ǂòdzǮEčã9#M
ěʑɮƤŋȴ;ʊÉ6čđïį9ʛ*MǼȈ
- Ɏ¿čà*Mŀɲ;ʓɈªȝdzŎʈǠȩ´ĦčãQ±9 -
Expansion of Stores Managed by the External Capital and their Acceptance among the Locals
- Focusing on the Historic District in Kawagoe Developed as a Tourist Site -
ɫ ° Ţ ˀ ŀ é ƚ ˀˀ Ŀ Ƨ Ȁ ˀˀˀ
Yoshie Ka Susumu Kawahara Yu Okamura
¥p
ʓɈªȝdzŎʈǠȩ´Ħčã9ʐī&N.čã87 ªȝdz8ǮE´ÁƊ¹&N.čã;Ĝ!<
:4JLɎ¿;IJɤ6814.ʹľŅǮčã ŀɲǰɂǗņʟǗ;ďɂʍ87ňʚ 300 Q ɲ*Ɏ¿ĭɔNʃň<ěĊ;z`ga|;
IJɤ6814MčãHM$(.čđ5ɉKN M;Ɏ¿ĭQIJɤ6(.Ąā;ɨęQɀč½ čđě;Țćȭ9JMŋȴʾ£ěʑɮƤŋȴ6þ
?ʿ;Ǹƽ"Éŋ5MƛɎƑȑM9HʛPK +Ąƴdz8Ő;őD6DL;8ƛɎǪD N4M6;ŷƃʾƫ 2004 ʿIƩɔȭƟʁFð [{\Ujɖ²5< 7$95HMJ8ċǫĻ=
L5ʱš861.Ťɉƈɉ&Něʑ ɮƤŋȴ;ʌō;êÀ<ǂòdz8ǮE;NI·
ŠĆĠ;ŨŝQǪR5M
Ɛªȝdz8ǮEQȠŶ*M.G9<$$Q Ǫƴ;ĕ6(4ǐǬ(4!ŚɈMĄŋɂI
ǮŁĕ;ɛʬ6÷Ʒ9Ŷ0ÐǬ;ʹʽàIɶ Ȟ ;Č6ɛʬQŲ4M5ƏɊ;ŋȴ IƦ;êÀƣŖ&NMʾŀé 2013 ʿ -;Ťý5 ʺ×dz8ŋƶQƊ¹*Mɮʕ×Iʤĭ×;MĄ āUlfvIuk×QƢ*MĬȦMěʑɮ Ƥŋȴ;êÀ<čđ;ǐ×QǪFĕöHLĒƤ dz9ƾʂ&NMAH;5O
$;J9Ɏ¿ĭ;ėØI-;Ɏ¿ĭQɰÀIJ ɤ9(.ěʑɮƤŋȴ;êÀƉ;ėØ61.Ɏ¿č à<ǀɥʧ;UqYjMčđ6Ɏ¿ʛʉ ǫƴ;Ŷȟdz8Dzļ;.G9<$;ǀɥ;UqY jQǖűſ([j (4!ŚɈŠŷ ƃ&N4M ˅ʿ
-$5ƤǼȈ<Ȏ9Ɏ¿čà;ʊɀ*Mǂòdz ǮEčã94Ŕʨ×;MěʑɮƤŋȴ;ʊÉ ǢǎQÁĊdz9ƵɎ*M$6Ȏ9$;ǢǎʯȺ 8±QɘȗɜƮIJɤčã6(4ʐī(Ådz8ě ʑɮƤŋȴ;ʊÉǢǎIŤù$NQï#ƿGMčđ
¸;ŤɡIîLșEQƕK9*M$N9JLěʑ ɮƤŋȴ;êÀQǐ(8K·ŠQĠP8Ǯ
E´ÁǐǬ;LƐÉŋIĄę;[j ; ƐǏ924žɑQɀ$6QG'*
k
r$ CUK.xN9'UL! UVWr#_`!D.!+-@fRX .Q¤!z w#2o,!7! CUK#.¢>a|?YUL2"
,G_. >a4365O<=t¦ #YT2;! ]7P_2Z
s, UVF#v #:{J9'?E Ptg Cg# #+ _
2W¡r_h.! . 8! W¡r_!Z UL#@f2j 1 +
![ (0l.A#bH2qd.UVA#^',/ /!W¡r_*MI.
W¡r_#UVK.%~y,/.
