• 検索結果がありません。

A Field Survey for the Protection of Endangered Weaving Technique and Motifs of the Traditional Cambodian Pictorial Ikat Silk Pidan: Some findings from the field survey in North-East Thailand and Southern Vietnam

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

シェア "A Field Survey for the Protection of Endangered Weaving Technique and Motifs of the Traditional Cambodian Pictorial Ikat Silk Pidan: Some findings from the field survey in North-East Thailand and Southern Vietnam"

Copied!
22
0
0

読み込み中.... (全文を見る)

全文

(1)

1.Introduction:thebackgroundandtheobjectivesofthisresearch

TheauthoraimstofindoutthecurrentsituationofweavingthetraditionalCambodian pictorialikatsilk pidan (hereafter・Pidan・)through surveysin ThailandandVietnam,in additiontothatofCambodiareportedinYonekura(2014).Asaresult,theauthoraimsto contributetopreservingandprotectingtheweavingtechniquesandmotifsofPidan.Theauthor aimsto:mapwhereandonwhatscaletheproductionofPidanistakingplace;findoutwhat kindsofmotifsofPidanexist;andcollectandrecordthemotifsofPidan.Asapartofthe research,thispaperreportssomefindingsfrom thefieldsurveyconductedbytheauthorin North-EastThailandandSouthernVietnam.Theauthor,basedontheunderstandingofthe currentsituationsurroundingtheproductionofPidan,alsoaimstoexplorepossiblepaths toitssurvival.

Pidan isa special,elaborately designed pictorialikatsilk for religiousarchitectural decorations.Pidan isa silk weftikatin a 2/1twillwoven using thesametechniqueas ordinaryikatsilkinCambodia.Yet,Pidanisdistinguishedfrom otherikatsilkbyitsdesigns ofreligiousnarrativescenesrelevanttoBuddhism,myths,etc.SomecommonmotifsofPidan includenaga2,ahalf-god-likeserpentordragon,celestialnymphs,Buddha,templ e,thetree-of-life,andwhiteelephants3(SeeFigure1forsomesamplesofikatsilkandPidan). 学苑 総合教育センター国際学科特集 No.919 37~58(20175)

A Fi

el

dSurveyfortheProtecti

onofEndangered

Weavi

ngTechni

queandMoti

fsoftheTradi

ti

onal

Cambodi

anPi

ctori

alIkatSi

l

kPidan:

Somefi

ndi

ngsfrom thefi

el

dsurvey

i

nNorth-EastThai

l

andandSouthernVi

etnam

1

Yuki

koYonekura

〔研究ノート〕

Figure1.Samplephotosofordinary-qualityikatsilk,ordinary-qualityPidan,andhigh-quality Pidan

Ordinary-qualityikatsilkfor

(2)

Yonekura(2014)hascompiledtheexistingrecordsontheproductionofPidaninCambodia. High-qualityPidanisanendangeredculturalheritagefacingacrisisofnear-disappearanceafter overthirty yearsofcivilstrifein Cambodia.Many antiquehigh-quality Pidanshavebeen destroyedortakenoverseas,withfewremaininginCambodia.Onecanhardlyfindnewly-woven high-qualityPidaninthemarketsandsilkshopsinPhnom Penh.Inthispaper,・high-quality Pidan・meansPidanwithexquisitelyintricatedetailedclearmotifs,thepricesofwhichcanbe 10~100timesmorethanordinary-qualityikatsilk.Onlyafew skilledweaversofikatsilkcan weavehigh-qualityPidantoday.Furthermore,thehigh-qualityPidanweaversaregettingold. Therearenotsomanyweaverswhocanmasterthetechniquesofcreatingthecomplicatedmotifs ofthehigh-qualityPidan.Itrequiresahugeinvestmentoftimeandefforttomastersuchskills. ThemotifsofPidanarenotdrawnonpaper.TheyareonlytaughtbyproducingPidan.Thus, when theoldskilledweaversofPidan passaway,themotifsandweaving techniqueswill disappearwiththem.Inaddition,asSiyonn(2008)andWolfarth(2017)describe,thecultureof using Pidan to decoratearchitectureforBuddhistritualshasbeen fading in Cambodia. Pidanisnow wovenmoreforaestheticreasonsdisconnectedfrom religiouspractices.

Yet,theCambodiangovernmentpoliciestosupportPidanproductionhavebeenrather weak.In2003,theauthorhadinquiredwiththeMinistryofCultureofCambodia,theNational Museum ofCambodiainPhnom Penh,andtheUNESCOofficeinCambodiaastowhetherthey hadcollectionsofPidanorpoliciestoprotectandpreservePidan.OnlytheNationalMuseum of CambodiainPhnom PenhhadonepieceofantiquePidan.Itscollectionsoftextileswerelost during thecivilwar.TheUNESCO officewasin possession ofonly recently woven silk clothsandnoantiquePidan.TheUNESCO officeusedtoconductsilkweavingtrainingin Cambodia,butitwasnotnecessarilypromotingPidan.RecognisingtheplightofPidan,in 2003,theauthorformedaPidanProjectTeam (PPT),agroupof7volunteers,aimingtoset upapermanentexhibitionofPidaninCambodiatopromotePidan.PPT hasraisedfunds in Japan and used theirown pocketmoney tohold Pidan Exhibitionsin Cambodiamore than10timessince2003.In2011,PPTdonated23piecesofhigh-qualityPidantotheNational Museum ofCambodia in Phnom Penh.Since2011,PPT hasawaited theintroduction of appropriatetextilepreservationfacilitiesatthemuseum,aswellasCambodiangovernment supporttothemuseum intheform ofPidandonations.4

Also,weavingPidanisquitetime-andlabor-consuming.InCambodia,ordinaryweavers whoweaveordinary-qualityPidanorordinaryikatsilkcanonlygetsmallnet-profitsafter deductingthecostsofsilkthreads,dye,tools,andlooms.Unlessweaverscanproducehi gh-quality,high-pricedikatsilkorPidan,net-profitsaresmall.Atthesametime,duetoitshi gh-price,itisnoteasytofindcustomerswhocanbuyexpensivePidan.Ratherthanbecoming Pidanweavers,youthshavealternativeoccupationalchoices.Theybecomemigrantworkersat constructionsitesorfactoryworkers.Theirincomeisbetterthanthatearnedbyweaving ordinaryikatsilk.

