \ % ÒѨX‫ڼ‬4@U8r֑ѵӼʒ[˧‫ݒ‬xǀ>W9rl%ǃ<8r‫ݪ‬œαɏWȇȊUDSԝr uS7s%ÒѨU[ж‫ګ‬Tėr8[Ӏ˹9‫س‬ūButLJ‫̉ז‬l3tUֽ6L&  ٠Ϲ\%ҩěҧ͐ūѕXqsɾ‫־ٺ‬xۣ`%‫ك‬ǭ‫ͭݏ‬ѕXqsɪΦDL&hGɾ‫ٺ‬Ȋȓ x 500޾ 1000 [ Ȋ ȓ X ŭ > %˼ ‫ ر‬W  Å ­ Á Θ‫ ޜ‬Ò Ѩ 500%ϩ ʨ 300%ؑ ʨ 200‫ޝ‬x l U X njȊȓ[Å­Á¼¢šŸx͐ūDL&ОX%͐ūBuLnjÅ­Á¼¢šŸŠX3t× ʵx%ҩěҧW‘—ÉŸ³}ş8rҩěҧW}ŗɦÁTۣ`%ãΘ‫آ‬xĞPS٠Ϲ LJ ‫ ז‬W ɾ ‫ ־ ٺ‬x × ʵ 8 r ͐ ū D L & ‫ ڐ‬ǭ ‫ ݖ‬Ԋ \ % Ȳ ʟ ‫ ޜ‬2007‫ ޝ‬X ț ǚ B u S 4 t ´ Å ˜ À Åٙ[٠ϹԴUǽթӢƒÉ X҅ELl[xĞӢD%ÛȄ[ɪ̙XǍwHSīФDLʓ̉ ‫ݖ‬ԊxƉ6L&  ٠ Ϲ ɾ ‫ \ ־ ٺ‬20 Щ ޾ 64 Щ [ ӥ ȿ T % Ǎ ‫  ؾ‬Å ­ Á Θ \ 1000 ö ‫ ޜ‬ӥ ̉ 500 ö % ȿ ̉ 500 ö ‫ ޝ‬U D % 2007 ʼ 6 ϒ X ɪ Φ D L & ‫ޡަޠޥ‬Ϊϝ٠Ϲ  ٠ Ϲ Ȋ ȓ \ Ը ʘ ʲ U D L & Ը ʘ ʲ \ % ö ǂ ւ 140 Ï [ {  { x þ ‫ آ‬F t Ȳ ۲ ʲ T %  Å „³ÉÁnÒѨȲ۲ʲȅUǏГ[ӞȟΎժxͯ‫ۑ‬DS4t@U8r%žÉ—xж‫ګ‬Ft[ X۲Ǎ9q4UųΡDL&  ٠ϹT\%hGɾ‫ٺ‬UFtʲƝӦϥxҩěҧXۣ`%ĔиȖϝLjʷ8rҩěҧX͞ɦB u L ի ̼ x ‫ ڕ‬Ҧ U D S % ̼ ɦ [ ͐ ū ‫ ܳ ܘ‬x 7 4 S ٠ Ϲ ɾ ‫ ٺ‬X ْ ˡ F t ʼ ‫ ҃ ޜ ޖ‬20 Щ Ā Ò ‫ޝ‬ [ ӥ ȿ Į ö x ͐ ū D L &ɾ ‫ ٺ‬Θ \ %‫ ޤ‬Ȋ Ҧ 3 L s ւ 45 ǐ U D L &͐ ū B u L ɾ ‫ [ ־ ٺ‬Ĕ ̼ зǐզx‫قک‬D%٠ϹǦ9ĮŴX+AƧƇ[7‫ݦ‬4,[٠Ϲġ‫ݠ‬ΜUUlX‫ك‬ǭDS‫ͭݏ‬ ٠Ϲx‫؜‬PL&  ٠ Ϲ ɾ ‫ \ ־ ٺ‬%20 Щ Ā Ò [ ӥ ȿ ‫ ؾ‬400 ö‫ ޜ‬ӥ ̉ 192 ö %ȿ ̉ 208 ö ‫ޝ‬T %2007 ʼ 5 ϒ X ɪ Φ D L & ٠ Ϲ ‫ ݖ‬Ԋ \ % Ȳ ʟ ‫ ޜ‬2007‫ ޝ‬X ‫ ڬ ق‬B u S 4 t Ϊ ϝ ٙ ‫ ݖ‬Ԋ x l U X D S % Ì ‫ ۮ‬ī ФxƉ6tUUlXʓ̉‫ݖ‬Ԋx‫ۃ‬ƉDLl[T3t&ϝ٥Μ[ʱϜX‫ډ‬Ο‫ޥ‬UDS٠ϹԴ xͱ‫ڬ‬DL& 72.

(4)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . ަ‫ޡ‬. ֒ϰ. ަ‫ޡޤޠ‬Ӟȟǭ‫ٰٕ[ݡ‬  Ӟȟǭ‫ݡ‬XɾFtٰٕx%‫̉رۿ‬UƮЛٰ̤X‫ܙ‬Ft‫ڐ‬ǭXɾFtǽթ8r٠dL& Ì- © ‚ K p » L + / I @ J G C E H K 7 U 0  · I | Ç F < 4 ,.  Ì- © ‚  ˜ L / I @ µ ¿ K r  J H K ¯ Œ  Æ Y y O ; E 0 W G ‘ 0 P < 4 ,. . ֒ ϰ x Ȃ 3.1 7 q ` Ȃ 3.2 X ԫ F & ‫ ̉ ر ۿ‬X Q 4 S \ %+ ‫ ݎ‬ʸ X ‫ ر ۿ‬T 3 t , U + ‫ ر ۿ‬T 3 t ,x Ǎ w H t U %4 G u [ Ȅ X 7 4 S l 95‫ ޚ‬Ā Ò x Ƭ k S 7 s %e U y V [ ö ( 9 ‫ر ۿ‬ ̉xٰٕDS4t@U9w8t&hL%ƮЛٰ̤XQ4Sl%‫[ڣפ‬ĻˍX+‫ݎ‬ʸX˧‫ݒ‬ 9 3 t , U + n n ˧ ‫ ݒ‬9 3 t , x Ǎ w H t U %  Å „ ³ É Á T 72.2‫ ޚ‬% Û Ȅ T 98.3‫ ޚ‬% Ϊ ϝ T 80.3‫ ޚ‬U % 4 G u [ Ȝ Ǎ l ‫ < ބ‬% Ӏ X Û Ȅ X 7 4 S ‫ ݤ‬؅ X ‫ ބ‬4 @ U 9 w 8 t & Û Ȅ [ ަȊȓxж‫ګ‬DSlʮ\‫س‬ruG%ƮЛٰ̤\ÌГX‫ބ‬4@U9ԫBuL&. Ȃ 3 .1 Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫         ٰ ̤ [ ̉ ر ۿ [ ٵ‬Ȃ 3.2  Ӟ ȟ р Ϸ [ Ļ ˍ c [ ˧ ‫ٰ ̤ [ ݒ‬. ަ‫ޡޥޠ‬Ӟȟĩ‫ٵ‬c[̩ˊU‫؜‬Ɠ̤Ȃ  4Gu[ȄX74Sl%Ӟȟĩ‫̉رۿ[ٵ‬x˟<ٰٕDS4t@U9w8PL9%Ӟȟ ĩ‫ٵ‬c[̩ˊn‫؜‬Ɠ̤ȂxV[Մˊ͝PS4t[8xĀÓ[‫ڐ‬ǭXɾFtǽթ8r‫س‬L& Ì- € § © ‚ G µ s @ B K ª ¡ G K Å o J D 0 E + [ G \ K Î D K “ ¸ 5 / V P < , / I @ K 3 œ – B L H B U J À 0 F < 4 ,É [ Ê µ s @ B K ª ¡ 5 l T V j n J I C E S + € § © ‚ Y ‡ W @ R J M G V M G V 5 w u < W N 6 A ,É \ Ê µ s @ B K ª ¡ Y + T V n t J < W 9 G Y ³ 2 W N 6 A ,.  Ì- / I @ L + q › K È 0 { ¥ F S © ‚ Y ‡ W @ R I U ¼ 3 1 G ‘ 0 P < 4 ,. . Q8 \ %Ӡ џ [ Ĥ ŵ B x Ӂ ҿ X D S T l Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬x ō Œ F d : 8 V 5 8 [ ̩ ˊ x ʃ Z L ‫ ڐ‬ǭ T 3 s % Ȃ 3.3 X ԫ F q 5 X Ȅ X q P S ‫ ۛ [ ʺ ״‬4 9 ‫ س‬r u % Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬ō Œ [ Ƅ Ǎ \ %  Å „ ³ É Á 54.0‫ ޚ‬% Û Ȅ 74.2‫ ޜ ޚ‬Ò Ѩ 71.2‫ ޚ‬% ϩ ʨ 74.3‫ ޚ‬% ؑ ʨ 81.5‫ޝ ޚ‬% Ϊ ϝ 89.0‫ ޚ‬U W P S 4 t &h L %Q11 \ Ş Ė Ԁ W ‫ ؜ څ ڒ‬Ɠ [ ̤ Ȃ x ʃ Z L l [ T %Ȃ 3.4 X ԫ F q 5 X % +FFyT‫څ‬75U̇5,U+3tՄˊ\‫څ‬75U̇5,xǍwHLƄǍ\%Å„³É Á 46.5‫ ޚ‬% Û Ȅ 58.4‫ ޜ ޚ‬Ò Ѩ 52.8‫ ޚ‬% ϩ ʨ 57.7‫ ޚ‬% ؑ ʨ 73.5‫ޝ ޚ‬% Ϊ ϝ 65.6‫ ޚ‬U W P S 4 73.

(5)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. t&4Gu[ȜǍXl%Ϊϝ9lPUlՌЍԀW‫؜‬Ɠ̤ȂxԫDS7s%ĀÓÛȄ%Å „ ³ É Á [ ‫ ݗ‬X W P S 4 t 9 %Û Ȅ [ ؑ ʨ \ Ӏ X ‫ ބ‬4 ij x ԫ D S 4 t @ U 9 Ӏ ˹ Ԁ T 3 t & @ u r [ ֒ ϰ 9 % Ӡ џ [ ‫ ث‬Ը B x ƽ ε D S 4 t LJ ‫ \ ̉ ז‬3 t 9 % Ȃ 3. X ԫ B u S 4 t Û Ȅ[ž¸ˆ¿«|š‡ÈžÉ—X8rǽթ‫[־‬ϒƾx‫س‬t‫ܥ‬s%ؑʨ[ϒƾ9ӀX‫ބ‬4U 45ŅǑ\‫س‬ruW4&. Ȃ 3 .3 Ӡ џ [ Ĥ ŵ B U Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ؜ [ ٵ‬Ɠ ̤ Ȃ         Ȃ 3.4  Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬U ‫ ̤ څ ڒ‬Ȃ.  Ӡџ[ĤŵBqslӞȟĩ‫ٵ‬xōŒFt̩ˊ9%‫؜څڒ‬Ɠ[̤ȂU‫ܙ‬ĥDS4t8V5 8 x ‫ س‬t L k X % Q11 X ɾ F t ǽ թ X Q 4 S + F F y T ‫ څ‬7 5 U ̇ 5 , 8 r + ‫ څ‬4 L < W 4 ,h T X 5 Ҧ 8 r 1 Ҧ x Ƅ s ˡ S S ˳ Ҧ ƚ D %Q8 X ɾ F t ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ǽ թ A U X ˳ Ҧ [ ʻ Ȍ ij x ж ‫ ګ‬D L ֒ ϰ x ‫ آ‬3.1 X ԫ F &  Å „ ³ É Á % Û Ȅ % Ϊ ϝ [ F d S X 7 4 S ϓ ̤ W ʮ 9 ‫ س‬r u %Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬x ō Œ F t ̩ ˊ x ͝ Q ö [ Τ 9 % + F F y T ‫ ބ‬4 ǥ Ҿ x ‫ څ‬5 ,̤ Ȃ x ͝ QŅǑ93t@U9ԫBuL& ‫ آ‬3 .1 Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬8 Ӡ џ [ Ĥ ŵ B 8 [ ̩ ˊ X ɾ F t ‫ ̤ څ ڒ‬Ȃ [ ж ‫ګ‬ =@<>A? (,& .-/$.  '(,.  . ,.  ; :6985: -/)' /#0-./-0$"00'$&*-! *$,2(/-,+$,0. . . . 