* ʵʒĞħƪĞħʟ ʒŅǩĖȃħǼȈȃ Ɏ¿ȃħđ çĘÓƣɛȆ
192-0397 ƪʒÂǦĥŅæĞNj 1-1
e-mail ˋ kayoshie@hotmail.com
** ʵʒĞħƪĞħʟ ʒŅǩĖȃħǼȈȃ
Ɏ¿ȃħđ Ƈź ssm.kawahara@me.com
*** ÷ ÈƇź
¥ncr#}e
ǂòdzǮEčã#MŋȴȐ;[j 92 4;ǼȈ<ŎȓǠ;ŤâI 9H63!åɢ ƐǏ9ʛ*MǼȈř5L±=ǂòdzʱȲ
;ȠŶ9ù#.¬dž;Ǭʅƴȇ;åɢŭǏ9ʛ
*MH;ʾNJǭ 2013 ʿ Ɏ¿à9«ǂòdzŎȓǠ;
¬ĨKĄƴǬʅ@;ɻǬƙ;ŬƢƹȅɻQɞ).H
;ʾʕ 2001 ʿȐM((õč9Éŋ*Měʑ ɮƤŋȴ;ʊÉ9JMčã;·Š;ĆĠ9ąʬŤɡQ Ŷ0-;ĬŦIŤùQɸD4ɞ).H;<B6R 78
¥ES!\£.W¡r_#G~yu
D+Ɏ¿čà;ʊɀ*MǂòdzǮEčã9 4Ŕʨ×;MěʑɮƤŋȴ;ʊÉǢǎQƵɎ*M .GǂòdzǮE´Á;îLșEƕǽ9PMʓ ɈªȝdzŎʈǠȩ´Ħčã ʾ£ ʓªŎčã6þ?ʿ Á 110 čãQɜƮIJɤ6*MʓªŎčã9ǺǶ*M
;<Ɏ¿IJɤ6(4;yh^ ʹ!2
ȵdz9<ǣȱ;ǮE´Á; QH0-;ʋć șȨ9JMåɢI´Á;îLșEM.Gěʑɮ Ƥŋȴ9IJŜ*M×QŶ0M6ȬMK5M D.Ŕʨ×;MěʑɮƤŋȴ6(4<ȏȭK;
Țʸõč;ʓªŎčã9ĶęĐŋȴ;ɆƉŋȴļ ʙQɀ¨ƴʾ£ ªŎeV6þ?ʿĦČ
*MñȰŠM.G-;ĬŦQǽGM ʾ˅ʿªŎeV;īȪ6ųÉ
ƤǼȈ;ɳƔK -;ªŎeV;īȪ6(4 ʓªŎčã9ȋč*MŋȴĦČ*M$6ƓƤ ÂčƐãË9Ē3ƤǿʾƤʑʿ;ŬČčã£ě9 ɆƉŋȴÉŋ(4M$6Ɏ¿ĭù#;ĄƦQů 14M$66ˇʩǶ*A4ɗŒ*MH;6 (.-(4ʓªŎčãQƢ*MɀƆɎ¿å©Ȑ
; web x_9Žɾ&N4MŋȴšĔK$NK
;ƨ¦9ɗŒ*M¨ƴ6ÉŋɀPN4MʓªŎč ãQűſ(.ÉŋœŦ<ŋȴšĔ9ØɄɴdz9
¬ŬK google mapgoogle street view 5ǽə(.
$;ɜƮ;țƬ 2016 ň 3 ơǧČªŎeV9 ɗŒ*M;< 5 ǿĦČ(Éŋč<*A4;ʓªŎč ã 110 čã;0 5 čã9ʞKNM$6Qűſ(. ˆʿ ʾɃ˅ˁɃ 2ʿ $; 5 ǿ;ƵɈQƊǨ(.;Ƀ 3 5 MÉŋœŦ< A ǿQʠõǿ6HǂòdzǮE Qƶũ*MŎȓÇ9ŋȴQƶMɷʧŋĞʑË5 1.5HŋȴƉ5ƠĞŭ; T ǿ<ȱǿÇ5ɆƉ
;ŋȴukQŶ14L2;ʓªŎčã9Ɇ
ƉŋȴQļʙ(4MukĜɏȚćĐ51.
