地方財政における歳入と歳出の異時点間の関係 : 都道府県データによる分析-香川大学学術情報リポジトリ

全文

(1)―ÀÖ―.

(2) . . ―― ――.

(3)

(4) #$%& '()*+, 453678/ 9. !

(5) ". !-./012,3. !#$:;/<'=

(6) >

(7) 3. 4?36@ABC:DEFGHI

(8) JKL. !MNOPQ

(9) . R34?36STUVBC/:DW

(10) XY)ZZ,34?36 @ABC:DEF #$[\!/XY> ]^_à nQ Z /bcZ?def(gh, Z(i,jklm '(L>). 34?36@ABC/ 9o pqrstbuf( \:DEF, #$vw(st

(11) xy=<'=

(12) f() iwznst 34='36{@ABC[?|}~6st Mtax-spend hypothesisQ,[)1FriedmanMn Q

(13) (~ 3 6/fI,A?/">'f_Z? f()!Buchanan and WagnerMn Q }~ / 36/il

(14) [Z?/ ) 34 36

(15) ¡¢£A/¤ ¥¦§¢£A/¨©Z?/u *+ª«

(16) ¬®^¯°±M²³´µ¶µQ\]^_·¸¹º/»>) ZZ

(17) ¼½¾>i) nQ gh

(18) R34?36@ABC:DEF¿ PayneMÀ ÁÁ ÂQ

(19) ÃlÄÅf().

(20) ― -―. ÊË;ÌÍÎÌÏ. ±+. ÐÑ Ò.

(21)

(22) . !. "#$ %spend-tax hypothesis&'()

(23) *Peacock and Wiseman %+ , ++ , . ,&/0

(24) 1. 234567 1

(25) 8952:;#. $<=

(26) >?52:@ABC. DEF

(27) AGHI. CBarro%+ , . ,&JKLM

(28) NOPQ

(29) RS TUVWX 1Y Z[\]^C

(30) :@_`

(31) :$a$b cd^ ) e

(32) 'fgh

(33) . %fiscal synchronization hypothesis&'(i

(34) 'jk

(35) lImn)Âo. Cp qr2As9 tuv. *vwMusgrave%+ , -&x Meltzer and Richard%+ , y +&)

(36) 1. 2z{. A!|}SAGH~

(37) Hoover and Sheffrin %+ , , &x Baghestani and McNown%+ , , &

(38) 'H^C1

(39) 2. . %institutional separation. hypothesis&'( i^

(40)

(41) A

(42) 9L%I CL&A%VAR&( %ECM&

(43) 'Granger

(44)

(45) ¡ ¢£¤ ¥¦AXY)i'jk%§&¨©'2ª«gjkA¥¦¬ BX®^¯°§ T©)

(46) Marlow and Manage , y y& Holtz-Eakin, Newey and Rosen %+ , y . + , y y& Chowdhury%+ , y y& Ram%+ , y ,& Joulfaian and Mookerjee%+ , , ±& Miller and Russek%+ , , ±& Dahlberg and %+ Johansson%+ , , y& Payne%+ , , y& Zapf and Payne% ± ± ,&N( i

(47) 1. 28²

(48) T®§'B³´kµ¶jA¥¦¬. LAC~·

(49) ¸¹% ± ± y&·º% ± + ±& (»bB

(50) ¼½A¾¿¸¹% ± ± y&A«g$«gÀÁ $ ¥Â·º% ± + ±&ÃÄ §Å![«gVA@v ÆÃÄ

(51) A¥¦ICÇÈ% ± + +& ³.

(52) ¶{,yz@ ´

(53) µO=>. ―s―.

(54) #!Ewing, Payne, Thompson and Al-Zoubi . !"#$%&'()*+",. -./%01 234567,89: ;<=> ?@A. BCDEFB-GDHIJKDL MNOD;< =>PQRSTUVW-XYMNTZMN,[\]^<T_àD b@cdefaDb@cWg,h^<i:WRjklO,m?Ln U,W-?&?AB-,#opqJKDLTijerina-Guajardo. and. Pagán rR Carneiro sL ;<=>&tu vDwxq,yz@{ GDP =>,m?e|}7 a~RYMNTZMN,[\]^<0? r G.Owoye and Onafowora LOECD oq q,yz@ @A. ;<=>01?B-, TW-@ q,m?Le|}7a~! T ,#_à defa?-,~]@c0?@A TqDLDoi and Ihori T ;<=> &tuDGranger ;<=>01 e|}7a~=N1,89: {T]@ ¡¢&£¤¥¦§¨HI%,0?@AG.© ª«¬ L{®¯°#± ²³e|}7a~ R!{ GDP ´

