「総合的な学習の時間」の効果に関する研究 : 「開かれた学校」づくりの視点から

全文

(1)º»+,¼ +, No. , pp. ῍ , .

(2) ῌῌ ῌῌ . !. The Effectiveness of Period for Integrated Study ῌῌ Focusing on School Reform with Support of Parents and Local People ῌῌ Akira KAWAMURA. H8HF. ῌ. ῏ ῎ ῌ ῍. WWB8PH9& gh& g) a 8-H& ;BJ . "#$%& '& ()*+,. H8H9#F. -./01& 23415. & cf 1z cf "WX. 67*89:& ;<=9>?. G4BH9 . 1@ABCDE%9#F ;GHI. J<F X& . J& "B@A8K. B#=V+,J"& Y*Z. LMNO PQBR& ;:#. B+SD8D . 9+STD@AUQ8V WBX&. JVD7)H9HGF ¡& "& ¢£. Y*Z[\ 8]^_`GBab_9. +B¤H9 ¥¦§¨© # . # cde fF ;B

(3) & gh& @A. 8ª«H& + ¬8v. ijklBH9m B& +,nop. ®¯HWB8-H& Y*Z. qrsDE%& ;%8@A. D|WB"!°J<BabH9#F. WBDO J< ct fF ;uH. WGH9 "& . 9 DvMw8x=9. 8)#& Y*Z [\. # cyz & t fF WWB. 8,^<=9O "±8²G. "& @A. BH9³«NvJ& Y*Z. c{|& f 8}. |ÍJ2_XG=9#F. %~I<BRF H H ; v J& . _& ";£µ <=9¶#$=9#F. Dn_;8%. %·J"& WGH . =92D_& PISA . D /H9

(4) 8<¸. TIMSS B#=u Dn. 9#8¹WB8&BF. _9{& ;HD=9#F ; K c{|& f "Y*ZT |8%& .

(5)

(6) . w '. ¼. NT\J ? T.<. ῍. * !M?-/ > !.

(7) . /x(& 1" 7h.N-?

(8) ?

(9) . . 5Z[GH

(10) { 051

(11)

(12) =. !n. !". VSN M?5= !" \. . #$ %&' () *+. N7h2]5--.=GH /v%&. ,-. /( 0 01 2

(13). 1 J7h > =34Z55. 34,5 6 *78 9:!;<. !TSK!". 5

(14) =. / #$ 1" > !?. 6N 47 KH. () 0 @ /AB ? ,. ,T T8 >.* . ? CDAB E1 . JH =59C. !?. AB?F=GH ?=I. .:5 = \. * . -J4 KL.M?N OPQRSB. ,T yH*QS V. TM? RSB! M?SK!" +, -.N>5A; UVWX *S. D. ? T: 9=59C!M?. 5?:!". SB M?5YM? SB!?Z[. MSjkSN s#t ¡¢ -?. !TSK!" \.

(15) 34 :!. :!*. !? !+,-. yH*f ? >.* ?9)5. ]?= ^_ . :!M?5;= *JH :!. ,*SK.M?5`S:T . 5£¤:!". . ? @4 F=GH *?`5aYBV . ῎. . !M? bC!" P #$ c78 9:!. ῌ . ;< SN +,- d?Me K\. 6S¥<:! ¡¢-??.. H] f> ? Tg @. =rN

(16) . 7h TiT /?-TiT ? \. ¦5>C!M? =?N>?* ]?9. KTiT Eῌjk1 ?F=G. )5§¨:!M? =©N@ª. H l ;. l5 :!M?SK!". m n> !" \. 4N . s#gN ~A«*] o(). ¡¬?B. ,. *pq5 or!7"5. ®7hyH*f . 6?= 9:!s. S¯C >!7hD@. #t5

(17) = al5$u=. !. #E: . /v%& w'& x(& 1" . :!F° & *±². r) 7hyH*f . 9n.GHg /*F³´-)*. N z. / 1. +=. F°

(18) I?> ;m1 H. /1. !". ..S

(19) { |z}n> !M?. /v. %& 1 78 ,)]5}. 6*N o& () *SK!". !* ~] M. - µJ >!. !M? /w'& 1 > !". j¶ Ko*SN·¸20¹º»5. == N. ¡¬ =LM ,

(20) { }. = !P -?= . n>B. !" .X -.

(21) )*+ ,-./ ¹ºW9»¼.

(22) .