D. A ǿ<ĞĐĄƴ~ @;ÉŋQř6(22 HǂòdzǮEÇ;ɷʧŋ9HÉŋ(4LĜƷ 8ȋčļʙQ(4.
õč;ʓªŎčã9ĶęĐŋȴ;ɆƉŋȴQļʙ*
M¨ƴƉ<ķ8$6P1.ʓªŎčã5<
ǮE´Á;.G;ƛɎ ;ĴĩIi]Uåɢ
;ŚɈŠM87Éŋ9IJ*Mok ʹ$
6ţ&NM
Ƀ 1 ªŎeVˉǿ;ƵɈ
øȄ Ƥǿ ŬČč
Öƴň 8ƴŦIɨęāǶ
ʾõǿ HP ;Ƀɓ;DDQŽɾʿ
˔ǿ ʒŌ 1980 XYd[hgƴ˃W
_l ʲāʳʲƴ˃Āʥɧƴ˃
[bvj^fv
˓ǿ ǟƤǹ 1971 Ⱦȿ cvy`Ȑ
˃àȔā;Ʌʈë>ɨę¡
ˏǿ ľƲǹ 1957 TYb\ʥɧ
˒ǿ ʗʔǹ ƕ ɣȹĥijʘŋʳʲŋ
ˎǿ ȁġŀǹ 1977 džȶtSf^˃TYb\˃
ĶǠʥɧ˃ĮÅ˃ǪčɿÀ / ¨ǯѯ
Ƀ 2 ʓªŎčã9#MªŎeVˉǿ;ÉŋƉ
ʓªŎčãø ªŎeVˉǿ;ÉŋŋȴȡƉ áǓʍ Êʴ 3 ǿ 9 ŋȴ
ēǥǹ ŀɲ 5 ǿ 12 ŋȴ
ʒŌ ǫıĎ 2 ǿ 3 ŋȴ Ŀľǹ ¶Ƌ 3 ǿ 6 ŋȴ ĞËǹ ɣǭ 2 ǿ 3 ŋȴ
Ƀ 3 ªŎeV;¨ƴÏÉŋœŦ
øȄ ȡ ŋ ȴ ɷʧ
ŋȴ ĄƴƑɕÇ ŋȴ
ĞĐĄƴ~
Ç ŋȴ
˔ǿ 140 ŋ 129
ŋ 10 ŋ 0 ŋ
˓ǿ 50 ŋ 42 ŋ 8 ŋ 0 ŋ ˏǿ 38 ŋ 36 ŋ 2 ŋ 0 ŋ
˒ǿ 18 ŋ 18 ŋ 0 ŋ 0 ŋ ˎǿ 70 ŋ 18 ŋ 6 ŋ 46 ŋ
¥]7#W¡r_#G~y ƤȌ5<ªŎeV;ÉŋEKNM 5 2;ʓ ªŎčã;5HªŎeV¨ƴÁǿÉŋ(
D.ÉŋŋȴȡƉÁĊƠĜ;ʓªŎčã5Mēǥ ǹŀɲčãQɜƮIJɤ96(ěʑɮƤŋȴ;ÉŋǢ ǎIčđșȨ;ïį;ǢǎQűſ(.
ʾ˅ʿŀɲʓªŎčã9#MǮE´Á;îLșE Țȣ
ŀɲ;ʓªŎčã9#MǮE´Á;îLșE<
õǿ5ƠHĜÉŋœŦQğƭ5ĈR/
- 20 -
ªȝdzŎʈǠQ<)G6*MĜ!;ƌàɦǧĦ*M ŀɲǰɂĄŋɂ ʾ£ǰɂ6þ?ʿQř6 (4ƘĀ 60 ň¢JLʊGKN4.ǡ9Ąŋɂș öIȱǍ©ijʘĮ87čđ;ĜƷ85ƶũ&N .ŀɲǮEĤĂ©QșȨ(ÁĊ9¾ʶ#4ȑ ī(.žưĐ;Ǯ3!LéÒ5MǮ3!LɊȒ Q 30 ňʃ!č½șȨʋǬ(4.$6ǮE
´Á9ÜƬdz9¼4M((ʃňǰɂ;}
UʆL5Mǹʍ 39 ôȢɈčƐʍŀɲĎŪDžû ľȢ;ƥ;ʀłǜK¥Ǯłǜʚʾ£ɃʆL 6þ?ʿ94ěʑɮƤŋȴ;ėØȺ(!ª ŎeVH$;ɃʆL9ʧ(.ɷʧŋ6(4ÉŋQ ɀǮE;Ǣǎ<8LĚà(4M-$5
ǰɂ9#MªŎeVQúG.ěʑɮƤŋȴ;
ʊÉ;ƙȉʚdz8Ěʏűſ.G;ɜƮQ$81.