(55) µOD=> ¶{·¸¹º@{¶{»¼b+½?@AcBB Ewing, Payne, Thompson and Al-Zoubi L¾¿ÀÁÂq$Ã{ #± { T¶{TÄÅ]@ÆÇ,y?uÈlÉÊ,Sz ~]@ ?ËÌ<Í?@ABË,ÈlÉÊÎ"#$&'()* +", -.®%&!.ÏÐHIJK Zapf and Payne Saunoris and Payne Young Tb@A.ÑÒÓW-@ÔÕ DL'("#$ÖL+"W-&?A r Tijerina-Guajardo and Pagán rL¿×Ø,yz@Ùx [Ú GDP ÛMN VAR 1,89:e|}7a~R,Ûm MN´

(56) µO=>0?@ACarneiro sL¾|Ü`,yz @Ùx GDP rMN,m?²ÝÞ?@A.

(57) ―¹Æ―. ÇÈÉÊËÌÊÍ. ¹º´¹. ·À ¶¹.

(58) !"#$%&'()*+,-./. 012. 3456789:;<=>;?@A B:CDEF9GHI

(59) JKLM VAR NO'PQ$%&'()*+ ,-. RS. V2:W2A:; WS. 0123456TU. RS+XQYZ2

(60) [\. ]@^_7@AB7YCD9 `. abÌcdef]gE. hV2AB. i19?j:;>f]gE6kV2ABlm 8no 9`pqr^s I tuvewxy #z1{|:

(61) }~9abÌcde9. V2. :

(62) }W2` I z>

(63) }W2ab` Icdef]gE6k>zHV2^n>;2z> W2A7HàbÌcde6 3456V2A CD9SW2A<9/V2O :;>OQ PQ 7Y. !"#

(64) . ]@TQ{|ABVAR 012TUV2. $%&'()*¡¢£¤,-¥-V2A. ¦9$%&'()*+,-§. . ]@¨©V2Aª«. ¬§©®2A ¯O¥ #!%"$ CD9GHI °±

(65) àb Ìcde²³ ´ µ ¶ ¶·¸z>¹ º ´ º·¸<·¸O /:;>3456V2A:;>V® Ä O»E¼ 9½

(66) ¾¿·ÀÁÂ·¸ÃRSx>;2A.

(67) ―5/―. z{S+(.

(68) . !"#$%&'()*+,. -. . / 0 012345 6 . 6127 89:;

(69) <= !"# >?@ABCDEFG+,. HIJ. / / 61KL+7 MNOBJ PQRFSJ TUVWXY Z[\ ]^DE+_à+,7b c)TUVWXYZ [\34deRFSJ fEgRF. !"# hijk17. PQRFlbfBm3+, ,!. 兆円 60. ./1)%"#'*0$*+&-(. 50 40 30 20 10 0 1955. 1960. 1965 地方税. 1970. 1975. 1980. 地方交付税. 1985. 1990. 1995. 国庫支出金. 2000. 2005. 2010 年度. 歳出. EE89:;n

(70) <=pqr a+, z{|}1~12J,. no

(71) *+k1pqr%GF stuvqwxqy z{|}1~34 l+,7b E[pqr. z{|}1~ ztoJ4E+,.

(72) ―¨―. ÈMPÉÉÊ. . ¡_ ±.

(73) . !"#$%&'()*+',-.%&'/.0. #12345678/'9:;<.%&'=. >?'@A. BC$%&#D9',EFGHIJFKL MHNOHPQG R.ST B98C9UVH'WX Y.;Z[\ - ] ^ _à7bc12#9:WXY'de3a7 UVHfSgB98-hcER'WXY./ij _` "E kGH'lmn'opn,8#FkGHWXY qr.>?st . c. uBvw&t'ox yz R5{ . |}~9:,8 '>?.' '. E. /iB7 v@. Bj. D9WXY. c. LRTAX LRLAT LRNGD LRGEX 8/'. 9:j' . pm_Go ¡ ¢-GDP W£¤XYX. hc 8. ' GDP W£¤XYX R¥¦§C'WXY. ] ] ¨_©ª' pm&«] ¨SNA-¬784'] ¨SNA 'WXY .!B ] ® _`CBa¯#8d pm " ° ®SNA . ] ± ±_`-WXY. ²³ 412,4WXY. '´s. ] ] ®_`#D8-j. 9:' GDP. W£¤XYX R.° ®SNA ' ] ] µ_¶·'WXY ¶¸~¹º ±»¼ ° ®SNA " ] ] ®_`'WXY. ] ¨SNA '½¾WX. Y'¿À -ÁÂBÃp B98 #!&"%$)'( >?. Ä: ½9- LRTAX LRLAT . LRNGD LRGEX 'jWXY RDickey and Fuller ] ^ ] ] ® ADFAugmented Dickey-FullerÅÆElliott, Rothenberg and Stock ] ] ° DF-GLSDickey-Fuller GLSÅÆPhillips and Perron.