(23) . Q d\3RS"`. "! )]^@[l. . NJ1S"T9 n/ -.":9`.

(24)

(25) !. + ). " #$ %& . ¡Pb¢V"R"W&R£X". !AU J. !>K. '( ! )*+ ,-./ . Y54+-.":9` / 3&D. 0"12%3454. $H? )*+ ,-./. 6 %78 9 ":. " !AU "W"¤. %; < = ! / . ` A¥

(26) . !> &?. !@. = ! / !> . !A <. G` Z¦ )*+ ,-./ ". ! A < = ! /. C9` " G ,"#"§. !> += >. ([Hy \"g4`. ]y G "9` A ) !/ X?ῌA. ῌ. ¨^ © ῌ OPQª^&.

(27) . !

(28) . U J !>+\"«_` ?. "# C$A&D =E% > &. W-X ?OPQ"'()[ ῍ . F'()*& G

(29) HIH3. \Bd\38h ,$"B. &+JKL"MJ9*N& ). 454 8+R"g ῎ G. )*+. ,-./ B. *+ ,-./ OPQB RS. -Rq7r )op9Rq/ 7r". +TU # RS,V"W-X ? Y. ¬` $"Cg4` A. Z[./[+\]^W0 _* ?9. ) . ` Aa1+` "b29 &38. Q^ bcde f® . [& c4 ,Ad\3 efF. . 5gU G )*+ ,./ . ,A8hd\3i6j2W. !/ X?ῌA 4ä". G` )*+ ,-./ OPQª^Z«_ ` \Z. 0k elgU ` Am. S$ Rq7r¯$"Q^ ` . n &C )op9Rq/ 47. 3 X ) !/ X?$(g. r"Rq8m9` & '()* 8. 9=>. [ 4s9"*":t9 )*+ ,-./ B Rqu? )op/. 4v;<w

(30) c4Rq7r RqAl=x"1? d\3 ef F5Ry` & )op9 Rq/ Rq =op2> Az{|}~P l=x"t # 8 h d\3 e =op

(31) 2> >?J@[?A B. e. ·¸ä. "C P9` Amn ` "#"D9 )*+. ,-. ῍. . ./ ) !/ X?& . °h ) !/ X? )"W&. 8+7r"E RFG. !/ X? W-± i*Aj. ^ = RG> H )IJ !. =°k ²³ > A l2´. ! K ! L ! M !N. +mµcnoi . !RFO$ =GH. wu ) !/ ± !. n>/ 5 )*+ ,-./ P. U W¶A !

(32) 54+ .

(33)

(34) . o p.

(35). ¼. 9.mC&= 9>D C&=. . k#$ .*+*+- ,.

(36) . jlw>?q@ i/"#$+-+,. ! "#$ % &. ?@" 9P!#C= 9{C. '&(#). !*+. &'C&|6Q"}~+RS1. ,$ -.$ /* 0'. D*+.m 1>-i/#. 12* 3456#$+. = 0G D@ 9P!. "7%8 9":;<. #C= 9>D C&= A;"w. = ' 94= >? @. ,+n- .m1T"U . AB8C&">D EF@. ) V @ /%n W. *D* GH!. j#L 3".>D .m. I G J

(37) 34"1. +-+,C& 1 9>D C&=. < 9>D C&= KL8M"NO%. *+Xp<. #$ *D* P 9>D. 9>D C&= ¡Y¢7". C&= 32!#QR"SK,+,. $+ £Z¤C&["A<¥. ""* JTU@ +,.. ¦3D@ 9>D C&= "A<. VW".KLXYZ[\]^_àb. ¦ 9Wj§¨'C&©"QR<6. $1cYd*+ %efgh&'(. !\n = 9C&ª]«%$ =. 9#. )*= p. "i.,/+. 9C&.m/% +- = 1^_* . ,jk#$+,. @¦¬`+ 11,+ 9>D C. l- 9.mC&= GJ1/. &= ¡Y1¢7* . %n

(38) o%2p!#M ."0* 1q 2 3r GH! 9 4s15* tu. ῌ 9P!#C= 8N"A<. v8-"w,+ 2lxJ= . 7[a1¢7<" $+ 27JJb. -1y)."z F" {C&&. 1* . '|6"}~+ 9.mC&= KL8. ῌ{C& 9P!#C= . 1*+,L 1EF+, % J. aY1®X<" $+¯* "w. 9>D C&= KL8.-7,. ,+ °cdX1EF ¦1Jb. /!18<+ 9.mC&= KL8. * ±w27J1e * f 2 . 9<. C&]:] !;. 27J ²vC&"EF@ +,0'. <)=,/>? TU@ +8. ³,´|6¯ D@ 9aY. ,C&KL8@!"A? +,#, *. µ²vg}¯¶= 2 27J . D* 0GJ 9.m. # 9aY µ¯¶= 2 27JC. 1>< {C& BC. & %hi"AB$ . D:' !",+$ E' . 9aY µC&jk¯¶= lm . 1D* F"GF." :'.