ʾˆʿǰɂ;Ɏ¿čà;Țȣ
D+ǰɂ;Ɏ¿čà;ĚʏQűſ*M.G9Ɏ
¿ĭÀLʁEĭƉ6öP,4ǰɂ;Ɏ¿čà9Ŕʨ Q.6ȬKNMɤQƌǤɜƮJ>Ʉɴdz rTZKűſ(.ŀɲŅ< 1982 ňKɎ¿
ÀʁĭƉ;ȝɒQî14M.G 1982 ňQɜƮ;ɱ ǜƙ6(4ƊǨ(.ʾĉ˅óʿ
D+1989 ň; NHK ĞnjkzƗƓĹ;ƅƖ Q1#9Ɏ¿ĭėģGǮE´ÁƊ¹;
țƬ6(4 1999 ň;ʓªŎčã;ʐī9ȧ1.$
6ƕK681.-;ŗčđ5;Ɏ¿Uwj
;ėØ 2009 ň; NHK ʉȟhsĶɚ2=&;
ƅƖ 2013 ňƪǁƪȢƪşƪƺȢƺǒʹʇE8 6EKȢ6;ǸǷʆʋɻ;ʙģɎ¿ĭƉ;ė Ø9Ğ8ŔʨQ4M$6ŷƃ&N.
ʾˇʿǰɂ;ŋȴȐ;Ěʏ
ƽ9 1982 ňK 2015 ňD5; 33 ňʚËʾƼ Ƃ :1983/1985/1966/1988/1990 ňʿ;c¬Ĩčĉ
ʾȥĸ 1,500 Ë; 1ʿQǬ4ǰɂ;ɃʆL9ʧ(
.ƪ¸6ɇ¸ìƐ;õŎǠÏ;ŋȴȐ;ƴŦƴȇ;
ĚàQŀɲǰɂɃʆLŋȴȐĚʏɍĉ6(4
¯ũ(.ʾĉ˅ǃʿ ĉ;õɀ<ǰɂ;ʆL9ʧ
*MƋč%6;ŎǠǬʅ;ĚʏQǾ(4MȒĈ<
ƥ;ʀłǜQáȍ¥ǮłǜQæȍ6(õɀ;
ě¸B7Ơʃ;ǢǎQɃ(4MŎǠǬʅãË6(
4ŋȴ¬ĨÞŬÃÄÃǴƑɕʷɺĕȉ čȉĮƕ6ãË(.-;5ǡ9ŋȴ9 24<ƒĦŋȴ6ěʑɮƤŋȴ9Ë#.-
;ʢ 1982 ň£ÓKćƴ(4MŋȴH(!<ŀ
hÛ¦
hÛ¦
Kv
±O
±O 3%
z z Kv º¾ º½º¼º» ºº º¹¹Â¹Á ¹À ¹¿ ¹¾ ¹½ ¹¼ ¹» ¹º ¹¹ÂÂÂÁ ÂÀ ¿ ¾ ½ ¼ » ºÁÂÁÀ Á½ Á»
-N©çZ3ÛZ3y¨:$ M
Á» Á½ ÁÀÁº » ¼ ½ ¾ ¿ ÂÀ ÂÁ¹¹ ¹º ¹» ¹¼ ¹½ ¹¾ ¹¿ ¹À ¹Á¹Âº¹ ºº º»º¼º½ º¾
-N©çZ3ÛZ3y¨:$ M
_?N
ăÃL gNĄ
ºÂÁ»M!Íæ.lÇãÓÐÜ J¢L£Û.Û.âN
;¯ gN .Û7+ÜJ¢L;£Û.ÚåèNÇ lÛ7+ÜJ¢L;ÚgêWÖN
A
#UÇā]ă&#UÇàÖç·Ç
ªç \·Ço \·ÇÿĀõþñìðþ¸¥7Ą
¸¤7ā¸¥7 Î3 ÎD Nµāy¨a
ĉM M M
ç§áCY
M
M d<<V;¯ gl
ÛN
Ċ;¯ gNÛgk'fß
M
;¯ gN
ÛR8f
J¢Lç§áCYăJ¢LjĄ N:1
M
<q÷üúÈc`GÉXb
M
±O3%Ú®BÒéè
M«FÈÖÝÒÉXb
M M
ɲŅÇȚćȭ9JMŋȴQƒĦŋȴ6Ƀɓ($NK QŅÇɮƤŋȴ6E8(.D.ěʑɮƤŋȴ<
Ɏ¿čà;Ģƻ681. 1989 ň£ŗ9ǰɂ9Éŋ (.ŋȴ514¨ƴ;ĕö<ƤǿŬČčŀɲŅ ě·Țć;ĕö<ȚćȭŀɲŅěÉɹȭ5M ŋȴ6(.$NKKÎƎÉƩ81.ŋȴ92 4<ŀɲǰɂĄƴå÷șöʾ£Ąŋɂșö6 þ?ʿ;ǧǨʗ@;rTZJ>Ʃɔȭ9 JM Web 5;ŋȴø9JMƳȖ5ʜɍ5.Ʃɔ ȭ;uZȐ;ɓʄKűſ(.8øÓ;Ƀɓ 9Ěƞ81.ĕö< ŋȴĚà8H;6(.