(3)

Forexample,accordingtotheNGOCaringforYoungKhmer(CYK),recentlymoreyoung weavershavestoppedweaving.Theybecomemigrantworkerstogetregularincomesfrom thefactoriesoperating nearby their villages.CYK hasbeen training weaversin Takew provinceinCambodiafor20years.Forexample,theminimum wageoffactoryworkersin Cambodiawas140USD5permonth in 20166.Someworkerscan earn about200USD per month working longerhours7.On theotherhand,ifCYK orders a production ofhi gh-quality ikatsilk forspecialuseasobi,widebeltsfortheJapanesetraditionalcostume kimono,manyweaverswanttoproduceit.Thisisbecausedespitethefeeforproducingobi beinglowerthanthefactorywagebyworkingover-timeandlonghours,CYK payshigher laborfeescompared tothenet-profitsofproducing ordinary ikatsilk forclothing.Also, weaverscan weaveathomelooking aftertheirchildren and theirworking hourscan be flexibleandrelaxedcomparedtothefactorywork.Thus,ifweaverscanearnbetterincomes than weaving ordinary ikatsilk,moreweaversmay continuetoweaveandsomeofthem maybeabletomasterthetechniquesofcreatingthecomplicatedmotifsofPidan.

AftertheauthorhaddoneathoroughreadingofexistingEnglishandJapanesepublications on Pidan in Cambodia in 20148,thepreliminary hypothesisabouttheprospectofPidan weavingwasofasignificantendangermentofthisartform.Theauthorassumesthatnot onlyinCambodia,butalsoinNorth-EastThailandandSouthernVietnam,people・smotivation forweavingPidanmightbedeclining.

ThispaperfocusesonthefindingsonPidanfrom thefieldsurveyinNorth-EastThailand in2015andinSouthernVietnam in2016.Theauthorwaspromptedtoconductsurveysin thesetwoareasin lightofstudiesby Iwanaga(2003)andMorimoto(2008)describing the production by Khmerpeopleofasilk weftikatin a2/1twill,auniquecharacteristicof Cambodian ikatsilk notfoundin IndiaandIndonesiawhereikathasdeveloped.Iwanaga (2003)couldidentifyonepieceofPidaninthesurveyinSouthernVietnam in2003.

2.Theresearchmethodology,schedule,andtheresearchmembers Thekeypointsoftheresearchmethodologyareasfollows:

A)DomappingofthecurrentsituationofproductionofPidaninCambodia,North-East Thailand,andSouthernVietnam;

B)Collectand record themotifsofrecentand antiquePidan remaining in thesethree areas;Findoutthemeaningofthemotifsthroughinterviewsofweaversand・Pidan・ collectors;and

C)FindoutthecurrentsituationoftheproductionofPidan;forexample,area,number ofweavers,theamountofproductioninthesethreeareas.

Table1showsthelistofareasofCambodiawheresilkthreadproductionandsilktextile weavinghaveexistedsincethe1990s9.Duetotimelimitations,thissurveyhasnotyetinvestigated thecurrentsituationofproductioninthoseareasinCambodiaexceptworkshop-IinSiam Reap

(4)

Table1.TheareaswherepeopleproducesilkthreadandweaveikatsilkinCambodia

Province District Commune Village Kampot AngkorChey Dam Don Dam Don

AngkorChey AngkorCheyLeu,AngkorCheyKraom Dam BoukKpoh Takor

Chhuuk Meanchey VialTouvaal Takew PreyKavas PreyPdaw Saivar

PreyKabas TropeangKrouch TanYaap

Char AmpilKhanLech

Kdan Vial,Poam (Angkep Baok in oldmap)10, Kdan

Bati Tnaot Pey,Tanop

Samraon Srar SrarKhanLech

Kirivon

KompongSpeu Phnom Sroch PreyRamdoul Kaptouk

Ou KlanTatan

Kandal KsachKandal PreekLeon PreekTaon

PreekTakou PreekBonkon,PreekTakou PreekAmpil PreekAmpil

PonnyaLeu PonnyaLeu TuolOmpal KiengSvay

MukKampol KandalStun Saan

Phnom Penh RusseyKaew KohDach Lvea,Chungkoh,Kbalkoh,KohDach,Roneah PreyVeng Sitow Kandal PreekChankran PreekTapok

KompongCham KanMeas Sdaw Sdaw

RokarKoy RokarKoy

KompongSiam KorKoor CamkarSensep,KorKoor

Krouchmar Trea Trea1,Trea2,Trea3,Trea4,Trea5,Cham villagealongMekongriverneartheborder ofKrachieprovince

Samraon*11 KohSotin Lvie PreekTakou12 BonteayMeanchey Phnom Srok PaoyChar PaoyChar

Siam Reap Siam Reap ChotSam*

SreySnom

ToukChor* Uddow Meanchey ChungKal

Note:Theauthormadethistablebased on Tanaka (2013),Morimoto (1998,2008),Asahi(2011,2012), Kojin(2004),Iwanaga(2003,2005),Kong(2013)13,whichareJapanesepublications,andThePhnom Penh Post(2010a,2010b,2010c).In thosereferences,ifthereareconfusionsin thenamesofvillagesand communes,theauthor hasrevised thespellingsbased on NIS (2008),NCDD (2014)14,andAmakawa (2004).ThenamesofsomeareasweretranslatedintoEnglish from Japanesepublicationsandsosome Englishspellingsofthenamesmaybedifferentfrom thepronunciationsinKhmer.

(5)

andtheweaversinTakewweavingforNGO-C.Thisisleftforfurtherinvestigationinthefuture. InadditiontothoseareasinCambodiawherepeopleproducesilkthreadandweaveikat silk,similarikatsilkiswoveninnearbycountriesasfollows15.

◆ Thailand:BuriLam province,Surinprovince,SirisaketprovinceinNorthEastThailand

wheretheKhmerorLao-Khmerlive.

◆ Vietnam:Tropeang Chrau village,Van Giao commune(nearChau Doc),An Giang

provinceinSouthernVietnam

◆ Indonesia:Sumatra ◆ Myanmar

◆ China:Hainanisland

◆ ThePhilippines:Mindanaoisland ◆ Malaysia

ConsideringthatthemotifsandtheculturalandreligiousmeaningsofPidanareuniqueto Cambodia,theauthorputapriorityonconductingasurveyintheareasnexttoCambodia. TheseareasareNorth-EastThailandandSouthernVietnam whereethnicKhmerlive.

Thekeyfieldworkschedulewasthefollowing.On21March2015,theauthormetMr. SIYONN Sophearith,Lecturer,RoyalUniversityofFineArts,Cambodia,todiscussaboutthe objectivesoftheresearchandplanning.Onthesameday,theauthoralsohadameetingwith Mr.KONG Vireak,Director,NationalMuseum ofCambodia(NMC),toobtaininformationon PidankeptattheMuseum.Theauthorconsultedhim aboutthepossibilityofutilizingthese researchfindingstorequestthatCambodianikatsilkweavingand/orPidanbeacknowledgedby UNESCOasanIntangibleCulturalHeritageinthefuture.TheauthoralsometMs.SAM Thida, DeputyDirector,NMC.ShehelpedtheauthortoholdPidanexhibitionsatNMCin2010and 2014bycoordinatingwiththetextileteam ofNMC.