(74) ―k―. ,o ;r~. PP

(75) Kwiatkowski, Phillips, Schmidt and Shin KPSS

(76) .

(77) . !"#$% &

(78) '()*+ A ,%

(79) -./01234%56+. !".

(80) 78&9: ADF ; PP !"<=. LRLAT

(81) LRNGD

(82) @A LRGEX BCD>?.

(83) >?LRTAX

(84). %EFG HIJKCD9. !"9: ;WXVF ;YZS

(85) DF-GLS ! LMNOPQRSTUVF

(86) !. 9 9.

(87) %EFCD>?GLMNOPQRSTUVFE

(88) 3 KPSS.

(89) [\CD>?,% OPQRSTUVF% . (

(90) ]>?G 9: <]^<WXS_%;%^!"S`VF% a

(91) )*+ B -./012b56+cd,% PP !".

(92) %EF>?%GCD>?9. TUVF4%G

(93) efg>?9. IJKCD9TUVF Y;`. % V=

(94) KPSS !"<= 9.

(95) ADF

(96). LMNOPQRS.

(97) [\>?,%CD>?. OPQRSIJKCD9TUVF

(98) efg>?9. "" !

(99) >?[\S !. F4%Y;Sh< (

(100) YF= !" >?9: Y;`% 3

(101) DF-GLS 9 ""9: ;WX9i4%G

(102) j&k>? ! !. TUV.

(103) LRGEX %. "">?9: ! %EFG !. ;%^!"Sl=F% S

(104) -./012b56+,% !"<=WX[ ;

(105) [\>?.

(106). ""9: ! !. ;%m^ Y^

(107) ?1n2b56+; ?1@A-./012b56+ ,o !". piqr4% S

(108) st9. -./012b56+. !"uvi

(109) >?LRTAX

(110) LRLAT

(111) LRNGD

(112) @A LRGEX "">?9: ;WXwxy( Y;[ ! [\ ! Y9

(113) V=z{>?S|}w~: <]^< [ (

(114) Johansen

(115) |}w !" $VF% YY9

(116) st9. #. 76[ (

(117) 6?S 4.

(118) ――. efghijhk '!. . lmno . %"$#&. A. ADF

(119) . DF-GLS

(120) . PP

(121) . KPSS

(122) . LRTAX. . . . . LRLAT. . . . . LRNGD. . . . . LRGEX. . . . . Δ LRTAX. . . . . Δ LRLAT. . . . . Δ LRNGD. . . . . . Δ LRGEX. . . . . . . . . . B ADF

(123) . DF-GLS

(124) . PP

(125) . LRTAX. . . . . LRLAT. . . . . LRNGD. . . . . LRGEX. . . . . Δ LRTAX. . . . . Δ LRLAT. . . . . . Δ LRNGD. . . . . Δ LRGEX. . . . . . . . KPSS

(126) . . !"# Δ $%&%'()*+#,-./

(127) !012 $ &34567892$ :456789 ;#

(128) + #,

(129) <=> !"#?@A&B$2

(130) !"#CD EF$GH4I 10 #,ADF

(131) : DF-GLS

(132) &CD $2AICAkaike Information Criterion JKLM NOP10#,EF2PP

(133) : KPSS

(134) &GH$2Bartlett kernel 4Q01 NeweyWest R > JK010#,ADF

(135) : PP

(136) !"#STB$2MacKinnon ;UVP#,DF-GLS

(137) &STB$2 &WXY+$ MacKinnon ;2&WXY+$ Elliott, Rothenberg and Stock , Table, p. ; Z[VP#,\ 12KPSS

(138) !"#STB$2Kwiatkowski, Phillips, Schmidt and Shin , Table, p. ;UVP#, $]^_+à2 $]^_+à2 $ ]^_+à+#b:4Ic,.

