(2006
)
ALE
Optimal Shape Determination of A Oscillating Body by ALE Finite Element Method
41
!"#$%Hiroki YOSHIDA
1
&'()*+,-./
,
0123456,78/)*+9:;<=>?
,
@ABCD.EF9GH6/.<.
IJ,
)*+90123456@H:;<5KL4CDM?+
KNO,PQR/-B
,
5KLSTUFV<NO4WX?5KL,-;<YZ4[F\]^<
.
_`4Tabcde4fg1
,
hijk,-;<lmnopq4fg,
MH,?TUrst4fg,78/
,
5KLTUrNO?hiu,WXV<EF9vwFA8/.<
.
R@Rxyu,
,
+KNO4z{?,
5K,78/+K?|}S~EMA.F.X4F6/DJ
.
4u?
,
TaANOS,
5K,78/+K9|}V<F.4
,
Tabcde,D,
hiu,WXV<EF]^<
.
5KLTUNOWXZ4B?
, Pironneau
1),2)
9
Stokes
_4V<]4jt4sFSR
,
4hi5KL4fg,7B569b jk]D<EF,A8JEF,7B¡rRJ
.
]?
,
¢£¤h,5KLS¥¦§.<EF]u¤hFR
,
¨©iSz{ªhX i
,«§V<.
IJ,
Tabcde,.J
Lagrange
¬htS§.,
®¢£¤hSX¯V<
.
°±²³´,?, ALE
µ¶,7<·¸¹rM6Jº»¼
Navier-Stokes
²³´F,
½¾xX4´S§.J
.
NO¿À,§.H6<Á±,?,
°±²³´SÂÃÄÅ_V<Æ,TaNO4X´rS.
,
z{ªh
X i
4¥¦uA¤hFV<EFA {ÇS8J4
(
ÈÉt)
S§./.<.
TUr,?Á±tSa§R,
NO4¿ÀS8J
.
2
ÊËÌÍÎ2.1 Navier-Stokes
ÏÐÑÒÓ
Γ
SÂV<2
¸¹2ÔÕÖΩ ∈ R 2
SX¯R,
ÕÖ
Ω
?º»¼×5K]ØJM6/.<4FV<.
°±²³´,?
,
Ù4ALE
µ¶,7<·¸¹rM6Jº»¼
Navier-Stokes
²³´S§.<.
˙
u i + b j u i,j + p ,i − ν (u i,j + u j,i ) ,j = 0 in Ω (1) u i,i = 0 in Ω (2)
EE]
, u i
Fp
?5ÚF»L]^B, ν
?}×ÛhSV
.
IJν
?Reynolds
h4Üh]µM6<. b j
?ALE
¨©ÝÞßà,áV<â4ãáÚ]^<
.
2.2
äåæçèé+K4NO?{Çê³,-./
,
xëR/½¾xX4SØìR
,
TarM6A;6íAHA..
EE]îï<+K4½¾9xX]^<F.EF?
,
jkÕÖ,-;<ÂÃÄÅðñÝo4Vï/4ÄÅ4½¾4òó9
,
xX]^<EFFô£]^<
.
½¾xX4´?Ù47,µM6<
.
m
X
e=1
a e (x i ) (l) − A 0 = 0 in Ω (3)
EE]
, a e
?õÄÅ4½¾SµR, A 0
?ö÷ÕÖ4½¾, m
?òÄÅh, l
?Tar,ÉøBùRúhSµV.
3
Îû3.1
üýþÿ ]?
,
5KLbcZS/.<.
E],
bcS5KLS¥¦¢£¤h,§.<
3) .
¢£¤hJ
?5KL4¬ó,7B
,
Ù47,X¯M6<.
J = 1 2
Z t f
t 0
q 1 (F 1 − F ˆ 1 ) 2 dt + 1 2
Z t f
t 0
q 2 (F 2 − F ˆ 2 ) 2 dt (4)
EE]
, q 1
Fq 2
?L,
L,Û<¤hSR/.<
.
MH,, F 1
FF 2
?L,
L4{ÇiS, ˆ F 1
FF ˆ 2
?L,
L4uiSR,
Ù4´,78/µM6<
. F i = −
Z
Γ B
− pδ ij + ν (u i,j + u j,i )}n j
dΓ (5)
3.2
üýþÿTabcde]?
,
X¯M6J¢£¤h9TUFA8JO9
,
TaAO]^<FX¯M6<EE]¢£¤h?
,
°±²³´(1),(2)
F½¾b(3)
SØJRA9HTUrM6A;6íAHA.E6?VA
,
D4TUrZFH6<
.
]?,
m¬htS§.
,
¢£¤hS®V<EF],
AR4TUrZ,D<EFFV<
.
´(1),(2),(3)
SIF/
, R k (U i , X j ) = 0
Fµ¶R,
mo¬hS
λ
FV<F®¢£¤h?,
J ∗ (U i , X j ) = J(U i , X j ) − λ k R k (U i , X j ) (6)
FA<
.