In April2015,theHEIWA (peace)-NAKAJIMA Foundation pledgedtoprovideresearch funding for this survey.Mr.SIYONN Sophearith drafted a field survey schedule.He conducted afield survey insideCambodia,including Takew province,which isfamousfor silk weaving.In August2015,theauthorvisitedCambodiatofinalisetheplanning ofthe survey in North-EastThailandwith Mr.SIYONN andMs.SEKIGUCHIfrom CYK.From 9 to 14 September 2015,theresearch team conducted a field study in Surin and Ubon RachataniinNorth-EastThailand.Mr.SIYONN continuedhisfieldsurveyinsideCambodia visiting Takew,Siem Reap,andotherprovinces.On 1719August2016,theresearchteam membersvisitedAnGiangprovinceinSouthernVietnam.

Theresearchteam consistedofsevenpeople.Table2showsthenamesandrolesofthe members.Theresearchteam deployedtoNorth-EastThailandconsistedofmembersnos.1,2,3, andtheauthor(7).Theresearchteam deployedtoSouthernVietnam consistedofmembers nos.4,5,6,andtheauthor(7).

(6)

3.TheresearchfindingsinSurinandUbonRachataniinNorth-EastThailand from 9to14September2015

Beforethisfieldsurvey,theauthorhadassumedthatinNorth-EastThailand,peopledidnot activelyweavePidan.However,thisassumptionwasoverturnedduringthisfieldsurvey.The villagersstillactively raisesilk-wormsand produceikatsilk cloth forsampothol(skirt madeofsilk)andPidan.Someworkshops,notably,produceveryhigh-qualitysilkclothwith traditionalandcreativemotifs.Whyarepeoplestillactivelyproducingikatsilkthere? 31.Surin

The research team visited the silk weaving workshops and a village where people producesilkthreadsbyraisingsilk-worms.

311.TheWorkshopofMr.S

Mr.S,aThaiwhoismarriedtoaCambodianwoman,weavesmotifsofPidanastheyare woveninCambodia,includingnaga,tree-of-life,birds,animals,andflowers(SeeFigure2). Heonlyusesnaturaldyes,includingindigo,forhissilk.Consideringthesocialchangesthat havemadehiscraftararity,hereasonablyclaimsthatinThailandnobodyelsebuthecan dyemorethanonecolorwithnaturaldye.

Table2.Thenameandroleofeachmemberoftheresearchteam Name,title,organisation Roleintheteam 1 Mr.SIYONN Sophearith,ABD,

Lecturer,DepartmentofArchaeology, RoyalUniversityofFineArts,Cambodia

MainResearcher.ConductresearchinCambodia andNorth-EastThailand.

2 Ms.SEKIGUCHIHarumi,Advisor, CaringforYoungKhmer RepresentativeinCambodia,

PidanProjectTeam

Coordinateresearch in Cambodiaand North-East Thailand.AccountinginCambodia.

Resourceperson 3 Ms.KampoyTONGNAM (Peap),

Researchassistant,

formerCYK weavingtraininginstructor

Communication,logistics,interpretation,etc.for researchinSurin,Thailand.

Resourceperson 4 Ms.INOU Mayu,Representative,

Seed-to-Table,Vietnam CommuniresearchicatinAnGion,logiang,Vistics,ietnam.nterpretation,etc.for 5 Ms.KIM Kha,FormerHeadofWomen・s

UnioninSShamlet,Vietnam ResearchAssiweaversinSShamlstant.Formedacooperatiet,Vietnam. veof Resourceperson

6 Dr.MIYAMOTO Kazuko,

Professor,YamanashiUniversity Member,PidanProjectTeam

Analysecollectedinformationandassessthe directionofresearch

7 Dr.YONEKURA Yukiko,Associate Professor,ShowaWomen・sUniversity RepresentativeinJapan,

PidanProjectTeam

ResearchTeam Leader.Compileandanalyse collectedinformationandwritereports. Coordinatebetweenresearchteam members, researchassistants,andinterpreters.

(7)

Hisfour-meterlongsilkclothwithsacredmotifswouldsellforadecentpriceof120,000 THB16(about3,600USD).Thistypeofsilkclothisproducedonorderoronacommissionbasis.

Accordingtohim,youngpeoplethesedaysmoveoutofhisweavingvillagefor・better・work inothercitiesorplaceswithareasonassimpleasthatweavingisboring.However,withthe government・ssupport,especiallythatoftheQueenMotherCenter,hehasputforthgreatefforts totrainyoungpeoplepassionateaboutweavingbytravellingtovariousplacesinThailand. 312.Makingsilkthreadsfrom goldencocoonsinP village

WhentheauthoraskedMr.Sfrom whereheobtainssilkthreads,heintroducedustoP village.InPvillage,about300householdsraisesilk-worms,morethan120householdsmake silk threads,andabout1516householdsweavesilk cloth.Silk threadproduction involves theentirevillage(SeeFigure3).Formaintainingtheirenthusiasm andcommitmenttosilk productionandweaving,thevillagersformedasilkresourcecenterinthevillageformutual assistanceandtoraiseawarenessofsilkproductionandweaving.

Figure2.PidanwovenattheworkshopofMr.S

High-qualityPidanwovenattheworkshopofMr.S High-qualityPidanwithreligiousmotifs, Buddha・simage,wovenattheworkshopofMr.S

Figure3.SilkthreadproductioninP village

(8)

313.TheWorkshopofMr.V

TheworkshopofMr.VdoesnotweavePidan,butthisworkshopgivesgoodtipsonhowto makeagoodnetprofit.Thisworkshopproducesaverysophisticatedandcomplicatedhi gh-qualitysilktextile,whichlookslikeembroidery.Atthisworkshop,aweaverearns230THB (about6.9USD)perday,andaweaver・sassistantearns200THB (about6USD)perday. Sincemostoftheweaversweremiddle-agedorolderpeoplewhohavedifficultiesinbecoming migrantworkers,thisincomefrom weaving isimportanteven though theirearningsare minimal.Tooperateoneloom requiresfourweavers.Theycanonlyweavefivecentimeters aday,and itrequiresonemonth toproducelessthan twometers.Thisprocessisti me-consuming(SeeFigure4).However,theintensiveworkisworthitsincetheworkshopcan sellabout3.2metersofthishigh-qualitysilktextilefor250,000THB(about7,500USD).The author calculatesthatthelabor costofoneloom to produce3.2 metersisabout1,536 USD~1,792USD17.Thismeanstheworkshopcan makeareasonablenetprofiteven after deductingthecostsofothermaterialsforproducingthishigh-qualitysilktextile.

314.TheWorkshopofMr.B,D village

Mr.B producessilkclothwhensomeoneordersorcommissionsit.Thepriceofatwo meterlongnagamotifsilkclothusingnaturaldyeis20,000THB (about600USD).Ittakes 2.5monthstoproduceitstarting from tying and dyeing thethreadstoweaving it.The weavingalonetakestwoweeks.Remarkably,hehasalsoinventedaweavingmachinewhich canweave2metersofsilkinonly3days.