(39) ῌ9P!#C= ",+1. !]H'I# ;1$. U +|*+, "w,+ ¦. 1/ F+p . 27JJb1* f @1Jb*. n /* 19~ C&:]. ·¸ w27Je ? 2 27. !J;1." >D C&. J y). ¹| !3-+,L. KL81lKL*+,L MN. "<)#"AB$ ¦8 y). n= ,/i/" ,C&KL8A;<. . ¹nº"Q*LEF@ .. .*+OK@ +,. 9+ µnº¶= 2 27J»y).

(40) %-./

(41) 01( º_D$»¼. .

(42) . %Z[\¡¢T3£¤T( =]^_. ¥ >¦%T3!$ &'§

(43) ¨(©

(44) 563!$#$ "§/ª«

(45) ¬ "Mx®e)¯* °¥±e²³´µ¶+¬ °¥W·µ¶¬ ¸¹+"#,

(46) WW-./e"#0 b . . . . . . . . \,. . %I3T3!$( =]^_. T3 #= e/i K >8 !D$#= /

(47) i e k" T

(48) #$ b . . . . . \,. . %"456$7( =]^_. . . . .

(49) Iàb$c6$!<deFfIgh ab$

(50) Z[\ie Ij+@D kl

(51) emno

(52) I"p$

(53) q68!3rs$ klaItu[vD$ "w x

(54) yID$ LMz{|I"p$

(55) }~Inp$ r

(56) dIg/h b . . . \,.

(57) . &GED$"4'( B = "4>. . HIJ3KLM

(58) "#D$. !"#$ % &"#'(. 7$ %"47 &N. )*+$,. D$"4'( D$,. ῎ῑ῔῍ῌ%-./

(59) 01( 2!3 "456$78!3 9:; <. ῌ. ΐῒῌ῏ῐ. 8 =>?@A : ;, B . = /

(60) CD. OPQRI STU %V<

(61). $EF$ %"47. W( XIY=T %Z[\( %( %"4.

(62)

(63) . º ». ¼.

(64) .

(65) # YZ bq R!

(66) %.

(67) .

(68) rs@ A . . ! "#$% &' (). model VWX `tu. * & + , -. / 0 1 / 2 3. vwcde àbcde `xycde

(69). 456(789 :;<$%.. # `z Yhe @{({s|I%$. !=> ?@AB .@CD6. }@ YZ b{({s|(. EBFG$H!@3(I%$. I. JKL MN. *~H! Aab. OP Q R9STR U

(70) . m(k@(I%$%^H!(} '. . ! VWX

(71). H model y R!

(72) %. # YZ [%)$%S@A. -2 I% . \ =.]B^S@A^. aW-2 nm. _($ ! VWX à.

(73) % \YW-2

(74) . bcde

(75) # `fgYhe YZ. rs VWX `xycde ?@(. !@S@A. (I^ /{s(I <OB @ B. . ! VWX

(76) # YZ !ST. VWX `tuvwcde VWX àbcde VWX `xycde

(77) # `fgYhe

(78) # `z Yhe YZ `«¬YZe YZ `²³YZe. . ** ** ** ** ** ** **. AI% 6 YZ a bmcd

(79) %VWX

(80) EBF ). = * * * *. $% zk^¡¢£¤¥:¦ !§(@3 ¨6(7CD6© z YhH!@cA }@ AI% YZª@ «¬YZ ($]'A

(81) @I % VWX®¯°

(82) abH!. µR¶ Pearson STR - ¹M2 *P¸ **P¸ . ! :;)$%z 7

(83) H! @ Bῌ@I%$.

(84)

(85) R9STRijS(. ±qῌ!῍ }@ ῎A%O. klm@A cno &. 3($ª!(I. 'H!]I%mp. \ = !. 6 R!