ʾˈʿǰɂ;ěʑɮƤŋȴ;ʊÉǢǎ;ƵɈ ĉ˅óĉ9Ǿ*J9ŀɲŅ5<Ɏ¿ÀLʁE ĭƉ 1982 ň£ʝǺĬ9ėØ»ù9Lǰɂ<
ŀɲŅ;řdzɎ¿č5M$6K÷Ʒ;»ù6Ȭ KNMĉ˅ǃ9Ǿ*J9 2003 ň9ĞŭªŎ eV T ǿ;ÉŋQƻ9ɆƉƋč5ěʑɮƤŋȴ
;ÉŋģD14M$;ƙƣ£ʝɎ¿ÀLʁE ĭƉ;şǛ8ėØƙƣ9Hʓ8MD.ʒřIƺǒ Ɛʧ6;ǸLÀNʋɻ;ģD1. 2013 ň£ʝ ěʑɮƤŋȴ;ėØ&K9ʯȺ5M-;ʢě ʑɮƤŋȴ÷ĘʣŻ(4Éŋ(4L$NK<Ŏ Ǡ;ŬƢȭ÷51.D.Ɖň£ȉč ȉĮ51.Ƌč9HěʑɮƤŋȴÉŋ(4M 2012 ň£ʝ<ªŎeV£ě;ěʑɮƤŋȴHĜ
!Éŋ(4M$6ƕK981.ƽȌ5<-;
ǢǎQɘ(!ɉ4!
¥W¡r_!Z.UB#m ƤȌ5<ěʑɮƤŋȴ;Éŋ9IJ(4ǡ9ǰ ɂ9ʛPMč½;Ʒ8čđșȨ7;J9ï#ƿ G4MQűſ*M-;ʢ ěʑɮƤŋȴQč
½;7;J9ŹM;ɋǜʓɈ5Mč
½șȨ@;vrTZK<ěʑɮƤŋȴ6 14HÓȌ;J8ȋč;ɋǜ/#58! J-H;
76ťɌM$6-N<ƓŇdz9Țć ȭ6;ILîLɀ$65MʮɉMʛ³
;ʓɈŠ5M$6ŷƃ&N.-$5ĉˆ;
J9ƺɼ9<ŅÇě61.ƤǿŬČč;ȋč9 JLãË(.Ȥɼ9<ʮ;ɉMʛ³QǾ*H;6 (4Țćƹʞ;MƤǿ6;ŀɲ;Ĭŋȴ;ɩ§ȭ
;ǕdzɵʦQǾ*$6QȬȚćȭ6ŋʗ÷
5MH;Q·ŋȴȚćȭ6ŋʗDZ8LƉŋȴ QƢ*MĶɊƸļʙ¨ƴÁĊdzɊƸ5ŋȴļʙ*M ÁĊeV¨ƴ69ãÏ(.
$N9JLěʑɮƤŋȴQǹÇÉɹ·ŋȴ˃
ǹěÉɹ·ŋȴ˃ǹÇÉɹĶɊƸŋ˃ǹěÉɹĶɊ Ƹŋ˃ªŎeV; 5 29¤ɚdz9ʰĐà(..
/(ǰɂ9<ǹÇÉɹ·ŋȴĦČ(81.