E4®¢£¤h4xªSFB,
S<EF]Èɲ³´FNO¿À,§.<Á±S
V<
.
3.3
è颣¤hSTUrV<J4?
,
®¢£¤h
J ∗
4xªS(δJ ∗ = 0)
,V<EF]^<.
δJ ∗ = ( ∂J
∂U i
− λ k
∂R k
∂U i
)δU i
+ ( ∂J
∂X j
− λ k
∂R k
∂X j
)δX j + R k δλ k (7)
7B´
(7)
4õSF<F,
Èɲ³´FÁ±?Ù47,H6<
.
− u ˙ i ∗ − (b j u i ∗ ) ,j + p i ∗
− ν(u ∗ i,j + u ∗ j,i ) ,j = 0 in Ω (8)
u ∗ i,i = 0 in Ω (9)
u ∗ i = 0 on Γ U (10) s i = 0 on Γ D (11) s 1 = 0, u ∗ 2 = 0 on Γ S (12) u ∗ i − q i F i = 0 on Γ B (13) u ∗ i (t f ) = 0 in Ω (14)
∂J ∗
∂X j
= grad(J ∗ ) i = −s j u j,i (15)
EE]
, s i
?Ù4´]µM6<. s i = {b j u ∗ i − p ∗ δ ij + ν(u ∗ i,j + u ∗ j,i )}n j (16)
3.4
NO¿À,§.H6<Á±?
,
Èɪh@HH6<Ým
s j
F5Ú42Ô²4iu j,i
,78/{ÇM6<
.
,
ÒÓSV<F,
5K,@6J+K4µ½5Ú?FAB
,
45Ú4iFA8/RI
.
E], u j,i
,áR/Nx¸_Sa§R
,
+K4â,-;<5Ú42Ô²4iS
,
4â,¤<ÄÅÔ]4iFR/<EFFV<
.
4
!5K,@6J+K?"KFAR
,
Ù4|}²³´,#
,
ª$Y
,7<1
%&SÂR/.<FXV<
.
m Y ¨ + c Y ˙ + kY = F 2 (17)
EE]
, m, c, k
?6'6(Ûh,
)*Ûh,
+ÛhSµR/.<
.
5
,û-5.1
. ]?
,
TUrstFR/ö÷i,PQRA.Á±tSa§RJ
.
st]?,
®¢£¤hJ ∗
,áR//01ß2pS3V<EF,7B
,
45¢£¤hK
9@6<
. K (l) = J ∗ (l)
+ 1 2
X i (l+1) − X i (l) T
W
X i (l+1) − X i (l)
(18)
EE]
, W
?Ûh6SµR/.<.
45¢£¤h9TU,A<FD
,
3RJ/01ß2p9,A<J
,
45¢£¤h9TU,A<EFF,
®¢£¤h9TU,A<EF?ô£]^<EF,A<
. X i (l)
STajFV<F
, δK (l) = 0
9B\J,
NO¿À47ðpq?Ù4´]µM6<
. X i (l+1) = X i (l) − 1
W grad(J ∗ ) (l) (19)
6
89û ]?
,
°±²³´·
Èɲ³´F,:;4<=rS
.
2Ô²4<=rFR/?,
>Xr3?¤hÂÃÄÅtSa§R
,
5Ú,¤R/?3?¤hÄÅ,
»L,¤R/?x¸ÄÅS§./.<
.
@Ô²4<=r,?
,
>X,A6,
@ÔBSCD6<
Crank-Nicolson
t(
Cujt)
Sa§V<.
7
DEFGHIJNO¿À,§.H6<Á±4K?
,
«§V<ÂÃÄÅðñÝo,PQV<EF9@8/.<
.
L.1
47,+K_M9NxAÂÃÄÅðñÝo
(Delaunay
ðñÝo
)
S§.<F,
Á±4K?L.2
47,NOPA4FA8/RI.
,
NO¿ÀS.P;<FNO9QR,
ðñÝo4ST15KL4BCAU4VW9~D/RI
.
E] ]?L.3
,V7,,
+K_M,X45YðñÝoS±RJÂÃÄÅðñÝoS«§V
<EFS<
.
E4ðñÝoS«§V<EF]Á±4K?L
.4
47,ZH@A49H6,
ðñÝo4ST1
,
5KL4BCF.8JZSjWRJ.
[
.1 Delaunay
\]^_[.2
`a[
.3
\]^_[.4
`a8
hijkFR/
,
1h250
4º»¼Navier-
Stokes
56,-;<+K45KLTUNOWXZS
.
EE]+K?L,7B,
U|}S~EV4FV<
.
hijk]?,
NOSªNM<EF]LFLSbcV<EF9u]^<J
,
¤h
q 1 , q 2
SF,1.0
FzXRJ.
á6?,
NOªN,Éâ4}(9
,
TC]0.02
S<EF4A.7,<
.