(6) ;85:47;3:  )$ -1/ *(%$ +-/$ "-,2$,($,0. . . . ‫  ޜ‬Å „ ³ É Á ޭ t(965)=7.161, p<.01 % Û Ȅ ޭ t(979)=2.939 , p <.01% Ϊ ϝ ޭ t(389)=4 .579, p< .01‫ޝ‬.  ǏГX%Ӡџ[ĤŵBqslӞȟĩ‫ٵ‬xōŒFt̩ˊ9%Ӟȟĩ‫ٰ̤[̉رۿ[ٵ‬U‫ܙ‬ ĥ D S 4 t 8 V 5 8 x ٠ d t L k X %Q9 X ɾ F t ǽ թ X Q 4 S+ ‫ ݎ‬ʸ X ‫ ر ۿ‬T 3 t ,8 r + ‫ ر ۿ‬T \ W 4 ,h T X 4 Ҧ 8 r 1 Ҧ x Ƅ s ˡ S S ˳ Ҧ ƚ D %Q8 X ɾ F t ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ǽ թ A U X ˳ Ҧ [ ʻ Ȍ ij x ж ‫ ګ‬D L ֒ ϰ x ‫ آ‬3.2 X ԫ F & @ [ Ȝ Ǎ X l %  Å „ ³ É Á % Û Ȅ % Ϊ ϝ[FdSX74Sϓ̤Wʮ9‫س‬ru%Ӟȟĩ‫ٵ‬xōŒFt̩ˊx͝Qö[Τ9%Ӟȟǭ ‫ݡ‬x+‫رۿ‬T3t,ṲٰDS4tŅǑ93t@U9ԫBuL& 74.

(7)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r             ‫ آ‬3 .2 Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬8 Ӡ џ [ Ĥ ŵ B 8 [ ̩ ˊ X ɾ F t Ӟ ȟ ǭ ‫ٰ ̤ [ ̉ ر ۿ [ ݡ‬ >A=?B@ )-'!/.0%.  ()-!. !/!-.  < ;7:96; .0*(!0$1./0.1%#11(%'+."!+%-3)0.-,%-1. . . . 

(8) <96;58<4; !*% .20 +)&% ,.0% #.-3%-)%-1. . . . ‫  ޜ‬Å „ ³ É Á ޭ t(978)=5.605, p<.01 % Û Ȅ ޭ t(993)=5.883 , p <.01% Ϊ ϝ ޭ t(388)=3 .571, p< .01‫ޝ‬.  Ā Ò [ q 5 X %Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٰ ̤ [ ̉ ر ۿ [ ٵ‬%7 q ` Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ [ ٵ‬L k [ Ş Ė Ԁ W ‫ ؜‬Ɠ ̤ Ȃ \ % Ӡџ[ĤŵBxōŒFt8Ӟȟĩ‫ٵ‬xōŒFt8[̩ˊXqPSӯWt@U9ԫBuL& ަ‫ޡަޠ‬Ӟȟĩ‫ٵ‬U֑ѵӼʒ  ֑ѵ9ӼʒFt@UXqsӞȟԣȥ9‫ۑ‬j[T\W48U45Ʈ̠9%‫ڼ‬ʼӀX{{ [Ȅ(XɾDSǑ>ruS4t&ɪܵ%ΪϝX7>třɯǭ‫ݡ‬9%֑ѵ[‫ܓ̴ˊބ‬XUl WPSӠEL@U\‫̳ق‬XΣD<%‫ڼ‬ʼ[ÛȄ[̈‫ۍ‬W֑ѵ̴‫ܓ‬9%ǏГ[ӞȟрϷxl LrDQQ3t@U9D]D]ƿsщфBuS4t&J@T%֑ѵӼʒUӞȟԣȥU[‫ܙ‬ ĥXQ4S[ٰ̤%7q`ɑɛ[LkX֑ѵӼʒUӞȟĩ‫[ٵ‬VNrx‫صرۿ‬Ft8[̩ ˊxʃZL[9ĀÓ[‫ڐ‬ǭT3t&  

(9) Ì- ± ¢ ¬ Š L ‹ J © ‚ ® ƒ Y G S I 1 ,.    Ì- 9 K [ G \ K Î D K “ ¸ K 1 B + / I @ K 3 œ – B L H B U K “ ¸ J À 0 F < 4 ,É [ Ê † K @ R J L + ± ¢ ¬ Š 5 „ ‰ Á X E S + l / W µ ¤ Y F 6 W A 8 š < N 6 A ,É \ Ê † K @ R J L + µ ¤ 5 „ ‰ ® ƒ : X E S + l K ± ¢ Y F 6 W A 8 ¬ Š : > W N 6 A ,. . ֒ ϰ x Ȃ 3.5 U Ȃ 3.6 X ԫ F &Q12-6 X ɾ D S+ ‫ ̴ ڋ‬,U+ V N r 8 U 4 6 ] ‫ ̴ ڋ‬,x Ǎ w H L Ƅ Ǎ \ % Å „ ³ É Á 50.0‫ ޚ‬%Û Ȅ 62.4‫ ޜޚ‬Ò Ѩ 53.2‫ ޚ‬%ϩ ʨ 70.3‫ ޚ‬%73.5‫ޝ ޚ‬%Ϊ ϝ 60.8‫ ޚ‬U W P S 4 t & h L % Q17 T + ֑ ѵ Ӽ ʒ q s ‫ פ‬ҫ x Ю F d : , U ǽ թ D L ö [ Ƅ Ǎ \ %  Å „ ³ É Á 9 67.2‫ ޚ‬% Û Ȅ 9 82.2‫ ޜ ޚ‬Ò Ѩ 82.8‫ ޚ‬% ϩ ʨ 83.0‫ ޚ‬% ؑ ʨ 79.5‫ޝ ޚ‬% Ϊ ϝ 9 94.5‫ ޚ‬T 3 t &. Ȃ 3 .5 ֑ ѵ Ӽ ʒ U Ӟ ȟ ԣ ȥ        Ȃ 3 .6  ‫ פ‬ҫ x Ю F 8 ֑ ѵ x Ӽ ʒ B H t 8 75.

(10)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. ſհTƿsÒ?L%Ӡџ[ĤŵBqslӞȟĩ‫ٵ‬xōŒFt̩ˊ9%֑ѵӼʒUӞȟԣ ȥ U [ ‫ ܙ‬ĥ X Q 4 S [ ̤ ٰ U ‫ ܙ‬ĥ D S 4 t 8 V 5 8 x ٠ d t L k X % Q12-6 X ɾ F t ǽ թ X Q 4 S+ ‫ ̴ ڋ‬,8 r+ ƽ ɾ ,h T X 5 Ҧ 8 r 1 Ҧ h T x Ƅ s ˡ S S ˳ Ҧ ƚ D %Q8 X ɾ F t ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ǽ թ A U X ˳ Ҧ [ ʻ Ȍ ij x ж ‫ ګ‬D L ֒ ϰ x ‫ آ‬3.3 X ԫ F &  Å „ ³ É Á U Û Ȅ X 74Sϓ̤Wʮ9‫س‬ruL9%ΪϝT\ϓ̤ʮ9‫س‬ruW8PL&Ϊϝ[ȜǍX\%Å ­ Á Θ 9 n n ʆ W 4 @ U U % Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬x ō Œ F t ̩ ˊ x ͝ Q ö [ Ƅ Ǎ 9 ‫ ބ‬4 ‫ ޜ‬89.0‫@ ޝ ޚ‬ Ul%֕‫ؾ‬ԀWʮxlLrBW8PL‫ر‬ǾUDSֽ6rut& ‫ آ‬3 .3 Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬8 Ӡ џ [ Ĥ ŵ B 8 [ ̩ ˊ X ɾ F t ֑ ѵ Ӽ ʒ U Ӟ ȟ ԣ ȥ [ ‫ ܙ‬ĥ X Q 4 S [ ̤ ٰ <?;=@> '+%-,.#.  &'+. -+.  : 958749 ,.(&."/,-.,/#!//&#%), )#+1'.,+*#+/. . . . 

(11) :74936:29 (# ,0. )'$# *,.# !,+1#+'#+/. . . . ‫  ޜ‬Å „ ³ É Á ޭ t(970)=5.899, p<.01 % Û Ȅ ޭ t(989)=3.743 , p <.01% Ϊ ϝ ޭ t(388)= .863, n .s.‫ޝ‬.  W 7 % Q17 X ɾ F t ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ǽ թ X Q 4 S % J u K u A U X ֑ ѵ Ӽ ʒ U Ӟ ȟ ԣ ȥ U [ ‫ ܙ‬ĥ X Q 4 S [ ̤ ٰ [ ˳ Ҧ x ж ‫ ګ‬D L U @ v %4 G u [ Ȅ X 7 4 S l ϓ ̤ ʮ \ ‫ س‬r u W 8 P L & h L %Q17 X ɾ F t Q9‫ ޜ‬Ӟ ȟ ǭ ‫ ˳ [ޝ ̉ ر ۿ [ ݡ‬Ҧ [ ʻ Ȍ T \ % Å „ ³ É Á [ i T+ ‫פ‬ ҫxЮFd:,UǽթDLö[Τ9‫ٰ̤[̉رۿ‬9ϓ̤X‫ބ‬8PL9%ÛȄUΪϝT\ϓ ̤ ʮ 9 ‫ س‬r u W 8 P L & Q17 X ɾ F t Q11‫ ޜ‬Ӟ ȟ x ɟ t L k W r ‫ ބ‬4 ǥ Ҿ T l ‫ څ‬5 ‫˳ [ ޝ‬ Ҧ[ʻȌT\%Å„³ÉÁUΪϝT+‫פ‬ҫxЮFd:,UǽթDLö[Τ9‫ބ‬4ǥҾ[ ‫ ̤ څ ڒ‬Ȃ 9 ϓ ̤ X ‫ ބ‬8 P L &֒ ϰ 9 α Ԥ T W 4 Ә Ӥ U D S % + ɑ ɛ [ L k X ,U 4 5 ϧ Ą 9 % Ӟȟǭ‫ٰٕ[ݡ‬UԌͭX֒`Q8W8PLLJ‫̉ז‬9ԫǨBut ަ‫פޡާޠ‬ҫ‫ظ‬UӞȟٰ̤  Ӟȟǭ‫ٳ[ݡ‬٥T\% + ö ‫ ܘ‬9 ԣ ȥ D L ‫ פ‬ҫ \ Ŏ X ̺ r W 4 ,U 4 5 Ü ˞ 9 ‫ ر ۿ‬W Ē ֱ x ƬktȜǍ9ȯ4&D8D%@u\ö‫[ܘ‬ǶiU‫פ‬ҫU[‫ܙ‬ĥXQ4S[ٰٕ%3t4\ ö([‫פ‬ҫ‫ظ‬X‫ܙ‬ĥFt@U9rUlֽ6rut&J@T%ĀÓ[‫ڐ‬ǭXɾFtǽթxЋ ‫ؿ‬DSit@UXFt&   Ì- @ G 2 k Ä J T C E µ ¤ 5 ® ƒ : X @ G ; E S + µ ¤ L µ U K u F }  F 6 W ,. . ܼ ‫ ֒ [ ؾ‬ϰ \ Ȃ 3.7 [ U 7 s T 3 t & + ‫ ̴ ڋ‬,U+ V N r 8 U 4 6 ] ‫ ̴ ڋ‬,[ ǽ թ x Ǎ w H L Ƅ Ǎ x ‫ س‬t U %  Å „ ³ É Á 9 38.8‫ ޚ‬% Û Ȅ 9 29.0‫ ޜ ޚ‬Ò Ѩ 29.6‫ ޚ‬% ϩ ʨ 23.7‫ ޚ‬% ؑ ʨ 35.5‫ޝ ޚ‬%Ϊ ϝ 12.8‫ ޚ‬U W P S 4 t &@ [ ǽ թ \ %Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ˊ ̩ [ ٵ‬X ɾ F t ‫ ݖ ک ۇ‬Ԋ X W P S4tUֽ6rut9%ӀXΪϝT‫[̴ڋ‬ƄǍ9ʆW4@U9ŭ8t& ОX%@uhTUǏГX%Ӡџ[ĤŵBqslӞȟĩ‫ٵ‬xōŒFt̩ˊ9%‫פ‬ҫXɾF t ̤ ٰ U ‫ ܙ‬ĥ F t 8 V 5 8 x ‫ س‬t L k X % Q19-3 [ ǽ թ X Q 4 S + ‫ ̴ ڋ‬, 8 r + ƽ ɾ , h T X 5 Ҧ 8 r 1 Ҧ h T x Ƅ s ˡ S S ˳ Ҧ ƚ D %Q8 X ɾ F t ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ǽ թ A U X ˳ Ҧ [ ʻ Ȍ ij x ж ‫ ګ‬D L ֒ ϰ 9 ‫ آ‬3.4 T 3 t &  Å „ ³ É Á U Û Ȅ X 7 4 S ϓ ̤ ʮ 9 ‫ س‬r u % ŗ Ė X Ӟ 76.