Mr.B・sworkshophasproducedmanyworkswithsophisticatedmotifs.Oneofthem isthe silkclothwiththemotifofintertwinednagas.Hisworkshopsellssilkclothswithvariousmotifs atcompetitiveprices.Thepriceofafour-meterlongsilkclothwithadiamondmotifis15,000 THB (about450USD),onewiththenagamotifofPidanis50,000THB (about1,500USD) (SeeFigure5).Thepricesarehigheratthesouvenirshopfortourists.Thepriceofafour meterlongPidanwiththenagamotifisabout120,000THB(about3,600USD)~160,000THB (about4,800USD).

Figure4.TheWorkshopofMr.V

AttheworkshopofMr.V.Fourweavers

(9)

Mr.B usedtoliketextileswhenhewasyoung,butsociallyitwasnotcommonformen toweaveinhishomevillage.Whenhewasabout16or17yearsold,hedecidedtoemigrate for construction work and other careers including joining a traditionalmusicaltroupe. However,hisdesiresanddreamsfortextileproduction madehim return tohisvillageto takeonaweavingcareerfouryearslater.Hestartedtodesignandconstructhisworkshop byhimselfusingdiscardedwoodlogsleftoverfrom illegalloggingintheneighborhood.His businessbegan with 6 weaversand 6 looms.Even withoutgovernmentsupport,hehas managedtoexpandhisbusiness.Todayhehasforty-twopeopleworkinginhisworkshop. 315.TheWorkshopofMr.Y,Svillage

Thisworkshopproducessilkclothwiththemotifsofnaga,tree-of-life,ships,etc.(SeeFigure 6).TheyarethemotifsofPidan.Yet,theweaversdonotcallthem holpidanbutrather・sotpros (men・ssilk).・Sotprosarenotworn in daily life,butthey areusedon differentreligious occasions,forinstancewrappingasacredritualobjectknownasbaisarai,forwrappingthe deceasedforafuneral,forthedressingofcandidatesinmonkordinationceremonies,andfor

High-qualityPidanwithnagamotifsdesignedby

Mr.B andwovenathisworkshop Mr.B・sworkshopbuiltwithdiscardedwoodenlogs

Figure5.PidansoldattheWorkshopofMr.B andnearbysouvenirshops

Ordinary-qualityPidanandikatsilksoldatsouvenir

(10)

dressingforweddings.Theycanalsobehungonwallsandceilings.Asatraditioninthearea, peopleneitherwearsilkclothswithmotifsofBuddhaandpagodasnordonatethem topagodas. Silkclothswithsuchmotifsarewovenonorderofcustomersfrom Sisaket,Ubontani,etc.

Inthisvillagethenumberofweaversisremarkablylow;about10peopleweaveoutofabout 200households.Moreover,comparedtootherworkshopswhichtheauthorhasvisited,the qualityofsilkweavinginthisworkshopisnotexcellentbutordinary.Thepriceofatwo meterlongnagamotifsilkclothis2,000THB (about60USD).Despitethis,asenseofpride inweavingasavocationhasparticularlytakenholdamongtheworkshop・syoungmembers. From thiscanbeinferredincreasedchancesfortheweavingtradition・scontinuedsurvival. 316.T village

Theresearchersmetsomesilkweaversinthisvillageofmorethan390households.The weaversthemselvesdidnotknow how manypeopleweavesilkintheirvillage.WemetMs.SS, age60,and Ms.PT,age40.Ms.SS weavesaverticalstripemotifsilk cloth common in Surin,andpeacockmotifs,etc.TheytellusthatpeopledonotweavePidan,whichshehas neverheardof.Sheweaveselephantmotifsilk cloth recently,butnotforwearing.People hangitonwallsduringauspiciousceremoniessuchasweddings,housewarmingceremonies, etc.Peoplealsousesilkclothtowrapthedeceasedforfunerals.Monksaresometimesthe recipientsofdonatedsilkcloth.

Ms.SStoldtheresearchteam thatshehadneverheardofPidanandshestatedthat she did not weave it.However,the elephant motifs of ikat silk for hanging at the ceremoniesand notforwearing werethesamemotifsofPidan in Cambodia.Thewhite elephantsarethemotifsrelevanttoBuddhism (SeeFigure7).

Inthisvillage,silkthreadsarenotproducedbutboughtfrom Pecchabunprovince.Theprice ofsilkthreadsis800THB(24USD)perkilogram.Toproduceasilkcloth,ittakesabouttwo weekstotie,dye,andweavethesilk(about8daystoweave).Ms.PTweavespictorialsilkfor

Figure6.PidansoldattheWorkshopofMr.Y

Ordinary-qualityPidanwovenattheWorkshop

(11)

customers.Thepriceofan8meter(about2kuben)longsilkclothisabout10,000THB (300 USD),from whichsheearnsanet-incomeofabouthalfofthesellingprice,about150USD. Sincemostoftheweaversweremiddle-agedorolderpeoplewhohavedifficultiesinbecoming migrantworkers,thisincomefrom weavingisimportanteventhoughtheamountisminimal.

Theauthorconsidersthisnet-incometobebetterthanthatinCambodia.InCambodia,the priceofimportedsilkthreadshaveincreasedfrom anaverageof25USDperkgin2008to55USD perkg in 2013whilethepriceofsilk cloth hasdecreased from 70USD per1kuben (3.8 meters)in2007to40~50USD per1kubenin 201018.Thenetincomefrom producing1kuben decreasedto14~19USD.Therefore,ifaweavercan produceandsella2kuben long silk cloth,thenet-incomecanbe28~38USD afterdeductingthecostsofsilkthreadsanddye. 32.UbonRachaternee

321.TheWorkshopofMr.M

TheworkshopofMr.M19seemstofinanciallysustainitselfandbeindependent,asituation apparently facilitated by thevariousawardshehasreceived forthehigh quality ofhis worksofsilk.Hereceivesno financialsupportfrom eithertheThaigovernmentorthe Queen SirikitFoundation.Commercially heseemstobevery successful.Forexample,one bankhasaskedhim toproduceoriginal,specialsilkgiftsforthebank・sspecialcustomers (SeeFigure8).

TheancestorsofMr.M workedashigh-ranking governmentofficialsforgenerations. Mr.M isfrom aprestigiousfamilywhichisverywell-knowninthearea.Hismotherused toproducetextiles.Itwashismotherwhoinspiredhim totakeonaweavingcareerafter workingformanyyearsasaflightattendant.Hisworkshopproducesveryhighqualityand expensivesilk cloth including Pidan.Mr.M designsoriginalmotifsand inventsoriginal techniques.About90% ofhisweaversconsistoflocalpeopleandabout5% consistofpeople from outsidethecommunitywhomovedinduetomarriage.