.G£ŗǹÇÉɹ·ŋȴ6ǹěÉɹŋȴQöP ,4ŅěÉɹ·ŋȴ6(4ˈ2;ʰĐ5ɚƕ*M
ĉˆ ěʑɮƤŋȴ;¤ɚdzʰĐà
ɜƮƐǏ<ǰɂ9ʛPMÁ˅˅;č½șȨ;¢
ɃȭʾɃˈʿ6-NK9Ľ&8ȵ;ƒĦŋȴ˅
ŋ9IJ(4õˆƙʚȆō;äƶʈàUdsQɀ
¡șȨ6;ʛ³6ěʑɮƤŋ9IJ*MɉɐQ 1.ɯąʩǶ<ŬĽ*MșȨ;ƵɈI©Ă
dz9ʛP14MUwjȐ;Ƣǝ6-;ɘȗ
¡;ŀɲ;čđșȨȐ6;ʛ³;Ƣǝ6ɘȗě ʑɮƤŋȴ924;ŤɡIŹƐĄŋQćD8 M<ćD8!81.ŎǠŬƢȭ6ʛ³5M
Ƀˈ UdsQɀ1.č½șȨ6ŴŒȭ ŀɲŅʒŅƛɎɛ §
ŀɲǮEĤĂ© ĤĂʗ NPO ǏŀɲȻ;© Ô©ʗ ŀɲĄŁ©ɢŬ ȚćƄƁʑ ĶljŪŀɲɎ¿å© ijÞǨ
ŀɲǰɂĄƴå÷șö Ǩʗ ŀɲŅɎ¿ɛ Ɏ¿Ƒɕ¨ǯŴŒ D03!Lŀɲ Z vzn_
ÝǫĻˑǿ ©ʗ
˓ǮȱǍ© ©ʗ R7;© ŴŒȭ ƒĦŋȴ ːŋ
ɜƮƣʚˋ 2015/10/30-12/24
Uds;țƬč½șȨ<ǐÝɳƔ5Ğ!
ˇ2;ȋĕ9ƊǨ5.ʾĉˇʿ ǮE´ÁIƛɎœ ũ9îLșF´Áȕ6Ɏ¿ƴIǮEQǐ (.UwjȐQɀɎ¿ǐǬȕ -(4Ąŋ
- 22 -
ɂșö;ȋĕ5MƓŇdz9<Ɏ¿ǐǬȕș Ȩȩ6´ÁȕșȨȩ;ʛ³<ȼ!ŎǠ;ǐǬȐ5;
ŎǠ9ʛ*Mư¦Mĕö9´Áȕ;șȨ9Ťɉ QLjGMȆō51.$NKȭ;ƓŇdz8šĔÄ Ƣ87;ʚQîLŶ2;<ĄŋɂșöŴ14.
ĉˇ ǰɂ9ʛPMč½șȨ;ʛ³ĉ
ƽ9ˇȋĕ%69UdsÇįKěʑɮ Ƥŋȴ;ŹƐ;ǸʎQƊǨ(.-;țƬɎ¿
ǐǬȕ;șȨ;¢Ƀȭ<ěʑɮƤŋȴ;ĬŦIĜƷ ŠQűſ(4K+D.ãÏ(4Ƀǧ(887ǚ Ǟ6Ź4.ʾĉ 4 ʿ ƐĄŋɂșö;¢Ƀȭ<
ěʑɮƤŋȴ6ƓŇdz8ʛ³ŠĦČ*M.G·
ŋJ>ǹÇĶɊƸŋQč½ŋȴ6(4Ź-N£
ěQěʑɮƤŋȴ6(4Ź4.-(4ƒĦ ŋȴ;5Hǂò;ʗȫȴ6-N£ě;ƒĦŋȴQ ãË(4Ź4.$6HP1.ʾĉ 5 ʿ &K9´
Áȕ;șȨ;¢Ƀȭ<Ąŋɂȋĕ;ƐKŀɲǮ
EĤĂ©Ȑ;ĕ94ěʑɮƤŋȴÉŋŗ;Ĭ Ŧ;šĔÄƢɀPNM.GĄŋɂșö6BC÷Ʒ 9ěʑɮƤŋȴQŹ4.ʾĉˊʿ
£Kŀɲ;ʓªŎčã9#MěʑɮƤŋȴ
<č½șȨ%6;ƓŇdz8ʛ³;ōö9J14DZ8 MŹƐĦČ*M$6P1.
8´Áȕ;ř<ǮEĤĂ©5Měʑ ɮƤŋȴQúG.ƏɊŋȴ6;ʛPL<ŎǠ´Á;å ɢ9ʞī&N4.č½șȨ6(4<ěʑɮƤŋ ȴ;Éŋŗ;čđ6;ʛPLƐȐQåɢIŷĵ*Mŕ ÕQŴșȨĦČ8$6P1.