(12)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . ȟĩ‫ٵ‬xōŒFt̩ˊx͝Qö[Τ9% ‫פ‬ҫ9‫פ‬rǽ˵FtU45ֽ6XƽɾF tŅǑ93t@U9ԫBuL&  h L % Q17 [ + ɑ ɛ [ L k X \ ‫ פ‬ҫ x ЮFd:8֑ѵxӼʒBHtd:8,[ ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ǽ թ X ɾ F t Q19-3 [ ˳ Ҧ [ ʻ Ȍ ij x ж ‫ ګ‬D L [ 9 ‫ آ‬3.5 T 3 t & @ [ Ȝ Ǎl%Å„³ÉÁUÛȄX74Sϓ̤ ʮ9ٕkru%‫פ‬ҫxЮFd:U45̩ ˊx͝Qö[Τ9%‫פ‬ҫ9‫פ‬rǽ˵Ft U45ֽ6XƽɾFtŅǑ9‫س‬ruL& Ȃ 3 .7 ‫ פ‬ҫ [ ǽ ˵ X Q 4 S [ ̤ ٰ. ‫ آ‬3 .4 Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬8 Ӡ џ [ Ĥ ŵ B 8 [ ̩ ˊ X ɾ F t ‫ פ‬ҫ [ ǽ ˵ X Q 4 S [ ̤ ٰ >A=?B@ )-'!/.0%.  ()-!. !/!-.  < ;7:96; .0*(!0$1./0.1%#11(%'+."!+%-3)0.-,%-1. . . . 

(13) <96;58<4; !*% .20 +)&% ,.0% #.-3%-)%-1. . . . ‫  ޜ‬Å „ ³ É Á ޭ t(962)=5.316, p<.01 % Û Ȅ ޭ t(987)=4.046 , p <.01% Ϊ ϝ ޭ t(388)=1 .104, n .s.‫ޝ‬. ‫ آ‬3 .5 ɑ ɛ [ L k X ֑ ѵ x Ӽ ʒ B H t 8 ‫ פ‬ҫ x Ю F 8 [ ̩ ˊ X ɾ F t ‫ פ‬ҫ [ ǽ ˵ X Q 4 S [ ̤ ٰ 9<8:=;  #%$&.   #.  %#. ,6

(14) 705&'&* #()&. . . . 4 73-62. /165*!$% $)& )&&#( $#$"+. . . . ‫  ޜ‬Å „ ³ É Á ޭ t(879)=3.969, p<.01 % Û Ȅ ޭ t(985)=6.909 , p <.01% Ϊ ϝ ޭ t(391)= .214, n .s.‫ޝ‬.  @ur[֒ϰ8r%Ӟȟĩ‫ˊ̩[ٵ‬X\%‫פ‬ҫ9_UL`ԣȥButUʁϨXwLPS ǽ ˵ T : W 4 [ T \ W 4 8 U 4 5 Ʈ Л ̧ 9 ‫ ܙ‬Õ D S 4 t LJ ‫ ̉ ז‬9 ԫ Ǩ B u t &‫ ۇ‬X ‫ ؼ‬6 ] % ‫פ‬ҫ\4Guǽ˵FtU45ٰٕ9%ӞȟqslӠџ[ĤŵBxōŒFt̩ˊxƋ‫ܓ‬DS 4tUlֽ6rut& ަ‫‹ޡިޠ‬µ»¢|UӞȟǭ‫ݡ‬  Ӟȟǭ‫\ٰٕ[ݡ‬%ȊӗӞȟU4PLȲ:W‘‰ÉÁ8r%ĔyT4tȊȓ[‫ڼڣ‬WӞ ȟX4LthT%BhChW¯ÁTUr6t@U9T:t&JDS%‫[҄ډ‬հւnÀ }‡Á‫؜‬ƓU4PLĮö¯Á[Ӟȟĩ‫؜ٵ‬Ɠ\%ȊȓxȖԉUFtļ‫ݏ‬9Ȳ:4Uֽ6 77.

(15)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. rut&J@T%Ȋȓ‹µ»¢|X‫ܙ‬Ftٰ̤UӞȟĩ‫ˊ̩[ٵ‬U[‫ܙ‬ĥx‫س‬t@UX DL&hG%Ȋȓ[‫פ‬ҫӞȟUɦĔ˿ǑXQ4SʃZLĀÓ[‫ڐ‬ǭXɾFtǽթx‫س‬Si t@UXFt&   Ì- / I @ K m Z F 0 W €  K µ ¤ © ‚ K ¦ ” J D 0 E H 1 ‘ 0 P < 4 ,.   

(16) Ì- / I @ L + 9 X 4 U S = C G 9 K €  J m Q ² 8 @ 0 G ‘ 0 P < 4 + ? X G S 0 D 4 Ž C ¾ ? 1 G ‘ 0 P < 4 ,. . ֒ ϰ x Ȃ 3.8 U Ȃ 3.9 X ԫ F &Ĕ y T 4 t Ȋ ȓ [ ‫ פ‬ҫ Ӟ ȟ X Q 4 S % + ‫ ׯ‬4 ,U+ n n ‫ ׯ‬4 , [ ǽ թ x Ǎ w H L Ƅ Ǎ \ %  Å „ ³ É Á 90.5‫ ޚ‬% Û Ȅ 69.5‫ ޜ ޚ‬Ò Ѩ 62.8‫ ޚ‬% ϩ ʨ 78.3‫ ޚ‬% ؑ ʨ 73.0‫ޝ ޚ‬% Ϊ ϝ 70.1‫ ޚ‬T % nj Ȅ U l ‫ פ‬ŭ [ Ĕ y T 4 t Ȋ ȓ [ ‫ פ‬ҫ Ӟ ȟ X ɾ D S \ Ɂ ̤ ԀXUr6S4tŅǑ9‫س‬rut&ÌΤ%ǏEȊȓX@u8rlĔi֘>L4UǽթDL ö [ Ƅ Ǎ \ % Å „ ³ É Á 9 55.2‫ ޚ‬%Û Ȅ 9 35.7‫ ޜޚ‬Ò Ѩ 30.6‫ ޚ‬%ϩ ʨ 44.7‫ ޚ‬%ؑ ʨ 35.0‫ޝ ޚ‬% Ϊ ϝ 9 71.5‫ ޚ‬T % Û Ȅ [ ö ( [ ɦ Ĕ ˿ Ǒ 9 n n ē < W P S 4 t & О X % Ĕ y T 4 t Ȋ ȓ [ ‫פ‬ҫӞȟXɾFtǽթXQ4S+‫ׯ‬4,8r+̗4,hTX 4 Ҧ8r 1 ҦxƄsˡS%Ǐ EȊȓXĔi֘>L4UǽթDLöU4Gu˘P‫ڗ‬DL4UǽթDLöXŭ>S%ʻȌij x ж ‫ ګ‬D L [ 9 ‫ آ‬3.6 T 3 t & ֒ ϰ 8 r w 8 t q 5 X % 4 G u [ Ȝ Ǎ l + Ĕ i ֘ > L 4 , UǽթDLö[Τ9%ĔyT4tȊȓ[‫פ‬ҫӞȟx+‫ׯ‬4,UٰٕDS4t@U9ԫBu S4t&FWwN%ĔyT4tȊȓ[‫פ‬ҫӞȟ[ٰٕUɦĔ˿ǑU9‫ܙ‬ĥDS4t@U9 ԫǨBut&. Ȃ 3 .8 Ĕ y T 4 t Ȋ ȓ [ ‫ פ‬ҫ Ӟ ȟ            Ȃ 3 .9 ɦ Ĕ ˿ Ǒ. ‫ آ‬3 .6 ɦ Ĕ ˿ Ǒ U Ĕ y T 4 t Ȋ ȓ [ ‫ פ‬ҫ Ӟ ȟ [ ٕ ٰ [ ‫ ܙ‬ĥ 584697  "!#.   .  ". ,213 +.) 

(17) '

(18) $%(

(19) 

(20) %$

(21) #.  .  .  . / -*0* 

(22) '

(23) !&.  .  .  . ‫  ޜ‬Å „ ³ É Á ޭ t(922)=4.637, p<.01 % Û Ȅ ޭ t(847)=5.206 , p <.01% Ϊ ϝ ޭ t(380)=4 .767, p< .01‫ޝ‬ 78.

(24)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            .  О X %‫ [ ̼ ڼ‬ö U [ Ī ‫ ܙ ݠ‬ĥ x ʃ Z L О [ ‫ ڐ‬ǭ X ɾ F t ǽ թ X Q 4 S Ћ ‫ ؿ‬F t &@ u \ % ӣ Û È Ȳ ʟ ‫ ޜ‬2006‫ ޝ‬9 ‹ µ » ¢  | ̤ ٰ [ ˟ B x ԫ F l [ U D S Ӣ 4 L • É  ¹ Á È ¹ ª—Á͞ЕXǕhut‫ݖ‬ԊT3t&•É¹ÁÈ ¹ª—ÁU\%Ȋȓ[ö([Ī‫ݠ‬%‫ش‬ ձ%£šŸÄɇXqPSˢ̴Butö‫ܙܘ‬ĥ[+‫ډ‬ϝ,T3s%ԭĊԀW‫ܙ‬ĥ[3sΤ x ‫ ؾ‬ѻ LJ ‫ ז‬W ͞ Е U D S U r 6 q 5 U F t l [ T 3 t ‫ ޜ‬Putnam‫ ޟ‬2000ޮ Ȳ ʟ ‫ ޟ‬2006‫&ޝ‬   Ì- / I @ 5 ~ C E 0 W — J + À • K k L / I @ Y v 8 E 7 X W G ‘ 0 P < 4 ,. . Ȃ 3.10 X nj Ȅ [ ֒ ϰ x ԫ F &+ U S l J 5 ̇ 5 , U + h 3 J 5 ̇ 5 , x Ǎ w H L Ƅ Ǎ \ %  Å „ ³ É Á 78.2‫ ޚ‬% Û Ȅ 88.7‫ ޜ ޚ‬Ò Ѩ 90.8‫ ޚ‬% ϩ ʨ 82.3‫ ޚ‬% ؑ ʨ 93.0‫ޝ ޚ‬% Ϊ ϝ 63.0‫ޚ‬ T 3 s %Ϊ ϝ T \ n n ē < W P S 4 t &@ [ ǽ թ X Q 4 S % + U S l J 5 ̇ 5 ,8 r+ J 5 ̇wW4,hTX 4 Ҧ8r 1 ҦxƄsˡSS˳ҦƚDLl[x%@@T\+‹µ»¢| ̤ ٰ [ ˟ B ,U ǟ b @ U X F t &Ȃ 3.11 \ %@ [ ‹ µ » ¢  | ̤ ٰ [ ˟ B x ӥ ȿ Ŵ X ‫ س‬L l[T3t&Ȃ8rw8tq5X%ΪϝT\ӥ̉[‹µ»¢|ٰ̤9Ѝ՟Xē4@U9 w8t&@u\lNvy%Ϊϝ[۲ʲ‫[ۮ‬Ӏ˹U45@U9T:t9%۲ʲȄɰT3t ń³ÉÁnÒѨȲ۲ʲȅUж‫ګ‬DS‫ݤ‬؅Wۛ4xԫDS4t&. Ȃ 3 .10 ‫ [ ̼ ڼ‬ö U [ Ī ‫ ܙ ݠ‬ĥ         Ȃ 3.11  ‹ µ » ¢  | ̤ ٰ [ ӥ ȿ ж ‫ګ‬.  ɦ Ĕ ˿ Ǒ U ‹ µ » ¢  | ̤ ٰ U [ ‫ ܙ‬ĥ x ٠ d L l [ 9 % ‫ آ‬3.7 T 3 t & ֒ ϰ 8 r w 8 t q 5 X %+ @ [ Ȋ ȓ X Ĕ i ֘ > L 4 , U ǽ թ D L ö [ ‹ µ » ¢  | ̤ ٰ 9 %+ ˘ P ‫ ڗ‬J 5 U ̇5,UǽթDLöqsϓ̤X‫ބ‬4@U9ԫBuS4t& ‫ آ‬3.7 ɦ Ĕ ˿ Ǒ U ‹ µ » ¢  | ̤ ٰ 6957:8 !#"$.  !.  #!. -324 ,/* 

(25) (

(26) %&)

(27) !