Figure7.OrdinaryikatsilkwithpeacockmotifsandPidanwoveninT village

(12)

Mr.M hasinheritedfrom hismotherandcollectedquitearemarkablenumberoftraditional weavingtoolsandequipment.Duringtheresearchers・visit,hewasconstructingamuseum nexttohisworkshopforthepreservationandexhibitionoftraditionaltoolsandequipment. Heaimedtoopenthemuseum in2016.Healsoconsentedtoshow ushispersonalcollection ofhundredsofpiecesofextremelyhigh-qualityPidan.

33.TheresearchfindingsinNorth-EastThailand

Asawhole,Mr.SIYONN Sophearith,themainresearcheridentifiesfivekeypointsabout silkweavinginSurinandUbonRachatanibasedonhisinterviews.First,peopleweavefortheir living.InSurin,peopleproducethepictorialikatsilkclothwithsacredmotifsknownbythe KhmerslivinginCambodiaasPidanonlywhencustomersorderorcommissionit.Thepictorial ikatsilkclothisnotcalledholPidanasinCambodia.Instead,itiscalledbyitsmotifs,for example,holrupneak,asilkclothwithnaga(multiple-headedserpent),orsometimescalledsot pros(men・ssilk).Second,weaverswhoproducesilkclothhavediversereasonsandinterests. Forexample,Mr.B20expressesastrongcommitmenttoweavingasthepreservationofalocal

TheentrancetotheWorkshopofMr.M Mr.M・soriginallydesignedsilk

Figure8.TheWorkshopofMr.M

(13)

tradition,andasawaytomakealiving.Mr.Y,ayoungman,seemstousehisvillage・s traditionalweavingtechniquestofollow today・spopulartrendinThailand.Third,weaving communities gain supportand favor from the public,and also from the Royalfamily, particularlytheQueenSirikitFoundation.Fourth,thedemandfortraditionalsilkishigher inThailandthanthedemandinCambodia.TheThaigovernmenthasapolicyofpromoting theuseofsilk.Lastly,asMr.Sstated,difficultyinobtainingnaturalmaterialsfornatural dyecanbeaseriouschallengeforproducingnaturallydyedsilkclothinthefuture.

Afterthisfieldsurvey,theauthorcametotheconclusionthatthemainreasonforthe survivalandpopularityofsilkclothproductioninNorth-EastThailandisbecausethesilk producers and weavers are able to earn a reasonable netincome while taking pride in preservingtheirlongweavingtradition.RegardingwhatkindsofmotifsofPidanarewoven there,mostmotifsaretraditionalmotifsthatarealready known exceptthenaga motifs newlydesignedbyMr.B.

4.ThefieldsurveyinAnGianginSouthernVietnam from 17to19August2016 ThreeJapaneseresearchteam membersvisitedAnGiangprovinceinSouthernVietnam from 17to19August2016.Ontheafternoonof17August,theresearchersexploredChauDoc MarketandthecityofChauDoclookingforhand-wovencloths.Theteam onlyfoundoneshop inthemarketsellingsomesmallbags.Thosebagsweremadebyethnicminorities,accordingto theseller.Also,asouvenirshop in theVictoriaChau Dochotelsold someclothsbutno Pidan(SeeFigure9).

ChauDocMarket VictoriaChauDocHotel

Figure9.ChauDocMarketandKhmer-stylepagodas

(14)

41.SShamlet

On 18August,researchersvisitedSS hamletwith theguidanceofMs.Kim,aformer representativeofthewomen・sunioninSShamlet.Ms.Kim supportedandcoordinatedvillage femaleweaverstoform acooperativetoreviveweavinginSShamletin1999.SinceVietnam is aone-partystateunderasocialistregime,stronggovernmentsupportwasnecessaryforMs. Kim,awomen・sunionrepresentative,toform acooperative.In1987,thevillagershadtofleethe hamlettoSocTrangandTraVinhfor23yearsbecauseofthearmedfightingattheborderof Cambodia.AfterthevillagerscouldreturntoSShamlet,womenwantedtostartweavingagain. TheydiscussedandconsultedwithMs.Kim abouttheirdesire.Theyformedacooperativeand startedtoweaveagainin1999.Ms.N ledthegroupof12womenwhowantedtoweave.

They woveand sold fortheirfamiliesinsidethehamlet.Atitspeak,thenumberof weaversreached about300people,buttoday lessthan 100peopleweave21.Young people prefertomigratetowork,forexample,in theindustrialareain Dong Naiprovince,far beyondHoChiMinhcity.MerchantsoftheCham ethnicgroup22comefrom Cambodiato buysilkforlaterresale.TheirmarketisnotVietnam butCambodia.

Ms.N broughtouttheirhand-woven silk,including Pidan,and showed them to the researchteam.Whentheauthoraskedabouthow theyusesuchsilkcloth,sherepliedthat theyuseitforweddings(SeeFigure10).Whenadaughtergetsmarried,hermotherweaves andgivestwopiecesofsilk cloth tothedaughter.Peopleusesilk asadepositwhen they borrow money.PeoplesometimesalsodonatesilktoPagodas.

A Pidanbeingwoven TiedanddyedsilkthreadsforPidan

Thisordinary-qualityPidan(90cm x290cm)was1.5 millionVND23(67.6USD byanexchangerateof1 USD=22,200VND)

Thisordinary-qualityPidan(90cm x290cm)was1.5 millionVND (67.6USD byanexchangerateof1 USD=22,200VND)

(15)

Shebuyssilkthreadsfrom Lam Dong,nearDaLat.Inthepast,theyusedtoraisesil k-wormsand practicenaturaldyeing.However,recently naturaldyeisvery expensiveand thus difficultto buy.Ittakes two or three months to produce one piece ofikatsilk includingdyeingthethreads.Withinthattime,weavingtakesahalf-month(SeeFigure11).

Ms.N hasstoppedweavingduetofailingeyesightasshehasgrownolder.Shehasbeen succeededasaweaverbyhereldestdaughter,Ms.NS(age51).Ms.NS,however,hasalso beguntoexperienceworseningeyesight.

Anexampleofthecostsandbenefitsofweavingisthefollowing.Ifthepriceofsilkis 1millionVND,thematerials,includingsilkthreadsanddye,costabout40% andthelabor costs60%.They considerthelaborcosttobeabout25,000VND (about1USD)perday. They stateasan examplethatthemonthly salary ofa factory workerisabout4to 5 million VND (181.18USD~225.23USD with an exchangerateof1USD=22,200VND).To work atthefactories,theworkershaveto pay fortheirown living expensesforhouse-rents,foods,transportation,etc,butifbothawifeandhusbandworkatthefactoriesand thewholefamilymigrates,itisaffordable.