(86) VWX. . VWX

(87) # YZ b!9. ! VWX

(88) # YZ cno. . VWX `tuvwcde VWX àbcde VWX `xycde

(89) # `fgYhe

(90) # `z Yhe YZ `«¬YZe YZ `²³YZe aW \YW adj. R F. =. model ** * * ** . . model ** ** ** . ´ ´ . **. . **. µ RR¶·noTR *P¸ **P¸ . model . . . . model . . ´ . *.

(91) -.&8VW. ῌ῍ῌ.

(92) . z{)n.HIJz{)n. . A`%oK, /),h QL. !" #$ %&. ῐ῎῎῎S =:MN Q῏ΐSHO8!. $ '() *+,! . P /: 2 B01 ". % !" #$-.. QR ῑ S~1 !. /01 2 " % 3" 45. " #$ῌ >/$ K (!2. 6. 7

(93) 8 2 (!. >"T;8q9!%& /. &9: / ;. "K/> 8<= /. !" #$% <= >. 1U% !" #$2>. ?6 /)@! / . -. / )#: " 8q. "<=A "<=B<C<DE. !9V82> <= z{). FGHIHIJ@>K L . WX%@(!8 /1uY. MNOP@$. > % % /01 2. $ QR ῐ῎῎ῒS @>;(!@> . Z "/>% . !" $>/1 %T6 /. !. )U6:!. " #$@>-.2>/ /. 9 uY. ῌ. ῏. ῐ. !" #$Yu@>K:[ . ZX[ bp@> VW % . /9 % /. !" #$8 -!X"@>. B : .

(94) Y. #: %Z 2. \],h^j v U6:! :. . m (v%"_u>. [ " % . n uv,! k:! 9". @> !. K/>%! H %1$3. " #$ῌ >/$ 9 . @ / :8 3" 4\7 `. \ %Z 2 $]. ~¡8z{)n¢ <=£<. H^_`%a@>b7"cd?;. C<D8¤/EFGHIHI { . <=efU& ! b7'g29h. "9¥!U& !v G 2¦. 2 " (<=)* i+. 1. , -C./j;b0cd?Jk l (!:m128 % $ < =n A:efo34) #/> <D 56H^_p8 2 $7 8q!r8 2 8q9! H^_s 0> (8q! :t@ uv8.

(95) !" $l,! U6:! $w% <Dx;p< 2 <= xyz{)12@ =: |u>?6x;}@~1. !" #$ & 2 l@ (!ABCDE8 %F G 2 : <Dx;p%. ῒ῎ § ä@^©ª b«% I ῏ῒ ῌ ῏῔ (cCVWdef¬ Qg VW QBS ?h® ῏ῒῑῑ῎῏῔῕S i b«¯°4/l

(96) @"Q. ^ ^©±jk²³@>´, /@Llµ¶ Q·¸mS R¹ º¶ QnomS %p0Kqr@ 8 ῌῑ῍ Q ῏ S b~}@s0 » ¼:/%» Q ῏ S A:?Jt.

(97)

(98) . . . . . . . .

(99)

(100)

(101) !"

(102) #$" % &' ( )$ *+. ,- !./ 0 12#"3#

(103) % $(% p. $45 6& '7./8 "39!:; </( *0* =$)*#>?2/5 @

(104) +7$

(105) 9A!,/B* 1!</( *)*8>?2/ '(- C8D-9B /5 E./8 '7#70 F '1 F ' 23 F 14 F 56 F +7 # 7 0 F ' 1 F ' 2 3 F 1 4 F 56 F $45 7G$8 89./ SPSS ver. J for Windows H:5 I;8 'JKA-L#<=9B * KA#"" "* KA #>=?/"* 7@AMN#