(28) &%

(29) $.  .  .  . 0 .+1+ 

(30) (

(31) "'.  .  .  . ‫  ޜ‬Å „ ³ É Á ޭ t(876)=5.083, p<.01 % Û Ȅ ޭ t(827)=2.152 , p <.05% Ϊ ϝ ޭ t(370)=4 .929, p< .01‫ޝ‬ 79.

(32)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. Ӟ ȟ ǭ ‫ ݡ‬c [ ̩ ˊ U ‹ µ » ¢  | ̤ ٰ U [ ‫ ܙ‬ĥ x ‫ س‬t L k X % Q8 X ɾ F t ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ǽ թ % +‫פ‬ŭLN[Ӡџ9øqsÔĤXWPSl%ȊӗӞȟxɟtLkX_Us_Us9ƌƇF td:M,U+‫פ‬ŭLN[Ӡџx%qsĤŵXFt@Uxֽ6td:M,AUX%‹µ» ¢  | ̤ ٰ [ ˳ Ҧ x ж ‫ ګ‬D L [ 9 ‫ آ‬3.8 T 3 t & Ϊ ϝ T \ ϓ ̤ W ʮ X \ W P S 4 W 4 l [ [ %Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬x ō Œ F t ̩ ˊ U ‹ µ » ¢  | ̤ ٰ [ ˟ B U [ ‫ ܙ‬ĥ x ٝ i ƿ t @ U 9 T : t & ‫ آ‬3.8 Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬8 Ӡ џ [ Ĥ ŵ B 8 [ ̩ ˊ X ɾ F t ‹ µ » ¢  | ̤ ٰ <?;=@> '+%-,.#.  &'+. -+.  : 958749 ,.(&."/,-.,/#!//&#%), )#+1'.,+*#+/. . . . 

(33) :74936:29 (# ,0. )'$# *,.# !,+1#+'#+/. . . . ‫  ޜ‬Å „ ³ É Á ޭ t(930)=4.047, p<.01 % Û Ȅ ޭ t(970)=3.919 , p <.01% Ϊ ϝ ޭ t(374)=1 .386, n .s.‫ޝ‬. ަ‫‡š|«¿ˆ¸žޡީޠ‬Ȟɗ ‫ޝޤޜ‬ÛȄŗĖ                     . .   . . .  

(34) . . . .   . .

(35) .   . . . . . . Ȃ 3 .12 Û Ȅ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ʼ ‫ ޖ‬В ̴.    "  #   "     !#   "

(36)  # . 

(37). . 

(38) .  " # .  .  " # . 

(39) . "%$#. Ȃ 3 .13 Û Ȅ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬Γ ‫ ב‬χ     . 80. Ȃ 3 .14 Û Ȅ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ ֒ [ ־‬ɍ χ.

(40)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r             !YX F!, . ?7 +)%/B CF !F+)% . T  2  E D F ;7 / 6/ 97 <7  >7. 4/ :87. $/ @7. 87. +)%/ =7. 6/Z0/ VJSMPGBKS QRUOLHJS NB 'EDW ?7. & <7 1/Z

(41) / VB#B. !W 997. 1/Z

(42) / V(BIJH OUBEDW 9=7 /!V\[9888W. 6/Z

(43) / V*B" .B53EDW A7. Ȃ 3 .15 Û Ȅ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ ׉ [ ־‬Ќ.     ! !" "# #$ $% %& &                     .

(44) 

(45)   . .

(46) . . .  .

(47)   .  .  .

(48)   .  .  .

(49)   . 

(50) 

(51)  

(52)

(53)  .  .  .

(54) . ('

(55) . Ȃ 3 .16 Û Ȅ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ϒ ƾ     .

(56) . . . ! "     .     . . . . . . 

(57) !$#". Ȃ 3 .17 Û Ȅ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬Ĕ ɝ .    .  . Ȃ 3 .18 Û Ȅ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ɤ Γ. 81.

(58)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. ‫ޝޥޜ‬ÒѨ  . .  .  . . . 

(59) . . . . .

(60)  .  .

(61) . .  . . . . . 

(62) . Ȃ 3 .19 Ò Ѩ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ʼ ‫ ޖ‬В ̴.  

(63)  

(64)  .  

(65)    .    

(66)  .  

(67)   .  

(68)     

(69) .  . . .   . 

(70) . Ȃ 3 .20 Ò Ѩ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬Γ ‫ ב‬χ      !WV D! ,. ;7 AD <7  =7. Ȃ 3 .21 Ò Ѩ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ ֒ [ ־‬ɍ χ. +)%/@ .R2 CBD6/ <7. !D+) %/ 97 +)%/ =7. $/ ?7. 6/X0 /THQKN E@IQOPS MJFHQL@ 'CBU >7. 6/X

(71) /T*@" -.@53 CBU 987. 4/ :97 & ;7. 1/X

(72) 1/X

(73) / T (  @ G H /T@# FMS@C B U @ !U 9>7 997 /!TZY=88U. Ȃ 3 .22 Ò Ѩ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ ׉ [ ־‬Ќ 82.

(74)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            .       ! !" "# #$ $             

(75)  

(76)  

(77)   .   . .

(78)   .   . 

(79)  . . .  .  .  .

(80) . &% . Ȃ 3 .23 Ò Ѩ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ϒ ƾ.    . .  !     . . .

(81)  . . . .    . . . .  .  . 

(82) . 

(83) #"!. Ȃ 3 .24 Ò Ѩ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬Ĕ ɝ        Ȃ 3 .25 Ò Ѩ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ɤ Γ. ‫ޝަޜ‬ϩʨ.  . .  . .  . 

(84) .  . .

(85)  .   . . .  . Ȃ 3 .26 ϩ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ʼ ‫ ޖ‬В ̴. 83.  . . .

(86)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2.       "   !  "  !

(87)   "   ! " .

(88)   .  .  .  ! "  !$#".  .   . Ȃ 3 .27 ϩ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬Γ ‫ ב‬χ     . Ȃ 3 .28 ϩ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ ֒ [ ־‬ɍ χ. !WV D!, AD . 97 9<7  <7 !D+) $/ %/ >7 97. +)%/@ .R2CB D6/ :7. +)%/ =7 6/X0/ THQKNE@ QOPSMJFH QL@ 'CB ?7. 4/ :87. 6/X

(89) / T*@"  -.@53C B U 1/X

(90) / ?7 T(@GHF MS@CBU 9>7. & :7 1/X

(91) / T@#@. !U 9;7. /!TZY;88U. Ȃ 3 .29 ϩ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ ׉ [ ־‬Ќ.      ! !" "# #$ $                     .

(92)

(93)  . .  . .

(94)   .  .

(95)   .  . &% . Ȃ 3 .30 ϩ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ϒ ƾ 84.     

(96)

(97)     .

(98) .

(99)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            .      !   .  "  . . . "#! # "  " # ! 

(100) 

(101) .    . . .  . . . .    . 

(102) !$#". $'& %. Ȃ 3 .31 ϩ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬Ĕ ɝ        Ȃ 3 .32 ϩ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ɤ Γ. ‫ؑޝާޜ‬ʨ  . . 

(103) . .  . 

(104) . 

(105) . .

(106)  . . . . . . .   Ȃ 3 .33 ؑ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ʼ ‫ ޖ‬В ̴.  !    #   $ "$    #

(107)  $ .  # $ .  # $  #&%$. . . 

(108)

(109) .   

(110) . Ȃ 3 .34 ؑ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬Γ ‫ ב‬χ     . 85. Ȃ 3 .35 ؑ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ ֒ [ ־‬ɍ χ.

(111)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. %* ;9 DG >9  A9 %1 B9. 61 ;?9 ' ?9. "ZY G". 0 @9 "G-+ -+&1C &1 0U4FE =9 G81 A9 -+&1 @9 81[21 WKTNQHCL TRSVPMIK TOC (FE ?9. 31[

(112) 1 W   C $   C 31[

(113) 1. "X W) CJKI A9 PVCFEX B9. 81[

(114) 1 W,C#! /0C75F E X A9. 1"W]\<::X. Ȃ 3 .36 ؑ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ ׉ [ ־‬Ќ                            !      !     "      "     #       #     $      $     %      %     &       &             .  

(115).  .

(116) . .

(117)   .

(118)  .

(119) . .   .     .

(120) . .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .

(121) . (' . Ȃ 3 .37 ؑ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ϒ ƾ           . . . .  !     .     . . . .

(122)  #"!. .   

(123)   #" !. Ȃ 3 .38 ؑ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬Ĕ ɝ        Ȃ 3 .39 ؑ ʨ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ɤ Γ. 86.

(124)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . ‫ޝިޜ‬Ըʘ                   .  . .  . . .  . 

(125) . . 

(126)   .  .  . .  . Ȃ 3 .40 Ը ʘ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ʼ ‫ ޖ‬В ̴. .     . 

(127).  .  .  .  .  .  . 

(128)  .  .  . Ȃ 3 .41 Ը ʘ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬Γ ‫ ב‬χ    .  . #$0 ". Ȃ 3 .42  Ը ʘ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ ֒ [ ־‬ɍ χ. 2  & % 3 .   $ . 

(129) 0)1. *2  &%3 !.  . -1+0'/, ( +  0  .   . 254 3 Ȃ 3 .43 Ը ʘ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ ׉ [ ־‬Ќ 87.

(130)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2 ". " ". "!". !"". "#". #".        "     "     "     . "   ". "  

(131).  . . . . .  . .       .   %$. . . Ȃ 3 .44 Ը ʘ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ʼ ƾ.   '# % $% "&! (  '. ( .  .

(132)   '. ( . '#% $% (   ' * )    ( .       .  . %&$" !&#%   '*)( % & $ " . 