(139) ―©©―. :;qr

(140) DDBÀkÁ*./ I" Johansen .;LJ<E. §¨n[. ®¯°±¦. . v. ¡. ¢T£¤¥¦. #!!. ##". (©ª «T!©«. («ª !P. #"". ###. !(ª ¬¢T«!. !¢ª ¬. #"#. ##$. ¢ª ¬e¬¢!¢. PTª (P. #"$. #!%. eª P«!PP. ©ª «. #!!. #!". P¬ª ¬TT. !«ª e«. #!". #!#. PTª e¬«¢. !eª ¢«. #!#. #!$. ¢ª ©!«P¬. P(ª e«. #!$. #!%. eª P«!PP. ©ª «. ²³v

(141) # +,-´µ§M. !# !$ AIC

(142) "!$

(143) VAR "

(144) "!" ¶ 3 Lno

(145) ·¸§Ÿ¹5G +,-./º

(146) »5¼¶W½n[¾ Johansen

(147) .E¢ T£¤¥¦ Osterwald-LenumP ¢ ¢ !¿%W. !# !$ AIC

(148) VAR " "!" Akaike Information Criterion

(149) "!$. ! "#. $% LRTAX LRLAT LRNGD &' LRGEX ()*

(150) +,-./ 0123456 78-93 :;< :;=>< ? "%)3G HI3JF $ @ABC &'DB()EF ! T VAR KLMN

(151) OPQR)SE. #!04231H7:B,J>J9 783USVWXYZM[\].^_`R-a-b Hamilton T cd! e P P 78fghij*klmLnopS qrstuvwx yz{|qr}~qrADDB#./-9 -9"# DDB5+,-./

(152) G qr5 E3 D$%DB#./5EE0 qr5 4 DB5j

(153) \]E5%$

(154) VWW

(155) v 783 DDB

(156) .E()

(157) j~0./0

(158) -9.

(159) ― ―. ¡¢£¤¥¦¤§. ®. ¨©ª« ¬.

(160) VAR 0 / #". ! "#$%&'(. )*+. 0 "!"0 /$( / #0 / / !""! !#")"! ,0 / !,"$. !. ! !* !)!%& "#'*012342356 # /%* ((*,-./ $ 789:$;<56. +$" "# ")",' -#( -#" !+&. 56*0=>?@*AB$%&CDECDFGEHIJKL MNOK$PQ$RST* VAR U8VW-$$*0 ,'"$"#$%&= !#%18XY$Z[\V VAR & ]^_`VMA'aPb(. )*+. 0 .$ /$ μ "$ /"" / !.") "$ #$ / / !""" !#")"". ". !" $ +$" -!! "# ")' -#-5 6 "!! #!)!! ,' (* 0 1" +& ( ( *μ $&. *0($. +56 ".. 0 % / ". . ( $" % $ / ! '(. # * "+ 'e2/fghVijk )*+cd#$ ".$ &. + /nofp=qrstuV l$m$PQi$hh* 0. * "+ 'e2 .$yQ $vwx! ($ ".$ &. * "/ ". +$ 0. ! z{|}!V~$. )vwyQ*0 /$e2)f y~ Vn!!#$,-.$2342356 #* $. /VW#;}! F}jVvwyQ)0 i$VWvwyQ2

(161) Wj % '. h-#-56 &;e2) ! 56*01#$&( )""")##")")--' $;e2)7*0;56*0 & +&. # . ($. 789:$;<56 ##$&#&&. ". ! 2

(162) 'a*+((* '$&# # 2

(163) Cholesky decomposition#$''& 'a*.

(164) ―©ª―. {|¡¢#¡£¤¥¦0§ #

(165) . )("#!!# (. !.

(166) . !. ". !! & #!!$ "# )()(&$ #$ $"#!!"# # "#!!"# # "! $ (# ($. #$" ! %&'()*#$+ )(,()- ./0$" !. % % !% !% $() $() $%% )%()4+5" ! " # 123 ! # ) )%( $ % ( % % 6 789:$!#6;<! " 3 % =789:>?@ABCD>?E

(167) BEFGHI0J ) K1 ( !!+ L')M 3 NOP$QR+5! )("#!!#. )(#$#&'()6=ST UL'+5!#<V ("# " # )( NOPQRArecursive structure+5!QR WJ6X # ("# YZ[ \]+^_+ !# à1 V bcd:)4)M ,WJWe fgh#$3>?@ i#)M1j+5!bcd:)4)Mj BEFGHI#k lT