Forexample,theauthorboughttwopiecesofPidaninSShamlet.ThesizeofthePidan was90cm x 294cm.Thepricewas1.5million VND (67.6USD with an exchangerateof1 USD=22,200VND).Thevillagerstoldusthatthelaborcostis60% oftheprice.Itmeans thatthelaborcostwas40.6USD toproducethisPidan.Ittakestwotothreemonthsfrom dyeingthreadstoweaving.OneproducercanmakeseveralpiecesofPidaninparallelwhile tyinganddyeingneedstimetodrywhileonecancontinueweaving.Orifseveralproducers cooperateand dividetheirrolesoftying and dyeing threads,and weaving,they may be producingnotonlyonePidanbutseveralPidanconcurrently.Thisisanimportantsource ofincomeforweaverswhostayinthehamletsincemostofthem aremiddle-agedorolder people.Theyhavelessalternativeoccupationalchoices.Also,sincethelivingexpensesinthe

Figure10.Theweavers・cooperativeandPidanwoveninSShamlet

TiedanddyedsilkthreadsforPidanwithBuddhist

(16)

hamletarelessthantheoutside,thisincomefrom weavingisadvantageouseventhoughthe amountislessthanthewageoffactorywork.

TheauthorconsidersthisnetincometobebetterthanthatinCambodia.Asdescribed insection316,duetothepriceincreaseofimportedsilkthreadsinCambodiain2010,the netincomeofproducing 1kuben ofsilk cloth decreased to 14~19USD.Therefore,ifa weavercan produceandsella2kuben long silk cloth,thenetincomecan be28~38USD afterdeductingthecostsofsilkthreadsanddye.

TheresearchersleftSShamletandvisitedtheKhmer-styleVR Pagoda.ThePagodawas undergoingrenovations.Accordingtothevillagers,VR PagodausedtohavePidanhanging

Figure11.OrdinaryikatsilkwoveninSShamlet

Traditionalwoodenthreadshuttles Silkthreadsbroughtfrom outsidethevillage Ordinary-qualityikatsilk Ordinary-qualityikatsilkforclothing

(17)

ondisplaybeforethestartoftherenovations.Therenovationsaretakingalongtimedue toalackofavailablefunding.Fundingeffortsareongoing,withindividualdonationsoften rangingfrom 410,000VND to520,000VND (SeeFigure12).

After the researchers left the pagoda,we also visited the Khmer Textile Weaving Training Center,Van Giao commune,Tinh Bien district(SeeFigure13).Thegovernment constructeditwithfundsofabout25,000USD (about2.5millionyen).

Figure12.Khmer-stylepagodanearbySShamlet

A buildinginsidethecompoundofVR pagoda

GateofVR pagoda Wall paintings of VR pagoda created with the supportofdonationsfrom localpeople

Figure13.TheKhmerTextileWeavingTrainingCenterconstructedbythegovernmentnearSS hamlet

ThegovernmentconstructedtheKhmerTextile

WeavingTrainingCenter,VanGiaocommune TheVipromotietnamesegovernmenthasa polngthetextilesoftheKhmer,anethniicy ofc minority

(18)

42.TheresearchfindingsinSouthernVietnam

Inconclusion,regardingwhatkindsofmotifsofPidanwoveninSShamletinSouthern Vietnam,allmotifsaretraditionalmotifsthatarecommon in Cambodia.Afterthisfield survey,the author came to the conclusion that the main reason for the survivaland popularity ofsilk cloth production in SS hamletin Southern Vietnam isbecausethesilk producersand weaversareableto earn a reasonablenetincome,whiletaking pridein preservingtheirlongweavingtradition.

5.Conclusion

Before conducting these field surveys,the author had assumed that not only in Cambodiabutalsoin N orth-EastThailandandSouthern Vietnam peopleprobably didnot actively weavePidan today.However,thefindingsofthesefield surveysoverturned this assumption (SeeTable3).In fact,in N orth-EastThailand,thereareyoung weaverswho choosetoweaveikatsilkintheirhomevillagesafterreturningfrom migrantwork.Some youthschooseweavingasanoccupation.TheyweaveikatsilkandPidantosell.Theyseem tobesuccessful.AlsoinNorth-EastThailand,therearesomeweaverswhoareweavingvery high-quality expensive ikat silk on order from customers. Since those weavers have customerswhopayhighpricesandappreciatethehighqualityofikatsilk,itisworthwhile fortheweaverstoweavehigh-quality ikatsilk andalsoPidan with pictorialmotifs,even though the production process is quite time- and labor-consuming.Also,in Southern Vietnam,femaleweaversweaveikatsilk including Pidan sincemerchantsorderand buy theirproductstosellinCambodia.Inshort,individualweaverscanearnreasonablenetincomes afterdeductingthecostofmaterialsincludingsilkthreads,dye,toolsandlooms.Also,in both countries,many weaversweremiddle-aged orolderwomen who havedifficultiesin becomingmigrantworkers.Therefore,theincomefrom producingsilkclothisimportantfor thosewhohavefeweralternativeoccupationalchoices.

RegardingwhatkindsofmotifsofPidanarewoveninNorth-EastThailand,theauthor observed thatmostmotifsaretraditionalmotifsalready recorded exceptthenaga motifs newly designed by Mr.B.In SS hamletin Southern Vietnam,allmotifsaretraditional motifsthatarecommoninCambodia.

Comparing such situations ofactive weaving in N orth-EastThailand and Southern Vietnam with the situation in Cambodia where young weavers decide to work at the factories,theauthorcouldidentifysomesimilarpointsinactivesilkweavinginNorth-East ThailandandSouthernVietnam.First,somehavecustomerswhoarewillingtoorderikat silkandpayhighprices.InCambodia,weaversstruggletomakeendsmeetduetorather high costsofimported materials24and a lack ofsuch demand forhigh-quality expensive ikatsilk.Second,asMr.Sdescribes,theroyalfamilyandthegovernmentofThailandhas policiestopromotetheproductionoftraditionalikatsilk.Also,inVietnam,thegovernment

(19)

supported the women・s union leader to form a weavers・cooperative in SS hamletand constructed the Khmer Textile Weaving Training Center.Such supportive government policiesareratherweakinCambodia25.Third,goodqualitysilkthreadsandthematerials tomakedyes,eithernaturalorchemical,areproducedinThailandandVietnam.Thecosts ofmaterialsofsilkproductionseem tobelessthaninCambodia.Thismeansthatthenet profitsofindividualweaverscan berelatively higher in Thailand and Vietnam than in Cambodia26.Thesepointsseem to encourageand motivatemoreweaversto continueto produceikatsilkinThailandandVietnam thaninCambodia.