(133)   . Ȃ 3 .45 Ը ʘ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬Ĕ ɝ        Ȃ 3 .46 Ը ʘ ٠ Ϲ ǽ թ ‫ [ ־‬ɤ Γ. ާ‫ޡ‬. ֽɺ.  hG%njȄx‫ی‬ESӞȟǭ‫ݡ‬XɾFt‫<ބ\ٰ̤[̉رۿ‬%hL‫[ڣפ‬ĻˍXɾFtƮ Лٰ̤l‫ބ‬4@U9αr8UWPL&J[ÒT%Ӟȟĩ‫[ٵ‬LkXƌƇFt@UUӠџx ĤŵXFt@U[%VNrxōŒFt8[̩ˊxʃZL‫ڐ‬ǭXɾFtǽթxŭϭDLU@ v%ü[Ӟȟĩ‫ٵ‬X‫ܙ‬FtBhChWٰٕU‫ܙ‬ĥFt@U9ԫǨBuL&LU6]%Ӟȟ ĩ ‫ ٵ‬x ō Œ F t ö \ %Ӡ џ [ Ĥ ŵ B x ō Œ F t ö q s l %Ӟ ȟ ǭ ‫ ̉ ر ۿ [ ݡ‬x ˟ < ̤ ٰ D % Ӟȟĩ‫[ٵ‬LkXijа[‫ބ‬4l[x‫څ‬75U45‫؜‬Ɠ̤ȂxԫD%֑ѵӼʒ9Ӟȟԣȥx Č5Uֽ6%‫פ‬ҫ\ԣȥBuSl‫פ‬rǽ˵FtU45‫غس‬XƽɾD%BrX\ȀPS4t U:X‫[̼ڼ‬ö9Ƌ>S<utMv5U45‫ބ‬4‹µ»¢|ٰ̤xԫDL&֕‫ؾ‬ԀWŭ ϭT\%Ըʘ٠Ϲ[ȜǍX%üȄqslÅ­ÁΘ9ʆW4@Un%lUlUӞȟĩ‫ٵ‬x ō Œ F t ö [ Ƅ Ǎ 9 ‫ ބ‬4 ‫ ޜ‬89‫ @ ޝ ޚ‬U X q s % ϓ ̤ ʮ 9 ū S 4 W 4 ‫ ݖ‬Ԋ 9 3 t [ T \ W 4 8U̇wut9%žÉ—[ԫFŅǑ\ǏГT3t&  Ӡџ[ĤŵBxōŒFtU45ٰ̤\%ĮöԀ8QΪʸԀW‫ص‬ҦXȖR<l[T3s% Ju9Ӟȟĩ‫ٵ‬UV[q5X֒`Q<[8xԌ‫ظ‬ԀXUr6t@U\%J[q5W̙țx 88.

(134)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . Õ6ruW4‫ܥ‬s\ɱβT\W4Uֽ6rut&FWwN%Ύˉ%´‘È·ž|{%ԢՒ ‫־‬WV%ėr8[Ī‫ݠ‬T:t̙ț҄8r%Įö9ΪʸԀXĤŵWӠџxоkt@U9%Ȋ ӗ Ѻ τ ƚ n Ӟ ȟ р Ϸ %‫ פ‬ҫ ԣ ȥ W V X ֒ ` Q < [ M U 4 5 @ U x ٜ ˳ Ԁ X ċ 6 r u W 4 U % +Ӡџ9øqsÔĤXWPSlȊӗӞȟ[LkXƌƇFt,U45̩ˊ\ӠEW4[T\ W48U̇wut&lNvy%Ӡџ9‫ٹ‬8TW4LkXĤŵBxōŒFtU45ļ‫ݏ‬lW 4 U \ 4 6 h 4 9 %+ Ӗ ȉ [ Ӡ џ [ ҃ ‫ ˊ ڙ‬, x ʃ Z L ‫ ڐ‬ǭ U \ ‫ ۏ ܙ‬9 ‫ س‬r u W 4 @ U 8 r % Ȳ:W‫ر‬ǾU\ֽ6X<4&7Jr<%Å„³ÉÁTlÛȄTl%ȊӗӞȟǭ‫[ݡ‬Ѯż BXQ4S[̙ț\ƠŭXċwPS4t[T3v59%Įö[ΪʸӠџU֒`Q>tq5 W̙ț9‫؜‬:ѹrW4‫ۮ‬ŭT%Ӟȟĩ‫؜ٵ‬Ɠc[̤Ȃ9ƠŭXDZ‫ڕ‬BuS4W4[T\W 4 8 U ̢ Ň B u t &@ [ @ U \ % + ‫ פ‬ŭ [ Ĕ y T 4 t Ȋ ȓ [ ‫ פ‬ҫ Ӟ ȟ ,X ɾ D S ŗ ‫ ׭‬X ‫ א‬ɦ Ԁ X U r 6 S 4 t @ U 8 r l 5 8 9 6 t & Ӏ X  Å „ ³ É Á T \ 90‫ ޚ‬Ā Ò [ ö 9 + ‫ ׯ‬4 , hL\+nn‫ׯ‬4,Uթ6S7s%‫̼ڼ‬R:34l‫ׯ‬ɁT%ΪʸӠџx‫ۅ‬tÛT+Ӡџ9 ÔĤXWPSl,U8+֑ѵӼʒxУkSl,U8%3t4\+ɑɛ[LkX,U4PL q 5 W ‫ ڼ ڣ‬W ǭ ‫ ݡ‬U D S %Ӟ ȟ ĩ ‫ ؜ ٵ‬Ɠ x ٕ ٰ F t @ U 9 ݁ D 4 [ T \ W 4 8 U ̇ w u t &  D8D%ӖɪX\ĮöĮö[Ӡџ9ȊӗӞȟǭ‫ݡ‬X֒`Q4S4t@U\αr8T3t @U8r%ėr8[ˢTĮö[Ӟȟĩ‫؜ٵ‬Ɠxʄ<Τժ9˼‫ر‬T3t&J[Lk[̾98 s[_UQUDS%Ȋȓ[‹µ»¢|џƓ9ֽ6rut&LU6]%À}‡Ánԏ€ £Á†É%‫פ‬ҫĩ‫ٵ‬U4PLџƓ\%Įö¯ÁT\‫ܥ‬Ө93s%‹µ»¢|x͘ҦU DS‫ۑ‬kt[9ƏϰԀT3t&hG\%J[q5WΪʸӠџT[‫؜‬Ɠ9Ӟȟǭ‫غ[ݡ‬цX ˨՚Q@Ux%Ī‫[ݠ‬7>t̙țUDSö(XċۚD%BrXŞĖԀW‹µ»¢|џƓ UDS֏֫ƚFt@U9˼‫ر‬W[T\W8v58&JDS%J[LkX\‹µ»¢|̤ ٰ[‫̴ۼ‬9ϧĄUWt9%Å„³ÉÁTlÛȄTl%J[q5WֈȊ\٠ϹžÉ—8r 5896t&ÌΤ%Ϊϝ[۲ʲX7>t‹µ»¢|ٰ̤\žÉ—8r‫س‬t‫ܥ‬sƠŭU\ ‫ؼ‬6G%Ӟȟĩ‫؜ٵ‬Ɠx֏֫ƚFtÒT\%ėr8[ԭĊ‘¶[ȫƚ9˼‫ر‬UBut [T\W48U̇wut& ި‫ޡ‬. Μӊ. ؐ î  ‫ ޜ ׇ‬2003‫ ޝ‬ԭ Ċ Ԁ   Š´ [ Ū Τ լ ‫ ޠ‬۲ ʲ È ò ‫ ی‬È Ӟ ȟ ǭ ‫ [ ݡ‬L k [ ˻ Ә ɚ ‫ƒ ¡ ޡ‬ ¢ºūҹ‫ޡ‬ Ȳ ʟ  ʇ‫ ޜ‬2007‫ ޝ‬Å „ ³ É Á Ģ ij ̤ ٰ ٠ Ϲ ț ǚ ‫ޡ‬ + € ‹È« | à • « | ,Ԣ Ւ ‫ޟ‬1‫ޟ‬55-104‫ޡ‬ Ȳ ʟ  ʇ ‫ ޜ‬2006‫ ̙ ˊ ބ ޝ‬ț ԭ Ċ 9 l L r F ś Ӡ [ LJ ‫ ޡ ̉ ז‬ա ϥ ҽ ӥ È ϫ ʌ ƻ Ԟ ֡ ؅ - ś Ӡ [ 8 L N ‫ ޠ‬+ ś Ӡ ɚ , [ В ճ x k C D S . ٚ Ī ύ ̻ ‫ ޟ‬202-222‫ޡ‬ Putnam, R.D. (2000) Bowl ing Alone : The Col lapse and Retri eval of Amer ican Communit y. Simon & Shuste r.. ӣ Û  ѯ È Ȳ ʟ  ʇ ‫ ޜ‬2006‫ޝ‬+ 2004 ʼ л ɯ ‫ ئ‬Ҥ Ȋ X 7 > t ˵ ‫ [ ר‬Ӗ ӄ U ̤ ٰ , ٠ Ϲ ț ǚ ‫ޡ‬ Ϫ њ Ȳ ɚ 21 × ց ¨ » É ´ Å È } Å — ¿ ‡  ½ Å È À  É ™ È “ Å — É Ԣ Ւ ʼ ț ‫ ޟ‬3‫ޟ‬ 81-88‫ޡ‬ ީ‫ڴ٭ ޡ‬  ϝ٥Μ[ž¸ˆ¿«|š‡ÈžÉ—[Ȃ%7q`‫ډ‬Ο‫[آؾܼ[ޤ‬ě̴XʋƇx4LM 4L%Ȳɚ‫ܦ‬ԭĊɚԢՒԽ[ȲÞĩφħз%ԍ‫ۭ͓ݶ‬з%҇ǂ‫ث‬αзX̧‫٭‬Ft& 89.

(135)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. ‫ ډ‬Ο ‫ ޡ ޤ‬Ò Ѩ % ϩ ʨ % ؑ ʨ % Ը ʘ [ ö ( [ Ģ ij ̤ ٰ ٠ Ϲ ٠Ϲ֒ϰܼ‫آؾ‬   \EkX%3WLA‫[ڣפ‬ΪʸӠџXQ4S75894DhF& ޶ 1. 3 W L \ ø [ Ӡ џ X V [ Մ ˊ ҃ ‫ ڙ‬D S 4 h F 8 & @ [ Û 8 r ۣ y T < M B 4 & 1.҃ ‫ڙ‬ 2.n n ҃ ‫ڙ‬ 3. V N r U 4.n n Ô ҃ 5.Ô ҃ 99. w 8 r l46W4 W4 18.4 54.0 18.2 8.6 0.6 0.2 ÒѨ 32.7 48.7 12.7 4.7 1.3 0.0 ϩʨ 32.0 41.5 15.5 8.5 2.5 0.0 ؑʨ 25.4 49.9 1.6 7.4 1.2 0.1 ÛȄŗĖ 24.0 44.0 16.3 13.0 2.5 0.0 Ըʘ ޶ 2. 3 W L \ @ [ { U } [ ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ̤ ‫ [ س‬5 N % V N r [ ̤ ‫ س‬X ‫ ̴ ڋ‬T F 8 & 1.( z ) Ơ ŭ X l [ 9 W > u 2.( } ) Ơ ŭ X l [ 9 W < S 99.w 8 r W 4 ]ʽHWӠџ\‫ۅ‬uW4 lʽHWӠџ\‫ۅ‬ut 31.8 68.2 ÒѨ 39.0 61.0 ϩʨ 43.5 56.5 ؑʨ 36.3 63.7 ÛȄŗĖ 16.8 82.3 Ըʘ. 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0. ޶ 3. 3 W L \ %A ‫ [ ̼ ڼ‬8 L U V [ q 5 W 7 ý : Ǎ 4 x B u S 4 h F 8 &@ u r [ Û 8 r 3S\htl[x‫ޤ‬QM>ۣyT<MB4& 1. ì 4 X ԍ ١ 2. Ϊ ʸ Ԁ X ՚ 3. 3 4 B Q Մ 4. Q : 3 4 \ 99. w 8 r W xDLs%Ϊ NّxFtՄ ˊ[ý:Ǎ4 eUyVDS 4 Ӣǥ[‫چ‬DIJ ˊ[ý:Ǎ4 D8DS4W 4W4 4 s x F t W xDS4t V%Ӡџ‫ݏ‬T ƧƇDǍPS 4t 50.4 25.0 19.2 5.4 0.0 ÒѨ 44.0 24.3 23.3 8.3 0.0 ϩʨ 36.0 31.0 20.0 13.0 0.0 ؑʨ 45.6 26.0 20.6 7.8 0.0 ÛȄŗĖ 12.3 39.3 38.5 9.8 0.0 Ըʘ ޶ 4. @ u 8 r ٝ i Ò ? t @ U 9 r X Q 4 S %3 W L \ V [ q 5 X ̇ 4 h F 8 &J u K u X Q4S‫ޤ‬QGQ7թ6<MB4& ޶ 4-1.3 W L 9 Ȁ P S 4 t μ X % ‫ [ ̼ ڼ‬ö \ 3 W L x Ƌ > S < u t U ̇ 4 h F 8 & 1. U S l J 5 2. h 3 J 5 ̇ 3. 3 h s J 5 4. J 5 ̇ w W 99. w 8 r W ̇5 5 ̇wW4 4 4 37.0 53.8 6.8 0.8 1.6 ÒѨ 31.0 51.3 11.3 0.7 5.7 ϩʨ 37.0 56.0 4.5 2.0 0.5 ؑʨ 35.2 53.5 7.7 1.0 2.6 ÛȄŗĖ 16.0 47.0 23.0 9.5 4.5 Ըʘ 90.