(168) "mnGoD)Mpq ^r3WJ\]st1 ' !" !'$uvbcwxyzd:AMSE ,6 'uv{| # "! . %"! !" !'!&$}~ 1 &+ 3 )%(#. !. }~ 1 )%()4

(169) 1!#6+5" ^r3 WJ\]st1fT

(170) 'uvbc MSE &1. 3. )%(}~ MSE &1 )%(}~ 1 A)+ . !. Vj &WJ VAR pq

(171) . . ) K {

(172) )K+ . WJ 1$; . HamiltonA= , p. = mnGoD)M Cholesky factorization #T

(173) .

(174) ―¿È―. ÔÕ[Ö×ØÖÙ. ½¾F½. ´µÚÛ ]½. LRTAX LRLAT

(175) LRNGD LRGEX !# " !. !"#$%&'()*+. ,-./01,234. 9:%;<=62>?5VAR. @AB. 5678. CD>E,HamiltonF G G !. %&'<KLMN W VAR @AB ST<UV3. H>IJ". >,OP. FQ. #$. QR<- VAR. XY ">,Z[\<]-*AIC. ^P>^_`"!".ab153c7d"!"<ab*5 ef. %;gh<ij23. +E@AB>Ek2!. l>,mno<-J5p<q,. QR<r6,256sFQRΔ LRTAX Δ LRLAT Δ LRNGD Δ LRGEX 4t

(176) 2-xy`235z*{| ,l>,uvw. }~B-%%x. uvw. %;gh>E. q< *5<q,2->23. +Δ LRTAX Δ LRLAT Δ LRNGD Δ LRGEX <4t

(177) -*,23 578%x<q,15 }~>o2}~B 6!. . FPR. %;<UV34. 5. %;gh>¡¢<£->+23¤d¥. 5cV>¦§%x<q,5¨T©+ª«<¬® ¯,°2±².234}~B . °>,³U´µ<¶K>23. N·¸. ¹- >,º»¼Tijerina-Guajardo and Pagán½ ¾ ¾ ¿. À Carneiro½ ¾ ¾ W Å". %;>Ek2!. cV>ÁÂ >Ek2·¸. ¹- GDP. &'<ÆÇ*59:´µ¹ 4* GDP. ÃÄ. °. W HamiltonFG G !, pp.È ] FÉÈ ] ¿>c¼VAR @AB<CD2H-*¿Ê H.K»23sF HOP<q, VAR ST<UV-s½ HOP FQ QR<-J5<q, VAR ST<UV-23 4*s¿ HËq12AÌ>,ÍÎÏÆD-#$%ÆD<U,4 gh>^_,ÐÑ+ VAR <ab*ST<UV-,VÒ 2378s½ H>^_,,23.

(178) QR23. !%. ―XÍ―. ">?@ABC.

(179) . !. "#$ %&'(. !)* +. ,-./012345678&9:;<=%7. "%>?@. ABCDEFG( McCarity and SchmidtHI J J KLMN 7 ! 9:;<=#$ O(P QRSTUVWX QRU 1YZ"=. "#$ %%&. [ QRSTUR#$ Doi and IhoriHI J J \L] ^&Doi and IhoriHI J J \L _`1QR6àb&cdefg hijklmn&(P QRSTU STUopqrUsT=9tuv HSTU9uLw! QR6xyz{ GDP |>?@ABC EFGO |STU9uw! QR6xyz{ GDP QRSTU#$ G(`} _`1QRSTUi~ M

(180) ^G 2

(181) QRSTU 23| QRU 1YZ"=. " MNEF. " QRSTU#$ ` . %:GEFP%& f2 QRSTU . "` %:G. (R/

(182) B:vhG(&f_ . !. "#$ . !&XHQRU QRS. TU 1YZ"=LR &/ EF}( [EF`W [ %f¡}('( g¢£¤E¥E¦

(183) §¨GQRS TU. "` %:G. !&XR#©. ª«(` Ovh`W [%f¡}( ¬I QRU8&BGM® QRUK¯°±¤²³´µ¶8&K J·A _(}vhG(¬¸G'( @®±I¯°£¤ºA¸ ÃL · G2 »¼ºA½aS¾¿ÀÁÂ&. 2 Ä@®`ÅÆÇÈ}É ¿ÀÅÆ% >fÊË Ç@®`ÅÆÄÈ}É ¿ÀÅ.