Basedonthesefindingsfrom thesurveysinNorth-EastThailandandSouthernVietnam, theauthor identifiesseveralfactorscontributing to thesurvivaloftraditionalikatsilk weaving,includingPidan.First,theweaversinbothcountriestendtoexpressaloveof,and

Table3.FindingsonproductionandsalesofsilkclothsandPidansinNorth-EastThailand andSouthernVietnam duringthefieldsurveyinSeptember2015andAugust2016*

Country Province Village/ hamlet/ workshop/ NGO Hi gh-quality Pidan Ordi - nary-quality Pidan/ ikat silk Hi gh-quality silk textile Hi gh-quality ikat silk Young succe-sors

Silkthread Pri ceoftwo-metersilktextile (USD)

Thai

-land Surin Mr.S*** ○ × × ○ youthsTrain MadeiThailandn 1,800 Mr.V

un-known × ○ knownun- un-known 4,700

Mr.B ○ × × ○ ○ 225~750 Mr.Y × ○ × × ○ 60 T village × ○ × × unseen 75 Ubon Mr.M × Train youths unknown Vi

et-nam AnGiang SS × ○ × × Met1young weaver

Madein

Vietnam 46

Cam-bodia** Takew villages

× ○ × × Some

imported invillage 21~26 atmarkets/shops inTakew & Phnom Penh 40~200 Phnom Penh NGO-C*** ○ × ○ ○ Traiyouthsn imported/ Madein Cambodia plainsilkcloth 40~54 ikatsilk 126~156 Pidan 400~1,400 Siam

Reap workshop-I*** ○ × ○ ○ ○ MadeiCambodina ~3,000 *Theauthormadethistablebasedontheinterviews.・○・standsfor・producing・.

・×・standsfor・notproducing・.・Unknown・meansthattheauthordidnotask.

**SeeTable1forareaswheretheyusedtoproducesilkthreadsorclothbutthecurrentsituationis unknown.TheauthorvisitedandinterviewedNGO-C in20132017andworkshop-Iin2011.

(20)

pridein,thistraditionalikatsilk.Second,in addition to thisloveoftheircrafts,what motivatespeopleinNorth-EastThailandandSouthernVietnam toproducetraditionalikat silk weaving seems to be the reasonable net profits available for individualweavers. Otherwise,someyouthsinNorth-EastThailandwithalternativeoccupationalchoiceswould notchooseweaving.Also,formiddle-agedorolderpeoplewhohavenootherchoiceslike becomingmigrantworkers,incomefrom weavingishighlyadvantageous.Whatseemstobe crucialtoallow thesurvivaloftraditionalikatsilkweaving,includingPidancouldbe:the marketdemandforhigh-pricedikatsilk;andtheaccessandlow-costofikatsilkproduction materials.Thegovernmentpoliciesorpatronageofroyalfamiliespromotingtheproduction oftraditionalikatsilkseem tobehelpfulbutnotessential.

Therefore,forthesurvivaloftheendangeredweavingtechniqueandmotifsoftraditional Pidan,new andincreasingcustomers・demandsandnew marketsforPidanandtheaccess to low-costproduction materialsseem to becrucial.Theymotivatepeopleto continueto masterthetechniqueand carry itforward tosucceeding generations.Iftheexcellenceof high-qualityPidanisacknowledgedasanendangeredintangibleculturalheritageandbecomes betterknownaroundtheworld,itmaycreateanexpandedcustomerbaseandmarketdemand, therebyhelpingweaverstocontinuethispreciousculturalheritage.

[Notes]

1 TheauthorsincerelyappreciatestheresearchfundpartlyprovidedbyHEIWA (peace)-NAKAJIMA Foundation,Tokyo,JapantoconductthisfieldsurveyforApril2015March2016.Yet,theauthoris solelyresponsibleforanymisunderstandingsormistakesstatedinthisreport.

2 ItisknowninCambodiaasNeakPoan. 3 SeeUemura(2003)andIwanaga(2003). 4 SeeYonekura(2014).

5 ・USD・standsfor・USdollar・. 6 SeethePhnom PenhPost(2016).

7 A factoryworkerwhom theauthorinterviewedinTakew on28August2016alsosaidthatifshe worked long hours,she could geta monthly netincome ofabout190 USD after deducting transportationcosts.

8 SeeYonekura(2014). 9 SeeYonekura(2014).

10 AccordingtoIwanaga(2003),Poam villageisnexttotheeastsideofKdanvillage.Accordingto NCDD (2014),thereisnorecordofPoam villagein Kdan communebutthereisavillagecalled Peem inKompongReapcommune,PreyKavasdistrict.

11 According to NCDD (2014),Samraon village exists in the Krouchmar commune,Krouchmar district,butthereisnoSamraonvillageinothercommunesinKrouchmardistrict.

12 AccordingtoNCDD (2014),thereisPrekTakaevillagebutnoPreekTakouvillage.

13 According to Kong (2013),mostof1700 householdsidentified asdoing weaving lived in the5 villagesshowninTable1,intheKohDachweavingproductioncommunitylocatedabout10km north-eastofPhnom Penh.Kong(2013)didnotstatethenamesoftheprovincescontainingmajor silk-producing areas,buttheauthorcross-checked thelocationsbased on theotherpublications

(21)

andintegratedthem intoTable1.Theauthordidnotinclude・LoveaPrekChrey,LeukDek,Peam Chor,LoveaEm・inTable1sincethenamesoftheprovinceswheretheyexistedinwereunknown. Kongdescribedthattheyare・locatedinbetweentheMekongriverandtheTokriver・.

14 TheCambodiangovernmentsetupTheNationalCommitteeforSub-nationalDemocraticDevelopment (NCDD)in2008.

15 SeeYonekura(2014).

16 ・THB・standsfor・ThaiBaht・.

17 Thesimplecalculation oflaborcostis:(320cm/5cm)daysx 6~7USD/day x 4weavers=1,536 USD~1,792USD.

18 SeeYonekura(2014).

19 Tovisitthisworkshop,itisessentialtohavesomeconnectionwiththosewhoknowMr.M personally. TheresearchersappreciatesincerelythatonetextileexperthaskindlyintroducedustoMr.M. 20 Hewas39yearsold.

21 Thereare544householdsinSShamlettoday.

22 EthnicCham peopleinCambodiaalsoweave・Pidan・.TheirreligionisIslam. 23 ・VND・standsfor・VietnameseDong・.

24 SeeYonekura(2014). 25 SeeYonekura(2014).

26 Asdescribedin section 3-1-6,duetothepriceincreaseofimportedsilk threadsin Cambodiain 2010,thenetincomeofproducing1kubenofsilkclothdecreasedto14~19USD afterdeducting thecostsofsilkthreadsanddye.

[ReferencesinEnglish]

TheCambodiaDaily,31December2013.・SeniorGovernmentOfficialsRebuffOpposition Protesters・ Demands・.TheCambodiaDaily.Phnom Penh.

,20January2014a.・InternationalBrandsSeekProbeIntoProtestKillings・.TheCambodia Daily.Phnom Penh.