(136)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . ޶ 4-2.‫ פ‬ŭ L N [ Ȋ ȓ x ψ r D n F < F t L k X \ % W X q s l Ĕ и [ ƌ Ƈ 9 ˼ ‫ ر‬M U ̇ 4hF8& 1. U S l J 5 2. h 3 J 5 ̇ 3. 3 h s J 5 4. J 5 ̇ w W 99. w 8 r W ̇5 5 ̇wW4 4 4 47.6 50.8 1.2 0.4 0.0 ÒѨ 44.7 53.0 2.3 0.0 0.0 ϩʨ 58.0 37.5 4.5 0.0 0.0 ؑʨ 48.8 48.8 2.2 0.2 0.0 ÛȄŗĖ 45.8 49.3 3.8 1.0 0.3 Ըʘ ޶ 4-3.О [ × þ [ L k X % ‫ פ‬ŭ L N [ Ĕ y T 4 t @ [ Ȋ ȓ x ‫ < ׯ‬D L 4 U ̇ 4 h F 8 & 1. U S l J 5 2. h 3 J 5 ̇ 3. 3 h s J 5 4. J 5 ̇ w W 99. w 8 r W ̇5 5 ̇wW4 4 4 54.8 42.2 2.4 0.4 0.2 ÒѨ 49.3 48.0 2.0 0.0 0.7 ϩʨ 57.5 36.0 2.5 3.0 1.0 ؑʨ 53.7 42.7 2.3 0.8 0.5 ÛȄŗĖ 55.8 41.5 1.8 0.3 0.8 Ըʘ ޶ 5. 3 W L [ Ĕ y T 4 t Ȋ ȓ [ ‫ פ‬ҫ Ӟ ȟ [ ӄ ̩ X Q 4 S V 5 ̇ 4 h F 8 & 1.‫ ׯ‬4 2.n n ‫ ׯ‬4 3.n n ̗ 4 4.̗ 4 99. w 8 r W 4 4.2 58.6 17.4 19.8 0.0 ÒѨ 22.3 56.0 7.3 14.0 0.0 ϩʨ 12.5 60.5 14.5 12.5 0.0 ؑʨ 11.3 58.2 13.8 16.6 0.0 ÛȄŗĖ 20.8 49.3 21.5 7.3 1.3 Ըʘ ޶ 6. 3 W L \ %@ u 8 r l G P U @ [ Ȋ ȓ X Ĕ i ֘ > L 4 U ̇ 4 h F 8 %J u U l 4 Q 8 ˘P‫ڗ‬J5U̇4hF8& 1.G P U @ [ Ȋ ȓ T ψ r 2.4 Q 8 ˘ P ‫ ڗ‬F Q l s 99.w 8 r W 4 FQls 30.6 53.6 11.2 ÒѨ 44.7 41.3 13.0 ϩʨ 35.0 50.0 12.0 ؑʨ 35.7 49.2 11.9 ÛȄŗĖ 71.5 25.3 3.0 Ըʘ ОX%ԽɚUӞȟXQ4S%3WL[7ֽ6x7թ6<MB4& ޶ 7. @ 5 4 5 ̤ ‫ س‬9 3 s h F & ޿× [ Û \ % M y M y Խ ɚ n ͅ ‫ ؝‬9 Ӽ ۚ D S Ӡ џ \ Ĥ ŵ X W P S < t 9 %J u X Q u S ö ‫ ܘ‬r D 4 й ͝ N 9 ȷ w u S 4 < ߀U 4 5 [ T F 9 %3 W L \ @[̤‫س‬X‫̴ڋ‬TF8%JuUlƽɾTF8& 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2.ƽ ɾ 3.4 N 9 4 X 4 6 99.w 8 r W 4 W4 54.8 26.4 18.4 0.4 ÒѨ 53.0 27.7 18.3 1.0 ϩʨ 79.0 13.5 6.5 0.0 ؑʨ 59.1 24.2 16.0 0.5 ÛȄŗĖ 91.

(137)     . Ըʘ.     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. 44.3. 8.5. 47.0. 0.0. ޶ 8. Ȋ ӗ Ӟ ȟ U ‫ פ‬ŭ L N [ Ӡ џ U [ ‫ ܙ‬ĥ X Q 4 S %{ U } [ ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ̤ ‫ س‬9 3 s h F &3 W L[7й͝N\VNrX‫ڼ‬4TF8& 1.‫ פ ޝ { ޜ‬ŭ L N [ Ӡ џ 2.‫ פ ޝ } ޜ‬ŭ L N [ Ӡ џ 99.w 8 r W 4 9 ø q s Ô Ĥ X W P S x %q s Ĥ ŵ X F t @ U l %Ȋ ӗ Ӟ ȟ x ɟ t L k x ֽ 6 t d : M X_Us_Us9ƌƇ Ftd:M 71.2 28.8 0.0 ÒѨ 74.3 24.7 0.7 ϩʨ 81.5 18.5 0.0 ؑʨ 74.2 25.5 0.2 ÛȄŗĖ 89.0 8.8 2.0 Ըʘ ޶ 9. Ӟ ȟ [ ĩ ‫ \ ٵ‬% 3 W L X U P S V [ < r 4 ‫ ر ۿ‬W ǭ ‫ ݡ‬T F 8 & 1. ‫ ݎ‬ʸ X ‫ ر ۿ‬2.‫ ر ۿ‬T 3 t 3. 3 h s ‫ ر ۿ‬4. ‫ ر ۿ‬T \ W T3t T\W4 4 74.2 24.8 0.6 0.0 ÒѨ 75.3 24.3 0.0 0.3 ϩʨ 81.5 17.5 1.0 0.0 ؑʨ 76.0 23.2 0.5 0.1 ÛȄŗĖ 44.5 52.5 2.8 0.0 Ըʘ. 99. w 8 r W 4 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.2 0.3. Ð 10.Ӟ ȟ р Ϸ \ 3 W L ‫ [ ڣ פ‬Ļ ˍ X V [ Մ ˊ ˧ ‫ ݒ‬x ƺ f D S 4 t U ̇ 4 h F 8 & 1. ‫ ݎ‬ʸ X ˧ ‫ ݒ‬2. n n ˧ ‫ ݒ‬9 3. 3 h s ˧ ‫ ݒ‬4. h P L < ˧ 99. w 8 r W 93t 3t \W4 ‫\ݒ‬W4 4 73.6 25.2 0.6 0.6 0.0 ÒѨ 52.3 45.7 2.0 0.0 0.0 ϩʨ 65.5 32.0 2.0 0.5 0.0 ؑʨ 65.6 32.7 1.3 0.4 0.0 ÛȄŗĖ 34.4 46.0 16.8 2.8 0.3 Ըʘ ޶ 11.3 W L \ % ij а [ ‫ ބ‬4 ǥ Ҿ T l Ӟ ȟ x ɟ t L k W r ‫ څ‬7 5 U ̇ 4 h F 8 & 1. F F y T 2. 3 t Մ ˊ 3. V N r U 4. 3 h s ‫ څ‬5. ‫ څ‬4 L < 99. w 8 r ‫ څ‬7 5 U \ ‫ څ‬7 5 l 4 6 W 4 L < W W4 W4 ̇5 U̇5 4 4 8.2 44.6 34.6 9.6 1.4 1.6 ÒѨ 7.0 50.7 30.3 6.3 3.0 1.7 ϩʨ 8.0 65.5 22.5 4.0 0.0 0.0 ؑʨ 7.8 50.6 30.9 7.5 1.6 1.3 ÛȄŗĖ 8.3 57.3 26.0 7.3 1.3 0.0 Ըʘ. 92.

(138)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . ޶ 12. @ u 8 r Μ ՜ x 4 < Q 8 ٝ i Ò ? h F & J u K u X Q 4 S 3 W L \ V [ Մ ˊ ‫ ̴ ڋ‬8 7թ6<MB4& ޶ 12-1.ŗ Ė U D S Ӗ þ Խ ɚ \ ‫ ׯ‬4 @ U q s l % j D v ̗ 4 @ U x l L r D S 4 t 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3. V N r U 4. V N r 8 5.ƽ ɾ 99. w 8 r U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W U 4 6 ] W4 ‫̴ڋ‬ 4 ƽɾ 6.4 24.2 26.4 38.0 3.6 1.4 ÒѨ 1.7 16.7 13.0 46.7 22.0 0.0 ϩʨ 4.0 41.0 30.5 22.5 2.0 0.0 ؑʨ 4.5 25.3 23.2 37.5 8.8 0.7 ÛȄŗĖ 14.5 21.5 49.3 9.8 4.5 0.5 Ըʘ ޶ 12-2.Ի L N \ % Խ ɚ x Ī Ӣ D F ; S 4 S % ɤ Γ c [ Ī Ă 9 Ô ‫ ڙ‬D S 4 t 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3. V N r U 4. V N r 8 5.ƽ ɾ U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W U 4 6 ] ‫̴ڋ‬ 4 ƽɾ 8.0 53.6 25.0 10.4 0.6 ÒѨ 3.7 20.3 27.7 40.0 7.7 ϩʨ 3.5 47.0 33.5 14.5 0.5 ؑʨ 5.8 42.3 27.5 20.1 2.7 ÛȄŗĖ 5.0 12.8 45.3 15.0 18.3 Ըʘ. 99. w 8 r W4 2.4 0.7 1.0 1.6 3.5. ޶ 12-3.Ի L N 9 Ӡ џ x 3 h s ȫ 6 W < S l %Ӗ þ Խ ɚ 9 Ӟ ȟ ǭ ‫ ݡ‬x ‫ غ‬ц D S < u t M v 5 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3. V N r U 4. V N r 8 5.ƽ ɾ 99. w 8 r U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W U 4 6 ] W4 ‫̴ڋ‬ 4 ƽɾ 7.8 41.4 19.8 27.8 2.2 1.0 ÒѨ 9.3 49.3 19.0 14.3 7.0 1.0 ϩʨ 1.5 34.5 23.5 39.0 1.5 0.0 ؑʨ 7.0 42.4 20.3 26.0 3.5 0.8 ÛȄŗĖ 0.8 5.8 18.5 29.8 44.0 1.0 Ըʘ Ð 12Ë 4.Ի ‫ ڣ פ‬X l % Ӗ ȉ [ Ӟ ȟ ǭ ‫ ݡ‬x ˘ : ‫ @ ڕ‬D L ‫ ڂ‬ą [ Ì ՟ 9 3 t 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3. V N r U 4. V N r 8 5.ƽ ɾ U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W U 4 6 ] ‫̴ڋ‬ 4 ƽɾ 15.8 65.2 11.6 6.4 ÒѨ 18.7 66.3 10.3 2.3 ϩʨ 8.5 75.0 11.5 5.0 ؑʨ 15.2 67.5 11.2 4.9 ÛȄŗĖ 34.0 39.0 18.3 5.5 Ըʘ. 93. 99. w 8 r W4 0.8 1.0 0.0 0.7 2.8. 0.2 1.3 0.0 0.5 0.5.