(106) 9B"* 'JOPQ N#B" * CRDEKA-'J;S TUVWXYZ[#F* \]'JC R)* G#^_B* 2_$H;`2 90B*KA#IWXa#B "* 'bXca J'JK3 d#^_B* Le/#CR7>P fghi#F* Mj7kN# O_B* 70#lXmXYno Pp hi#F* 7Q#%_2"* 'qri #F* 7Ds RES#F* 'JTt$CR uv3 %hi#F* 5U7KAS#wB * 'JOPG#F* VWX2 /'J#F* $45 $8 48_ Y 48_ 4 _ 48_9/ 48_9/ xy$4 /% zZ[{ :d *|# 894* xy 4 8_9/ }B*5 Le/#CR7>Pfghi#F * Mj7kN#O_B* 7 Q#%_2"* @z\ * ]3 a LS8 $4B*5 î_~ ./8 a LS# `42@a# L*2/u9#40 7s$H:\ a LS8 b$4$ 1\ cd9. ¼. *5 7ef889 >B*# A8290B** 7G$8@ 89 >B*5 \8 09 g * Y g * 4_ g 90B* g 90B* 0f hB/5 ij * I; 89 *|# kS f8^/KlG mI;#nz XPoa KA) 4B* * 12 p f889 >B *5 I; ij 12 f889 * |# kSf8$^/KlG m *I;#nz " f q) *#,2 4B* $ 12 rp f889 >B*5 9. &I;$8 09 s2 / 4` s2/ 4_ s2/9/ A s2/9 / t\ : *5 I; ij 12 f889 * |# kSf8$^/KlG m *I;# z KA!z/ h _ >% 4B* $ 12 rp f889 >B *5 9. &I;8 uvg / 4`g / 4_ g / 9/ Ag /9/ t\ $ *5 7wz/87@S :/*5 $xKz/8 yz{ M

(107) 0z{M yz{

(108) 0z{M |RM ]#}/ ~¡¡¢R 14 0 zZ[ £ B*5 z{M¤¥mTX ¦f 4* yz{M

(109) 0z {M yz{

(110) 0z{ M z { M | R M ] # } / ~¡¡¢R 14 z{M¤¥ f§¨lX z{M : *5 E./8 70 '1 '23 1 4 $45 70 '1 © ' 23 14 @' f §¨lX © :/*5 pp. ῌ 8 ªX[a «[ ¬®¯°¡±m¨®X u /'

(111) «[¬®¯°¡±m ¨®X u

(112) /'

(113) /%² :/ !³O

(114) #6m`2/9/ "39!:; u

(115) /'

(116) Ć/*! Tj 1 !µ¶ 8KA·$¸¹º».

(117) (U)3V*gh *»¼-l5no. . ῌῐ ῏ ῑ ῎῍ Bernstein, Basil , “Class and Pedagogies : Visible and Invisible” in Power and Ideology in Education, ed. by Karabel, J. & Halsey, A. H., Oxford University Press, pp. ῍ ,

(118)

(119) pp. ῍ !"# $%&'()* *+,-. /0 . 1 2% 345 6789: . ; <*=> ῌῌ ?@5 ABCDEF ῌῌ G . H IJ K!"# "#*8L -M N?*"OP#%$Q&%RS?T 7,*&' H IJ (U)3VW% RS?%.7 BXYZ[:* pp. ῍. \ ]+ =>*^, 6789: . -._à/bc`def (U)3V*g h -4i0.*(Uj?*

(120) 1 ῌῌ (U)3V*gh *23?4j` k4j*

(121) 1-l55mno ῍ ῌῌ pq6$7 r pp. ῍ s/8 ` 9t:u ` v;< ` w= ` >?@x (U)3V*gh -l5Oy5m ῌῌ zA{;Bs``|C?}%D~ ῌῌ E6$7 . pp. ῍ a/bc

(122) C F ῌῌ k*GH* (U)3V*gh ῌῌ I0`@2 k .

(123)

(124).

(125) 4 pp. ῍ a/bc`-._`def Js?} (U)3V*gh * /K ῌῌ (U)3V*gh *2 3?4j`k4j*

(126) 1-l55m no ῎ ῌῌ pq6$7 r pp. ῍ K!"#0 LM s? ? | C? N? O?P?* K!* *=Q-. "#*8L . 46¡¢ 2-l5Oy5m K: . ῌῌῌῌ s?V27R ST £ . 46¡¢¤CC¥K!K ? -l5Oy5m hK . defà/bc`-._ (U)3V*g h -¦?§

(127) ¦&Q ῌῌ (U) 3V*gh *23?4j`k4j *

(128) 1-l55mno ῌ ῌῌ pq 6$7 r pp. ῍ u u¨©(.< ῌῌ ?ªUV Wù¨©*«X ῌῌ . =>%¬®¯5 °Y:Z . ῌῌῌῌ ±²%

(129) ³ ?(

(130) s´ . µe[ (U)3V*gh%L¶?< *\· ῌῌ ¸¹*K]º ῌῌ U ;¸¹$7 r pp. ῍ .

(131)