(184) ―B―. 4#. d8. ]. 7;5&"93:2&(+-!).0%6$'(0,/*81 地方税の反応. 国庫支出金の反応. .08. .12 .08. .04. .04 .00 .00 −.04. −.04. −.08 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. −.08. 1. 2. 3. 歳出の反応. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 8. 9. 10. 地方交付税の反応. .04. .06. .03. .04. .02. .02. .01 .00. .00. −.02. −.01 −.02. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. −.04. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. ij !,-.FGH 34MkhP!5 lm/FG H 34ek nm/±UVWXYZek !5 -.op/" #$%&'%*+o

(185) aoqRSTrs tuKvew5!D *ExyuF c8UVzXC A FGH 34e{| !5 VAR >}./ AIC RST.

(186) *+,-./01234. !"#$%&'%() !5 /. 6789:;5!9:<5!0=> 34 @"#$%&/. !5 ?. !6789: / 34A 0. BC D*EFGH 34IJKLMNOKL

(187) PQIJKLRST±UVW XYZ/[\ ]^_`YZ D*EFGH 34IJKLMNOKL ab5!/Lütkepohlc8 \ \ dCefghP@5.

(188) ―±―. "#m;<8;*®2¯3.

(189) . !"#$%&'()*+,-./012345. ,678()*+9:;<,=>8?:@/! ABCD;*E FG,HI JKLEM

(190) NO:PQR;<S()*+8TUV !"#$%&'KL91=>N8W RWXYMZ[. . !\(). *+]^_+`-.,1R!W/!"a,bcRd# e:f]KL,gh` ^_+ijkl. m,nN8. Jo&9QR#epqrs,tu/0;*, 9/0N88?NN&KLvKLwxy "#z{w8xy"#<w8|wx}q~/OABC DEKLW

(191) N8,6789 xy"#<w9,1R!1JO8T2xy"#z{w,1 9/086?N8W&l:@ TY()*+E

(192) ,Y ()*+9vE FG,H IQ()*+ABCDE8 &

(193) YMABCD()*+E FG,HIN8W/ORWJ1N8W . JRd8()*+9/!;<9. ,=>8@'8?:@NN&Wr,67 8bcRdv#e8 8?W()*+9#ea ¡¢, n. 1O£;*()*+ABCDE¤. 8¥

(194) ()*+:P¦§W~d!O R¨~;*,n©&)ª/ON8,«Q?8N:@Z[¬ . XRZ[8?:@.

(195) ―e―. F 9#. psp. p. 43672&"<8=5&(+-!).0%:$'(0,/*;1 地方税の反応. 国庫支出金の反応. .08. .12 .08. .04. .04 .00 .00 −.04. −.04. −.08 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. −.08. 1. 2. 3. 歳出の反応. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 8. 9. 10. 地方交付税の反応. .04. .06. .03. .04. .02. .02. .01 .00. .00. −.02. −.01 −.02. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. −.04. 1. 2. 3. z{1ghijBemn1|}~ L#$%. 4. 5. 6. 7. o#$]p1z.

(196) . !"#$%&"'()*+ . /0123456$%+7'() * @%. ,-.. 8$9):; <=>?. A#$'(BCDE1FG1HIJ61'(. KLMN%OP1/01QRSTUVW VX/YZ. [\6$@%]

(197) 1^_ 1VHàbLc. .dJU$` #6]e f1ghijBklmn1Lo]e VP p f. qr1s 1t$u$)vw88)f1xy. .

(198) ―}―. Z0+P,u ,-ow 6#. 34&"95:2&(+-!).0%7$'(0,/*81 地方税の反応. 国庫支出金の反応. .08. .12 .08. .04. .04 .00 .00 −.04. −.04. −.08 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. −.08. 1. 2. 3. 歳出の反応. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 8. 9. 10. 地方交付税の反応. .04. .06. .03. .04. .02. .02. .01 .00. .00. −.02. −.01 −.02. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. −.04. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. ,-HIJK+L;MTUV<M

(199) %{ <

(200) %.

(201) . &' ()* +,-./012345 !"#$%. 6789 :;<=

(202) >?@A+BC > #D=

(203) #$E %/FG,-HIJK+L;MNO+P

(204) MQRS T+UV 01,-.WXY+: Z0[\. =]FG5^_-àbc+d :efgh

(205) i <=:j% &' ,-HIJK+RSTefkl

(206) mn+op;Mqr1 sZ0mnLt ;,u ,-vow+o xyz{ |} |'~mn# ,-: avowc<M

(207) %.