£;Çį<õșȨ;¢Ƀȭ@;Uds5 Lȝɒdz9<õȋĕ;Á49Œ4<DMɉɐ6<
ɑ8((õșȨ;5;ƓŇdzåɢ;Çį Ťɉ9íƖ&N4Lī;µʫŠ<M6Ȭ KNM
D.čđÇ9<¬dž;ȋĕ6(4ȱǍ©șȨIŎ ǠŬƢȭĦČ*M$NKÁ4;IJɤșȨ9ɜƮ5 48M<șȨà&N48.G
ʑ;Ɛ@;rTZK;ʑËdzɉɐ5<M ȱǍ©;ȋĕK< čđ;ŀɲȂL@;ʛPLƐ ěʑɮƤŋȴ9IJ*Mèɤ9ŔʨQM$6Ǿă
&N.D.ŎǠŬƢȭ;ȋĕ5<ǡ9ɃʆL9
#MªȝdzŎʈǠ;ȠŶɪQɭ.G9ʹʭ;hl
jƍQɕī(4L$N;ƄŮIJŜ5MɮƤ QŶ2ªŎeV¨ƴ;êÀĜ6żİ&N.
ĉˈ Ɏ¿ǐǬȕșȨ9JMěʑɮƤŋȴ;ŹƐ
ĉˉ ǰɂĄŋɂșö9JMěʑɮƤŋȴ;ŹƐ
ĉˊ ´ÁȕșȨ9JMěʑɮƤŋȴ;ŹƐ
¥UB!Z.W¡r_#m ƽ9ǰɂ9#M 4 dUv;ěʑɮƤŋȴ čđ;Ɏ¿ǐǬȕ Ąŋɂșö ´Áȕ;
ˇ2;ȋĕ;č½șȨ67;J9ʛP14MQ
űſ(-;9ĦČ*Mɛʬ;űſQǶdz6(4ɜ
ƮQɀ1.ɜƮ<D+ʰĐà(.ěʑɮƤŋ ȴõ 4 dUv9ɗŒ*MŋȴQĄŋɂșöǨʗ K;żȽQH69 1 ŋȴ+2ųÉ(ʾɃ 5 ʿ õ 2 ƙʚ Ȇō;UdsQɀ1.
D.ĄŋɂșöǨʗJ>Ąŋɂșö;ř dz}pƢśʤDM R7;©;©ö9 4UdsQɀŋȴ%6;Ąŋɂșö@;
êØǢǎ6ȬƐ;łDZ;ĬŦQǽə(.
8;ɜƮ924< T ǿ<ÁĊdz9H
ǰɂÉŋƉdz9HƠĞß×5MªŎeV¨ƴ5 L ƤɜƮIJɤ6(4µʫŠʹ6ɑM D.
-N£ě;ˈdUv;õŋȴ<õdUv;ȡŤQɃ (4M6<ɑÌN8ǰɂ;ÁĄŋ;Ȭ ƐQűſ(4MĄŋɂșöǨʗõdUv;Æ ĐdzȬQŶ14Mŋȴ6(4żȽ(.ŋȴ5M .Gī;µʫŠ<M6ȬKNM
Ƀˉ ěʑɮƤŋȴ;dUvÏrTZ¾;šĔ
ěʑɮƤŋȴdUv UdsIJɤ 8ƴ ŅěÉɹ·ŋȴ O ŋ ŋʗ ʥɧɨę ǹÇÉɹĶɊƸŋȴ P ŋ ŋʗ ȸĻ ǹěÉɹĶɊƸŋȴ R ŋ ŋʗ ʸŁū ªŎeVŋȴ T ǿ čđɩ§ȭ Āʥɧ . ʲāɨę
ɜƮțƬǰɂ9Éŋ*M 4 dUv;ěʑɮƤŋ ȴ<´Áȕ;șȨ6<ŋȴÉŋǘ¹ƙ;ʛPL;E 5M$6Ɏ¿ǐǬȕ;șȨ6<-;șȨ;©Ă 5Mŋȴ£ě<ƓŇdz8ʛPLĦČ(8$6 Äʆ;ʛPLƐ51.((Ąŋɂșö6;ʛ PL<ěʑɮƤŋȴdUv%69DZ81.ʾɃˊʿ Á dUv6HĒƤdz9Ąŋɂșö9ØÀ(ƓŇǐÝ Ȑ9å×dz5MH;;·ŋ£ě;ŋȴdUv5
<ĝ;©öIȜ;É8ƙʚěǐÝD.ŘƴĂ
<čđěĺ¬5M$6KêØ(3KǢǎĦČ (../(ªŎeV514H¡čã6DZ 8Lŀɲ;ŋȴɩ§ȭĄŋɂǐÝ9ǔ!ʛ(.ŋ ȴHL©ǿ;ŤŞJLHŀɲ;ǮE´Á;îL șEQǨɐ(čđ9Ư'-6*Mŋʗ·;ÎƎ 9JM$6Ë1.