,31January2014b.・Madehere,ownedthere・.TheCambodiaDaily.Phnom Penh. ,7February2014c.・Threatof・massStrike・looms・.TheCambodiaDaily.Phnom Penh. Green,G.,2003,TraditionalTextilesofCambodia,RiverBooks,Bangkok.

,2008,PictorialCambodianTextiles,RiverBooks,Bangkok.

TheNationalCommitteeforSub-NationalDemocraticDevelopment(NCDD),・AboutNCDD・.<http:// www.ncdd.gov.kh/en/about-ncdd>,・NCDD DatabasesCambodiaGazetteerGazetteerDatabase Online・.<db.ncdd.gov.kh/gazetteer/view/index.castle>accessedon26February2014.

TheNationalInstituteofStatistics(NIS),2008,GeneralPopulationCensusofCambodia2008,Ministry ofPlanning,Phnom Penh.

ThePhnom Penh Post,3November1995.・Reviving thetraditionsofkhmerweaving・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh.

,26October2001.・SilkweavingtradeofLivSaEm underthreat・.ThePhnom PenhPost. Phnom Penh.

,26March2009a.・Silkindustryhitbydownturn・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh. ,22September2009b.・Silk importssettoslideassectorsuffersfrom crisis・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh.

,6January,2010a.・Silkvillagestrugglestosurvive・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh. ,4November2010b.・Highsilkpricesconcerncraftsmen・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh. ,28December2010c.・Hopefortraditionalsilkfarmers・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh.

(22)

,1February2011.・Weaversneedledbysilkprice・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh. ,11September2012.・Importedrawsilkgetscheaper・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh. ,28January2013a.・Officialsdraftsub-decreetodevelopthesilksector・.ThePhnom Penh Post.Phnom Penh.

,15March2013b.・Weavinganew futureforsilk・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh. ,3June2013c.・Nationalsilkboardplanned・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh. ,23December2013d.・Passion forsilk bringsJapaneseexperttoCambodia・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh.

,28July2016.・Asgarmentminimum wagetalksbegin,othersectorswantin・.ThePhnom PenhPost.Phnom Penh.

Siyonn,S.2008.PIDAN (BITAN)INKHMER CULTURE,REYUM,Phnom Penh.

Uemura,K.2003.・Cambodian TextileCulture・.TheTextilesofCambodia.Fukuoka ArtMuseum. Fukuoka,Japan,pp.153159.

Wolfarth,J.2017.・HolPidan:CambodianTraditionalPictorialSilkTextilePreservationandDevelopment, attheNationalMuseum ofCambodia,2016・.SoutheastofNow:Directionsin Contemporaryand ModernArtinAsia.Volume1,Number1,March2017,NUSPressPteLtd.,pp.205213.<https:// muse.jhu.edu/article/646482>accessed19February2017.

[ReferencesinJapanese](inJapanesesyllabaryorder)(50音順)

朝日由実子(Asahi,Y.),2011「カンボジアにおける手織物業の分布状況に関する一考察」『社会情報研究』 Vol.9,2011年 10月,pp.6174 ,2012「カンボジアメコン河支流沿いにおける絹織物生産と地域社会 スロックチョムカーと スロックスラエの関係を中心に」『社会情報研究』Vol.10,2012年 12月,pp.6578 天川直子編(Amakawa,N.),2004『カンボジア新時代』研究双書 539,日本貿易振興会アジア経済研究所 岩永悦子(Iwanaga,E.),2003「カンボジアの染織 チャム人の果たした役割を中心に」福岡市美術館『カ ンボジアの染織』福岡市美術館,pp.138144 ,2005「東南アジア織物文化におけるカンボジア チャム‐マレー人の技術を中心に」『季刊 民 俗学』29(2),pp.9497 植村和代(Uemura,K.),2003「カンボジアの染織文化」福岡市美術館『カンボジアの染織』福岡市美術館,pp. 124130 荒神衣美(Kojin,E.),2004「カンボジア農村部絹織物業の市場リンケージ タカエウ州バティ郡トナオト行 政区 P村の織子仲買人関係」天川直子編『カンボジア新時代』研究双書 539,日本貿易振興会アジア経済 研究所,pp.223273 コンクンテァリ(Kong,K.),2013「中央カンボジアの伝統的織物共同体コダッ」田中滋編『織の海道 vol. 05アジアへ,カンボジア クメール染織の美』織の海道実行委員会,pp.5967 田中滋(Tanaka,S.),2013「カンボジアを中心に見たインドシナ半島の染織概論」田中滋編『織の海道 vol. 05アジアへ,カンボジア クメール染織の美』織の海道実行委員会,pp.3857 森本喜久男(Morimoto,K.),1998『メコンにまかせ 東北タイカンボジアの村から』第一書林 ,2008『カンボジア絹絣の世界 アンコールの森によみがえる村』,NHKブックス[1102],日 本放送出版協会 米倉雪子(Yonekura,Y.),2014「カンボジア伝統絹絵絣ピダン制作の現状と課題」『学苑』第 883号,昭和女 子大学,pp.7588 (米倉 雪子 国際学科)

Tabl e1.Theareaswherepeopl eproducesi l kthreadandweavei katsi l ki nCambodi a Provi nce Di stri ct Commune Vi l l age
Tabl e2.Thenameandrol eofeachmemberoftheresearchteam Name,ti tl e,organi sati on Rol ei ntheteam 1 Mr.SIYONN Sopheari th,ABD,
Tabl e3.Fi ndi ngsonproducti onandsal esofsi l kcl othsandPidansi nNorth-EastThai l and andSouthernVi etnam duri ngthefi el dsurveyi nSeptember2015andAugust2016 * Country Provi nce Vi l l age/

参照

関連したドキュメント

Standard domino tableaux have already been considered by many authors [33], [6], [34], [8], [1], but, to the best of our knowledge, the expression of the

The input specification of the process of generating db schema of one appli- cation system, supported by IIS*Case, is the union of sets of form types of a chosen application system

Laplacian on circle packing fractals invariant with respect to certain Kleinian groups (i.e., discrete groups of M¨ obius transformations on the Riemann sphere C b = C ∪ {∞}),

The total Hamiltonian, which is the sum of the free energy of the particles and antiparticles and of the interaction, is a self-adjoint operator in the Fock space for the leptons

She reviews the status of a number of interrelated problems on diameters of graphs, including: (i) degree/diameter problem, (ii) order/degree problem, (iii) given n, D, D 0 ,

This section describes results concerning graphs relatively close to minimum K p -saturated graphs, such as the saturation number of K p with restrictions on the minimum or

delineated at this writing: central limit theorems (CLTs) and related results on asymptotic distributions, weak laws of large numbers (WLLNs), strong laws of large numbers (SLLNs),

delineated at this writing: central limit theorems (CLTs) and related results on asymptotic distributions, weak laws of large numbers (WLLNs), strong laws of large numbers (SLLNs),