(139)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. ޶ 12-5.Ի M > 9 Ӟ ȟ [ L k X ė 8 x D S l %ü [ ö l Ǐ E @ U x D W > u ] %3 h s ̤ ǝ 9W4U̇5 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3.V N r U 4. V N r 8 5.ƽ ɾ 99. w 8 r U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W U 4 6 ] W4 ‫̴ڋ‬ 4 ƽɾ 21.6 52.2 8.6 16.2 1.4 0.0 ÒѨ 33.3 48.7 9.0 8.0 0.0 1.0 ϩʨ 23.0 55.0 12.0 9.0 1.0 0.0 ؑʨ 25.4 51.7 9.4 12.3 0.9 0.3 ÛȄŗĖ 47.8 22.5 8.8 10.8 9.8 0.3 Ըʘ ޶ 12-6.֑ ѵ Ӽ ʒ \ ʸ X Ӟ ȟ ԣ ȥ x U l W 5 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3. V N r U U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W ‫̴ڋ‬ 4 12.6 40.6 21.6 ÒѨ 24.3 46.0 22.3 ϩʨ 6.5 67.0 20.5 ؑʨ 14.9 47.5 21.6 ÛȄŗĖ 32.0 28.8 27.5 Ըʘ. 4. V N r 8 U 4 6 ] ƽɾ 21.4 6.3 5.0 13.6 7.8. 5.ƽ ɾ. 99. w 8 r W4 3.0 0.3 0.5 1.7 3.3. 0.8 0.7 0.5 0.7 0.8. ޶ 12-7.Ӟ ȟ р Ϸ [ q 5 W ǭ ‫ ݡ‬x ‫ غ‬ц F t L k X \ %Ȅ ܵ Ԁ W Л ‫ ܙ‬X ˟ ŷ Ԁ W З ‫ ܥ‬x ͝ L H td:M 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3. V N r U 4. V N r 8 5.ƽ ɾ 99. w 8 r U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W U 4 6 ] W4 ‫̴ڋ‬ 4 ƽɾ 24.4 55.6 14.6 2.6 0.0 2.8 ÒѨ 33.3 49.0 16.3 0.7 0.0 0.7 ϩʨ 13.5 72.5 8.5 3.5 1.0 1.0 ؑʨ 24.9 57.0 13.9 2.2 0.2 1.8 ÛȄŗĖ 42.8 29.8 17.5 5.0 2.3 2.3 Ըʘ ޶ 13. T \ % @ u 8 r ٝ i Ò ? t Ӟ ȟ ǭ ‫ ݡ‬X Q 4 S % 3 W L \ V [ Մ ˊ Ѯ ż M U ̇ 4 h F 8&JuKuXQ4S7թ6<MB4& ޶ 13-1. Ȋ ӗ Ѻ τ ƚ X q t й Ѻ [ Ò ί 1. Ѯ ż T 3 2. h 3 Ѯ ż t T3t 63.4 34.0 ÒѨ 47.0 46.7 ϩʨ 63.0 31.5 ؑʨ 58.4 37.3 ÛȄŗĖ 83.5 13.8 Ըʘ. 3. 3 h s Ѯ ż T\W4 2.4 5.7 5.0 3.9 2.0. 94. 4. Ѯ ż T \ W4 0.0 0.3 0.0 0.1 0.5. 99. w 8 r W 4 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.2 0.3.

(140)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . Ð 13-2. Ԡ э n Ԡ ҥ W V % € £ Á † É ‫ [ ҄ ډ‬Ô ‫ڙ‬ 1. Ѯ ż T 3 2. h 3 Ѯ ż 3. 3 h s Ѯ ż t T3t T\W4 44.2 46.8 8.0 ÒѨ 45.3 49.0 5.0 ϩʨ 66.0 31.0 2.5 ؑʨ 48.9 44.3 6.0 ÛȄŗĖ 63.5 29.0 6.0 Ըʘ. 4. Ѯ ż T \ W4 0.4 0.7 0.0 0.4 1.0. 99. w 8 r W 4 0.6 0.0 0.5 0.4 0.3. Ð 13-3. Ȳ й р Ϸ 1. Ѯ ż T 3 t 57.8 ÒѨ 52.7 ϩʨ 74.0 ؑʨ 59.5 ÛȄŗĖ 76.8 Ըʘ. 3. 3 h s Ѯ ż T\W4 11.2 10.0 5.0 9.6 1.5. 4. Ѯ ż T \ W4 2.6 0.7 0.0 1.5 0.0. 99. w 8 r W 4 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.3. 30.2 36.0 30.1 29.4 24.0. 3. 3 h s Ѯ ż T\W4 11.0 13.7 11.1 9.6 2.8. 4. Ѯ ż T \ W4 1.0 2.0 1.1 1.5 0.0. 99. w 8 r W 4 0.2 0.3 0.2 0.0 0.5. Ð 13-5. ‫ ؎ ڷ‬n ƚ ɚ ‫ ׎‬Ο X q t ‫ ݬ‬Ο [ р Ϸ 1. Ѯ ż T 3 2. h 3 Ѯ ż t T3t 59.6 30.0 ÒѨ 52.7 35.7 ϩʨ 61.5 24.5 ؑʨ 57.9 30.6 ÛȄŗĖ 71.5 24.3 Ըʘ. 3. 3 h s Ѯ ż T\W4 9.8 9.0 12.0 10.0 3.3. 4. Ѯ ż T \ W4 0.4 1.0 1.0 0.7 0.3. 99. w 8 r W 4 0.2 1.7 1.0 0.8 0.8. Ð 13-6. ȇ Ȧ [ р Ϸ 1. Ѯ ż t ÒѨ ϩʨ ؑʨ ÛȄŗĖ Ըʘ. 3. 3 h s Ѯ ż T\W4 13.4 19.0 17.5 15.9 5.3. 4. Ѯ ż T \ W4 4.6 7.3 3.0 5.1 0.3. 99. w 8 r W 4 1.6 3.3 4.0 2.6 1.3. 2. h 3 Ѯ ż T3t 28.4 36.7 21.0 29.4 21.5. Ð 13-4. Ѩ n ʧ n ѽ W V [ л [ р Ϸ 1. Ѯ ż T 3 2. h 3 t T3t 57.6 ÒѨ 48.0 ϩʨ 71.5 ؑʨ 57.5 ÛȄŗĖ 72.8 Ըʘ. T3 47.2 40.0 49.0 45.4 66.0. Ѯż. 2. h 3 Ѯ ż T3t 33.2 30.3 26.5 31.0 27.3. 95.

(141)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. Ð 13-7. Љ Ϯ ԣ ȥ 1. Ѯ ż T 3 t 47.2 ÒѨ 43.3 ϩʨ 50.0 ؑʨ 46.6 ÛȄŗĖ 82.5 Ըʘ. 2. h 3 Ѯ ż T3t 35.4 32.0 25.0 32.3 16.0. 3. 3 h s Ѯ ż T\W4 13.0 18.0 15.5 15.0 1.3. 4. Ѯ ż T \ W4 3.4 4.0 2.5 3.4 0.0. 99. w 8 r W 4 1.0 2.7 7.0 2.7 0.3. @u8rٝiÒ?t@U9rXQ4S%3WL[7ֽ6x7թ6<MB4& ޶ 14. Ì ‫ ׭‬Ԁ X ‫ ؼ‬P S % V y W Ȝ Ǎ T l ѕ X ˲ 5 d : M U ̇ 4 h F 8 & J u U l % ğ Ȯ 9 3 s %Ȝ Ǎ X q P S \ %ѕ ˮ x ԣ t @ U X W P S l ‫ ˻ ׯ‬X ˲ 5 d : M U ̇ 4 h F 8 & 1.V y W Ȝ Ǎ T l % ѕ X 2.Ȝ Ǎ X q P S \ % ‫ ˻ ׯ‬99.w 8 r W 4 ˲5d:M X˲5d:M 71.6 28.2 0.2 ÒѨ 79.0 21.0 0.0 ϩʨ 59.0 40.0 0.5 ؑʨ 71.3 28.4 0.2 ÛȄŗĖ 20.5 74.5 4.8 Ըʘ ޶ 15. @ [ { U } [ ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ̤ ‫ [ س‬5 N % 3 W L [ 7 й ͝ N \ V N r [ ̤ ‫ س‬X ‫ ڼ‬4 T F 8 & 1.‫ ޝ { ޜ‬Į ö [ З ŵ x ɟ 2.‫ ޝ } ޜ‬ř ś [ ŵ ԅ x ɟ 99.w 8 r W 4 t L k X \ %ř ś [ ŵ ԅ t L k X \ %Į ö [ З ŵ 9ȯʆӁҿXWt@U 9ȯʆӁҿXWt@U 93PSlûΤ9W4 93PSlûΤ9W4 15.6 81.8 1.8 ÒѨ 12.0 85.7 2.3 ϩʨ 11.5 87.0 0.5 ؑʨ 13.7 84.0 1.7 ÛȄŗĖ 30.5 60.8 8.3 Ըʘ ޶ 16. @ [ { U } [ ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ̤ ‫ [ س‬5 N % ۣ b U F u ] % 3 W L [ 7 й ͝ N \ V N r [ ̤ ‫س‬ X‫ڼ‬4TF8& 1.‫ޝ { ޜ‬L U 6 Ì ‫ [ ׭‬ö ( 2.‫ޝ } ޜ‬L U 6 Ì ‫ [ ׭‬ö ( 99.w 8 r W 4 9ФD4ۣ͌xFtU 9͝Q‫פ‬rцɦxÓF \ ‫ ܥ‬r W < S l %Ӟ ȟ x З ŵ x ģ ɯ F t U D S V 5 ɟ t 8 X Q 4 S \ % l %Ύ ˉ \ Ì ‫ [ ׭‬ö ( X Ύ ˉ \ ʺ Ѷ H G %Ì ‫ [ ׭‬Ӟ ȟ x ɟ r H t L k [ ö([ųΡXąHtd ѕˮxŷɦFtd:T 3t :T3t 34.0 63.4 2.6 ÒѨ 37.0 61.7 1.3 ϩʨ 47.0 52.5 0.5 ؑʨ 37.5 60.7 1.8 ÛȄŗĖ 19.3 73.5 6.5 Ըʘ. 96.

(142)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . ޶ 17. @ [ { U } [ ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ̤ ‫ [ س‬5 N % 3 W L [ 7 й ͝ N \ V N r [ ̤ ‫ س‬X ‫ ڼ‬4 T F 8 & 1.‫ޝ { ޜ‬ɑ ɛ [ L k X \ % 2.‫ޝ } ޜ‬ɑ ɛ [ L k X \ % 99.w 8 r W 4 ֑ѵӼʒ9ȯʆ‫ۓ‬uS ‫פ‬ҫ9ȯʆԣȥBuS l %ø 3 t ‫ פ‬ҫ x T : t l %ø [ ֑ ѵ x T : t M M>ЮFd:M >ӼʒBHtd:M 82.8 16.6 0.6 ÒѨ 83.0 15.3 1.0 ϩʨ 79.5 20.0 0.0 ؑʨ 82.2 16.9 0.6 ÛȄŗĖ 94.5 4.0 1.0 Ըʘ Ð 18. ‫ פ‬ҫ U ö ‫ ܘ‬U [ ‫ ܙ‬ĥ X Q 4 S % @ [ ަ Q [ ̤ ‫ س‬9 3 s h F & 3 W L 9 @ [ Û T ԓ ɪ X‫ڼ‬4U̇5l[x%‫ޤ‬QM>ۣyT<MB4& 1.ö ‫ ܘ‬9 ʽ Ը X W 2.ö ‫ ܘ‬9 ʽ Ը X W 3.ö ‫ ܘ‬9 ʽ Ը X W 99.w 8 r W 4 t L k X \ %‫ פ‬ҫ t L k X \ %‫ פ‬ҫ t L k X \ %‫ פ‬ҫ X˲wW>u] xŵӢDW>u x˫ϔDS48 WrW4 ]WrW4 W>u]WrW 4 31.4 43.8 24.4 0.2 ÒѨ 41.0 47.3 11.7 0.0 ϩʨ 53.0 36.0 9.5 0.5 ؑʨ 38.6 43.3 17.6 0.2 ÛȄŗĖ 42.3 51.8 3.8 2.0 Ըʘ ޶ 19. @ u 8 r ٝ i 3 ? t J u K u [ ̤ ‫ س‬X % 3 W L \ ‫ ̴ ڋ‬8 ƽ ɾ 8 7 թ 6 < M B 4 & ޶ 19-1.ö ‫ ܘ‬9 ‫ פ‬ҫ X ̾ x Ɖ 6 W > u ] % ‫ פ‬ҫ \ ʻ Ս T ٠ ǡ [ 3 t l [ U W t M v 5 99. w 8 r 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3. V N r U 4. V N r 8 5.ƽ ɾ W4 U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W U 4 6 ] ƽɾ 4 ‫̴ڋ‬ 30.8 58.8 5.0 3.2 2.2 0.0 ÒѨ 32.3 60.7 5.3 1.3 0.0 0.3 ϩʨ 24.0 64.5 8.0 3.5 0.0 0.0 ؑʨ 29.9 60.5 5.7 2.7 1.1 0.1 ÛȄŗĖ 32.3 25.8 27.8 7.8 5.8 0.3 Ըʘ ޶ 19-2.‫ פ‬ҫ \ % ϝ Ϩ % ƶ D 4 Ӡ ɕ ՠ è [ Ȝ T 3 t 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3. V N r U U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W 4 ‫̴ڋ‬ 14.8 51.4 17.0 ÒѨ 27.7 51.3 14.3 ϩʨ 6.0 49.0 19.5 ؑʨ 16.9 50.9 16.7 ÛȄŗĖ 48.0 32.5 13.0 Ըʘ. 97. 4. V N r 8 U 4 6 ] ƽɾ 14.6 5.0 24.5 13.7 2.5. 5.ƽ ɾ. 99. w 8 r W4 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.8. 1.2 0.7 0.0 0.8 2.3.