$;ȯƛ9<ĄŋɂșöěʑɮƤŋȴ;ɩ§
ȭQșöǨ@;§ÿ*M$6IĄŋɂșöǨ
ʗř6(4Ąŋɂ;ŗ;s_QÄƢ*M.G
;ĕQʃňėØ*MD5;ŀɲ;ǮE´Á;Ț ȣQǻK+9čđ@êÀ*MěʑɮƤŋȴQúG4ɕ
#4M$661.ěʑɮƤŋȴQńʁH6
*MĄŋɂșö¸;Ú×M$6Ë1.
D.ěʑɮƤŋȴȬMč½șȨ6;ʛPL9 ʛ*Mɛʬ6(4<čđ9ĦČ*Mƕƌà&N4 8ʆ±IƝʼ; QǻK8$65čđ@;ê ÀŒÍ9ȷÛ(4M6ŤɉĜ!-;ƕƌà IšĔ;ILîLLJɽ9ɀȊð68MQƕǽ 9(4B(61.čđ¸;ï#ÀNÑ;Ɗ¹@
;ƣŖ1.D.ěʑɮƤŋȴȱɹHčđ6ʛ PM$69ʛ(4<õĬŋȴ;ŋʗ87;ɩ§ȭ;
ŤŞ9J14čđ6;ʛPL;ǔ&DZ814L ŋʗȐKH¨ƴ6(4;ŗƁÑȐ;ŚɈŠŷƃ
&N.
Ƀˊ ěʑɮƤŋȴ;dUvÏ;Ąŋɂșö6;
ʛPLōöɍ
ʾα : Áŋȴ9ɗŒ / ǡī;ŋȴ;E / ɗŒ8(ʿ
¥&)i
ªŎčãQĄƴč6(4Dzļ&,M.G9<Įɬ ɥŴ×;ʹěʑɮƤŋȴ;êÀ<ŚɈ8Ǣǎ9M
$NQïį(.5ŀɲ;±5<ǮE´Á;o
kʧ;îșE/#58!č½IĄŋɂ;ǐÝȂ@
;êØ87ªŎčã;·ŠQƂ8P+F(OƄM
¸;ŕÕQƣŖ(.ńʁE6ªŎeV6þR /ÁĊļʙQɀěʑɮƤ¨ƴHå×*MǢǎɉK N.$N<ěʑɮƤŋȴ;čđà;îLșE6 M
D.-;¼#<$ND5ǮE´Á;řQ Ŵ14.´Áȕ;ȋĕ58!ƓŇǐÝ5ʛPL;ǔ ĄŋɂșöěʑɮƤŋȴQȗËà(4Ź4 Lå×ʛ³3!LIɜƊ;×QDzƀ(I*$6 Ǿă&N../(ǧČ;6$Oǰɂ5<$
(.îLșEĄŋɂșöÇ;·;Ú×9J14ʊ GKNLD/ șE98148ŗ<ěʑ ɮƤŋȴ9IJ(4ʓªŎčãƢ*MǮ3!LɊȒ
- 24 -
;J8okʧ; /#58!čđIĄŋ Ŵ14.čđǐÝ;LƐ924Ó9ƕǾ5 M Qǽȋ(-NQǮEĤĂ©;J8șȨ QŶ14ʋǬ(4!$6ƢÜdz5M6ȬKN M -;.G Ƶ9ěʑɮƤŋȴ6ŵM;5<8!
-;ȇÏ;š9Ŝ).ěʑɮƤŋȴ;čđà@
¼#;ƐǏǼȈ&NMŚɈM
謝 辞
ƤǼȈ< JSPS ȃǼɪ JP26283016 ĒǵǼȈʾ B ʿ ˋɎ
¿D03!L;.G;ɒǯŰɁ;ȕà6ƇȮʙDz9 ʛ*MǼȈʾǼȈ¢Ƀȭˋŀéƚʿ;ÙũQï#.H
;5Mɓ(4ɠŤQɃ*M
註 釈
1 ʿ 2016 ňō;ƓƤŎȓħ©Ğ©ǼȈŧɝ©Ɏ¿čđ<ʒ ŅɒǯD03!L9®QƣŖ*M;ˍʾºˌʒŅɒ ǯƤĤĂ© Ɏ¿6čđvmZĶĤĂ©ʿ 5<Ɏ
¿čà;[j 924 ƛɎIʙDz[j
ɺǑÀÑʞƩĭȭÑʞ87ĜƷ8ɋǜ5ɢɞ&N4 M
2 ʿʓªŎčã£ě;ªȝdzǮE;čã9Éŋ(4Mě ʑɮƤ¨ƴ<ʓªŎčãÇ9DŽ(4ķ8
参考文献