(208) ―i―. ¡¢£¤¥£¦. i87i. §¨p© i.

(209) . !" #$%&'()*&

(210) . +,-./0123456,789:;<1 5#. 8=2;6&":4<3&(+-!).0%7$'(0,/*91 地方税の反応. 国庫支出金の反応. .08. .12 .08. .04. .04 .00 .00 −.04. −.04. −.08 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. −.08. 1. 2. 3. 歳出の反応. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 8. 9. 10. 地方交付税の反応. .04. .06. .03. .04. .02. .02. .01 .00. .00. −.02. −.01 −.02. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. −.04. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.

(211) rt56, 6,;. i. 789 =5# >?@A,B@

(212) CD; EFGH2IJKL' M!N

(213) OP95G=,Q; ERSTUVWXD<1YE Z[\]6,^_>`@aA1bcdefghNi889jklm7 no pqbci 8 88pqB@rstuvw] E

(214) OP5UVWXx y!2z];b{2b|}T~ :34

(215) !I JKL'M!5UVWXx6A156, ; S rt~@:!204&A1@Q0 defgh Ni 8 89~34=5#

(216) q^" ut!" b,_R.

(217) . ―C―. DÍ!D®¯°./.

(218)

(219) . !"#$%&'()*". + ,-./ 01. &

(220) + (!"#./

(221) 23 40"5!&6. 7. 89:;<=>?@$%A* BC

(222) D EFGHIJKLKMNO$%PQ4*". 7BCR. STUTVWXK

(223) DY"*

(224) Z[:\]^_`;Ra*bc d)*". 755e fghi$%

(225)

(226) jk. &STUl4*mnoWi0pqrA*". 5!es. 7t uvwx. ! !DTV#1 _`yz

(227) {| }~ t * +Wi0pqE 4*" x. 5!&6. 7 t uvwe. ! _`yz

(228) EFTV#1 ,. )){C ~ } EF ~ t*". 7.

(229) CTU EFDl4 *,)Wi0pqE d0"5!+ei. 7t uvwx. ! . EFDTV#1 _`yz

(230) ,)) {u~ } C u~ t EFu~ C!60d0*". 5!&6. 7 ~ F e

(231) &. Kl !4 t | |¡. ¢6( u t u¡¢ e¡¢£^¤¥4* TU VAR ¦£=§¨ ©ªi «¬. E. FD®¯°./±²o³´4 7, ±²Ke

(232) µ ¶>·^KM"* ¸¹d) º»¼t½¾¿J:\]^_`; _`yzl. :;<=>[email protected]À4 7. «¬Á"* :;<=>?@K6('() $%Â {. ! ÃÄes.

(233) ÇÈ>?@. 7 ÅÆt _`yzl4* &

(234) ÉÊ"*Ë:Ì>?@4 ,.

(235) ――. . !"#$"% (!. . &'() . *'$%")&)# . S. E.. .

(236) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . S. E.. .

(237) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . S. E.. .

(238) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

(239) . . .

(240) ―(7―. HA,w

(241) $V)$gOhz. ~. h. !:|:}. S. E.. . . $. U. 7 % ( U . ( ( (. 7 % U U. U % 7 7. . . !. . 7 . U % ( %. U U 7 ( U. U ( % . U . %. % U %. % % . % % 7. % U %. 7 U 7 %. (. ( . 7 . 7. U 7 ( 7. 7 U 7 . 7. U . U U 7 . ( ( 7. U % . ( ( . . U 7 . U U 7 % . U . U 7 % . ( ( 7 7 %. . U % . U U % U 7 . U % ( U . U U U . ( % ( % . . . U U U ( . % ( 7. U 7 ( 7 . ( U (. . % (. ( U U 7. % ( (. U U ( 7 . ( % . U . % ( % %. U U % U . U U 7. U % 7 ( %. ( U U . U 7 . :}$ !/]

(242) S. E. _ VAR AIC .

(243) . !"#$

(244) %. $

(245) &'$.

(246) ($. !)*+. ,-./01

(247) 23401 5- 6 7. !"#$01. 5- 89:;<=2>?@ABCDEBFG HAIJK- LMN5O@PQRS

(248) 3TU$VW,-XYZ 2>HA[\/]

(249) . !^YZ_à

(250) b=_'K. )-cMN XY*+,-_deRf

(251) ' ghij_kl

(252) ). !)_)'YZRf

(253) M. Nmn

(254) 5?oXYZABM

(255) pqrs tuv2w_x y)5

(256) R>yS)z{ YZ34X) YZ@. !YZ_à

(257) )-c

(258) . !b=_'4> )-N<=.