(143)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. ޶ 19-3.L U 6 ö ‫ ܘ‬X q P S ‫ פ‬ҫ 9 ԣ ȥ B u L U D S l % ‫ פ‬ҫ \ ‫ פ‬r [ Ƈ T ǽ ˵ T : t 99. w 8 r 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3. V N r U 4. V N r 8 5.ƽ ɾ W4 U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W U 4 6 ] ƽɾ 4 ‫̴ڋ‬ 8.2 21.4 15.6 49.4 5.0 0.4 ÒѨ 6.0 17.7 16.7 40.7 18.7 0.3 ϩʨ 3.5 32.0 21.0 41.5 1.5 0.5 ؑʨ 6.6 22.4 17.0 45.2 8.4 0.4 ÛȄŗĖ 5.0 7.8 20.3 29.0 37.5 0.5 Ըʘ ޶ 19-4.ö ‫ \ ܘ‬% Ȋ ӗ Ò X ȯ < [ Շ ‫ [ ݨ‬Ɠ Њ Ҿ 9 4 W 4 U Ӡ : S 4 > W 4 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3. V N r U 4. V N r 8 5.ƽ ɾ U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W U 4 6 ] ƽɾ 4 ‫̴ڋ‬ 38.6 49.2 7.6 3.0 ÒѨ 42.7 50.7 3.0 3.3 ϩʨ 21.5 76.5 1.0 1.0 ؑʨ 36.4 55.1 4.9 2.7 ÛȄŗĖ 75.8 19.8 3.5 0.8 Ըʘ. 99. w 8 r W4 1.4 0.3 0.0 0.8 0.3. ޶ 19-5.‫ פ‬ҫ \ Բ 9 ƅ P L l [ W [ T % ö ‫ פ \ ݨ‬ҫ x ʂ ] W > u ] W r W 4 1.‫̴ ڋ‬ 2. V N r 8 3. V N r U 4. V N r 8 5.ƽ ɾ U 4 6 ] l 4 6 W U 4 6 ] ƽɾ 4 ‫̴ڋ‬ 10.0 38.4 22.0 21.2 8.0 ÒѨ 14.0 30.0 10.7 16.7 26.0 ϩʨ 3.5 41.0 5.5 34.5 15.0 ؑʨ 9.9 36.4 15.3 22.5 14.8 ÛȄŗĖ 38.0 35.5 17.0 4.0 4.5 Ըʘ Ð 20. 3 W L ‫ ڣ פ‬X \ Ī Ă ˻ n Ī ˻ 9 V [ Մ ˊ 3 s h F 8 & 1. U S 2. 8 W 3. h 3 4. V N 5. 3 h lĪĂ sĪĂ ĪĂ˻ rUl sĪĂ 46W ˻9W ˻ 9 3 ˻ 9 3 93t 4 4 t t 2.8 7.6 8.6 55.4 3.2 ÒѨ 4.0 14.0 32.7 31.0 3.0 ϩʨ 1.5 10.0 51.5 31.5 2.0 ؑʨ 2.9 10.0 24.4 43.3 2.9 ÛȄŗĖ 6.3 6.8 30.8 22.8 17.8 Ըʘ. 98. 6. e U yVĪ Ă˻9 W4 6.0 5.0 3.0 5.1 7.5. 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.0. 99. w 8 r W4. 7. h P L<Ī Ă˻9 W4 9.6 8.0 0.0 7.2 7.3. 0.4 2.7 0.5 1.1 1.0. 99. w 8 rW4. 2.2 2.3 0.5 1.9 0.3.

(144)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . Ð 21. @ u 8 r ٝ i Ò ? t @ U 9 r X Q 4 S % 3 W L \ V [ q 5 X ̇ 4 h F 8 & J u K u XQ4S7թ6<MB4& ޶ 21-1. Ի \ % ԝ r W 4 ö 9 Ȁ P S 4 L r % й ‫ ڪ‬X ̾ Ƌ > x F t Τ M 1. U S l J 5 2. h 3 J 5 ̇ 3. 3 h s J 5 4. J 5 ̇ w W ̇5 5 ̇wW4 4 12.6 64.0 17.0 5.4 ÒѨ 25.3 59.0 11.3 1.7 ϩʨ 36.5 54.5 6.0 1.5 ؑʨ 21.2 60.6 13.1 3.5 ÛȄŗĖ 22.3 65.8 9.8 1.0 Ըʘ. 99. w 8 r W 4 1.0 2.7 0.5 1.4 1.3. ޶ 21-2.× Ө Û [ ö ( \ %и Χ n ɤ Γ [ ۛ 4 x ‫ ږ‬6 S %ì 4 X ė r 8 [ ˢ T Ƌ > Ǎ P S 4 t l[M 1. U S l J 5 2. h 3 J 5 ̇ 3. 3 h s J 5 4. J 5 ̇ w W 99. w 8 r W ̇5 5 ̇wW4 4 4 9.8 48.4 26.6 6.6 8.6 ÒѨ 30.3 42.3 19.3 1.3 6.7 ϩʨ 24.5 55.5 14.5 1.0 4.5 ؑʨ 18.9 48.0 22.0 3.9 7.2 ÛȄŗĖ 23.8 58.0 12.8 4.3 1.0 Ըʘ ޶ 21-3. Ի \ % ‫ פ‬ŭ [ ɑ ɛ 8 r ʂ ] u L 4 1. U S l J 5 2. h 3 J 5 ̇ ̇5 5 50.0 45.6 ÒѨ 46.0 48.3 ϩʨ 64.0 25.5 ؑʨ 51.6 42.4 ÛȄŗĖ 23.0 50.0 Ըʘ. 3. 3 h s J 5 ̇wW4 4.0 2.0 2.0 3.0 21.3. 4. J 5 ̇ w W 4 0.4 0.3 0 0.3 3.8. 99. w 8 r W 4 0.0 3.3 7.0 2.4 1.8. ޶ 22. @ [ { U } [ ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ̤ ‫ [ س‬5 N % 3 W L [ 7 ֽ 6 X ‫ ڼ‬4 [ \ V N r T F 8 & 1.‫ ޝ { ޜ‬ö ‫ ܘ‬X U P S ‫ פ‬2.‫ ޝ } ޜ‬ö ‫ ܘ‬X U P S ‫ פ‬99.w 8 r W 4 ҫ \ Ί ۴ F t d : l [ ҫ \ ٠ ǡ D %ś ɕ F t l [T3t T3t 13.0 86.8 ÒѨ 11.7 88.3 ϩʨ 6.0 94.0 ؑʨ 11.2 88.7 ÛȄŗĖ 1.0 99.0 Ըʘ. 99. 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.0.

(145)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. ޶ 23. 3 W L \ Ì ‫ [ ׭‬ö ( q s l % Œ ԰ x ʂ b Τ M U ̇ 4 h F 8 % J u U l ʂ ] W 4 Τ M U̇4hF8& 1.Ì ‫ [ ׭‬ö ( q s 2.Ì ‫ [ ׭‬ö ( q s 3. Ì ‫ [ ׭‬ö ( U 99.w 8 r W 4 ʂbΤMU̇5 ʂ]W4ΤMU ǏE<r4MU ̇5 ̇5 47.0 4.2 48.8 0.0 ÒѨ 25.3 2.3 71.3 1.0 ϩʨ 36.0 3.5 60.5 0.0 ؑʨ 38.3 3.5 57.9 0.3 ÛȄŗĖ 35.3 7.0 57.0 0.8 Ըʘ ϑ˯X%öӠ[ֽ68LXQ4S75894DhF& ޶ 24. @ [ { U } [ ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ̤ ‫ [ س‬5 N % 3 W L [ 7 ֽ 6 X ‫ ڼ‬4 [ \ V N r T F 8 & 1.‫ ޝ { ޜ‬ö [ ۖ Ǡ \ ц h 2.‫ ޝ } ޜ‬ö Ӡ \ ‫ פ‬ŭ T Ů 99.w 8 r W 4 P S 7 s %ö [ Ƈ T \ ȫ s ‫ ܖ‬4 S 4 < l [ M 6ruW4 18.4 81.2 ÒѨ 9.7 89.7 ϩʨ 10.0 89.5 ؑʨ 14.1 85.4 ÛȄŗĖ 17.8 80.5 Ըʘ. 0.4 0.3 0.5 0.4 1.8. ޶ 25. T \ % @ [ { U } ‫ ޥ‬Q [ ̤ ‫ [ س‬5 N % 3 W L [ 7 ֽ 6 X ‫ ڼ‬4 [ \ V N r T F 8 & 1.‫ ޝ { ޜ‬ö Ӡ \ ȴ < ԟ < 2.‫ ޝ } ޜ‬ö Ӡ \ ֌ < ‫ < ܓ‬99.w 8 r W 4 4:L4 4:L4 29.8 60.6 6.6 ÒѨ 27.7 61.7 10.3 ϩʨ 59.5 36.0 1.5 ؑʨ 35.1 56.0 6.7 ÛȄŗĖ 36.5 54.8 8.0 Ըʘ. 100.

(146)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . ‫ډ‬Ο‫ޡޥ‬Ըʘʲ٠ϹԴ. 101.

(147)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. 102.

(148)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . 103.

(149)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. 104.

(150)              Ӟȟٰ̤UӠџ‫ظ‬È‫פ‬ҫ‫  {{ظ‬ȄT[٠Ϲ֒ϰ8r            . 105.

(151)     .     ϪњȲɚ+€‹È«|Õ«|,ԢՒ  Vol. 2. 106.

(152)

参照

今ダウンロードする ( PDF - 37 ページ - 3.49 MB )

関連したドキュメント

居住地周辺の子育て環境についての意識と居住地選択 利用統計を見る

This questionnaire targeted 1,000 mothers who were bringing up a child, and the Internet was used.. However, in the decision making of the removal, convenience（&#34;Shop&#34;

都市の入り口を象徴する神殿――ナバテア王国の都ペトラの景観 (ヨルダン) 利用統計を見る

Abstract: In discussing about the planning and its background of the Sacred Palace al Khazneh and the Tombs in the historical rockbound City Petra, Jordan we pointed out the

神聖な，生きられる広場の景観――バクタプール (ネパール) 利用統計を見る

a) The attractive square was not the creation of one architect or planner; rather, it evolved gradually over centuries of interventions by many personalities to fulˆll the needs

資 料 編資 料 編

３Ｒ・適正処理の促進と「持続可能な資源利用」の推進 自然豊かで多様な生きものと 共生できる都市環境の継承 快適な大気環境、良質な土壌と 水循環の確保 環 境 施 策 の 横 断 的 ・ 総

資 料 編資 料 編

３Ｒ・適正処理の促進と「持続可能な資源利用」の推進 自然豊かで多様な生きものと 共生できる都市環境の継承 快適な大気環境、良質な土壌と 水循環の確保 環 境 施 策 の 横 断 的 ・ 総

地球環境変動防止制度の今後 利用統計を見る

たこともわかっている。この現象のため，約２億3,000万年前から6,500万年

資 料 編資 料 編

３Ｒ・適正処理の促進と「持続可能な資源利用」の推進 自然豊かで多様な生きものと 共生できる都市環境の継承 快適な大気環境、良質な土壌と 水循環の確保 環 境 施 策 の 横 断 的 ・ 総

環境法による環境化学物質制御に関する課題 利用統計を見る

とができ，経済的競争力を持つことができることとなる。輸出品に対して十