E6?,
ANO4},7<,
jk,§.H6<ÂÃÄÅðñÝo4STSEFF
,
,NOSªNM<EF,78/
,
,TaNO,_;<F.L,7<4]^<
.
ö÷4NO,-;<jkÕÖFÒÓ
,
ÂÃÄÅðñÝoSL.5, 6
,V
.
(15.0, 5.0)
(15.0, -5.0) (-15.0, -5.0)
4.5D
U D
14.5D
u = 0 v = 0
u = 0, t = 0
u = 0, t = 0 14.5D
(-15.0, 5.0)
u = 1 1 t = 0
2 1
2 1
i
[
.5
!"#[
.6
$%&'\]^_8.1
()*+,-jk,§.H6<ðñÝo?
,
"K4|},#8/}M6A;6íAHA.
.
E],
´(17)
,78/H6<.¥²
Y
4ª$SLaplace
²³´,/0V<EF]
,
â4}(S{ÇV<EFFV<.
∇ · φ = 0 in Ω (20)
φ = Y on Γ B (21)
φ = 0 on Γ U (22)
φ = 0 on Γ S (23)
φ = 0 on Γ D (24)
R
,
+Kµ½4â4}@H,
ÕÖ34õâ4}SÇV<EFFV<
.
+K4},É8/4â9}S4]
,
°±²³´S{ÇV<jk,-./?,
âFÄÅ4òh?ªrRA.
.
8.2
NO¿À,§.H6<Á±?
,
Èɪh@HH6<Ým
s j
F5Ú42Ô²4iu j,i
,78/{ÇM6<
.
,
ÒÓSV<F,
5K,@6J+K4µ½5Ú?FAB
,
45Ú4iFA8/RI
.
E], u j,i
,áR/Nx¸_SÙ47,a§V<
. u j,i = ∂u j
∂X i
= Φ 1,i u j1 + Φ 2,i u j2 + Φ 3,i u j3 (25)
´
(47)
,7B,
+K4â,-;<5Ú42Ô²4iS
,
4â,¤<ÄÅÔ]4iFR/<EFFV<
.
9
56
hijk78SL
.7
@HL.14
,V.
]H6JT9NO4CLSL
.7,
NOTar,É¢£¤h4:O;SL
.8,
ö÷NOFTaNO,-;<LFL4@<=SL
.9,10,
.¥²Y
4|}4@<=SL.11
,6'6V
.
L.12
?ö÷NOF|}SRA.>,H6JNO
,
|}SRJ>,H6JNOS?@RJL]^<
.
L.9,10,11
,-./,
âA?ö÷NO,-;<õiS
,
A?T9NO,-;<õiSµR/.<
.
MH,,
õNO]4·¸¹@Ô100
,-;<»LKLSL
.13,14
,V.
¢£¤h4:O;@H,
H6JNO9L
·
LSF,TUFR/.<EF9@B
,
+K4|},
+KBB,fCV<»LDSEH6/.<EF9@<
.
MH,|}SRA.>,?ï
,
+KƲ9D,ªNV<F.FG9HH6<
.
·¸¹@Ô50
@H100
4]4ö÷NO@,-;<L
,
L,
+K4|}4npi,?ï,
H6JNO]4õi?
66.2%, 92.8%, 84.8%
6'6E<EF9J
.
xyu,,
5K,^<+K4TaNO?5AI]^<EF9JH6/.<9
,
H6JT9NO?,
+KƲ7B²4K9LSM8J4FA8J
.
[
.11
NOPQRS[0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
0 100 200 300 400 500
Iteration cycle peformance function
[
.7
Q0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
0 20 40 60 80 100
Force
Non-dimensional time final shape initial shape
[
.8
-0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6
0 20 40 60 80 100
Force
Non-dimensional time final shape initial shape
[
.9
-0.04 -0.02 0 0.02 0.04
0 20 40 60 80 100
Displacement
Non-dimensional time final shape initial shape
[
.10
-1 -0.5 0 0.5 1
-1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5
Y-coordinate
X-coordinate
final shape (oscillating body) final shape (non-oscillating body) initial shape
[
.12
PQNOPQ[[
.13
PQ[(T = 100)
[
.14
NOPQ[(T = 100)
10
!"#$
,
%&'Navier-Stokes
()*+,-, ALE
./0123456)789:;*<=->?@ABCD
EFG3HI7
.
JKLMNO>?PQ*RS-TU$,
VWXY*<Z
Lagrange
[Y23AR=-\O#,
]^VWXY3_`Z
,
aEbcdeEfghijkl-\Omno7
.
\)k$@A>?3l-7p*.qrs2#tI7OSu-
.
vw*!"#lk)7xy3z{=-
.
•
|}~Y250
Erjr()*+S,
(;3u-@A>?$(#$r
,
L*3I7>?m@ArEOr-
.
•
893ZrSOZ7#$,
*rm
,
lk)->?*aEm)-\OmjI7
.
¡