(259) ―Ø―. ÙÚtÛÜÛÝ. ÏÐ§Ï. ËÌÈÞ ßÏ.

(260) . !. "#$%&'()*+,-./012345# 6 7289&:!;<=>?@=</?ABC=< ?A@DE&&F?/. E#GH3I6HH3@J!. KLMNO)P=>3=<QRSTUVWXYG3 Z[\H3/]^2" &&F?/. 2I6E_2=<?A. E#G3ÙJ!&ab/cD5. 3&FdeEf&%ghij'!@k3lm IH3"#=<?'&nopqrU/stuvGH3@ QwIQxy6C&3!;<?A@z{#I=> ?A/|}G3VWx~DE7#@3. =<?A/. E#G. 3Ù#E6H#Ù/4&G3J!KLMNO )Q@=>"#=<nopqrUtw#2<&Z['~ &<Z[ Qx3GH3. Qw6. 7Ef8Ù"#"32 KLMNO))2@=>Qa/ GH3P=<t/a GH3I~345#6 &:!;<=>?A@=< 2opqrU/¡¢G6H Ù@8£¤Q¥¦E'&<Z[I"Q. FriedmanK§ ¨ © ªO. «¬zG6H'~3~J!"#)®¯Qx!;< a/GH3@KLMNO=<t/$a2 )F°±²"G35'6H³´¬Ù"# @!;<µ¶·¸@KLMNO=<g¹"I~t wIº»/¡¼2H3½#"E6 3HyQQ@g¾ VAR /¿À2ÁÂÃÄq0Å3´¬ /Æ(6CJ!KLMNO)P=>3= <TUVWVGÇÈÉÊËÌ/4&G3ÍÎKÏ Ð Ð ªO @& $%&=<KÑÒO9g¾"#IÓÔÄ¿ÀÕÖw$%.

(261) ()xbi©Ãt

(262). ―ºÑ―.

(263) !"#$%&'()*+,-./0&12&345 678 9':;<= > ? >@&'()'()*+'ABCD'()E'FG <HI@JKL VAR M'

(264) %&'N ()*+

(265) OP977QR'ST A ()*+QRUVWX!97YZ[ \97!" ]^_à34 L#$%&'()bc<decf@S0' ()*+34&Vghijka%lm'12%lno &%p5q8r8':;<= > ? >@&'#$stuvwxbyz K{4|= #}QR'~`V%&

(266) 5 = &_ìR'7#$stm !"7&5q:;<= > ? >@&'KL[O8 'Fisher _`q8 %'VAR OLS %M 70'<= > > @&'] ¡./w_`¢`8# $%&

(267) LM£~]¤a ¥|'¦§¨©8 Arellano and Bond<? ª ª ?@Q GMM Mqr8':;<= > ? >@ &'!"«¬'#$05decf®*+¯°±² 0'<= > > @&7³#$ %´V'!"#$ µV¶§&'·¸R%l¹ ?&'!"ºKL VAR ¢`»85KL¼T½#$ %l¹=&'()bc<decf@ . m[¾¿#À'. ÁÂÁÂÃt

(268) m#$%l7Q R'()bcxbÄÅlR)QRÆÇÈÉ %pm7 5¹Ê'!"%&? ª J Jgh= > ? >ghr%#$st8 '9st#}7Ë7 Î%lÏ. «¬#$&ÌÍ.

(269) ―48―. °±.,/0,Á. . QRTU 7. #"$! .

(270) . !"#$"%&'. 7 89: ( )*+,-.,/0,123 4 4546. 4. . ;<=> 8

(271) ?!"%$"#@A&B!CDEFGH IJ?!KL( MN,-.,OP/0QRS)QRSTU3V76W 49: XYZ[$\S]^_ . 7

(272) àbcdeCDfghijklmPn 89: opqrs( )tu/0QR3 No.7. v v7 wxyz. 7

(273) {|}~c~c ( )klr. n!3.,%V. 9: 7v8 ¡ .

(274) . !¢#£%¤¥&'¦§¨©ª«¬n. ®qr¯HG?!CD( )°±.,/01²3 V845Vv6 W9: ¡$³´µ .

(275) tu. !¶·/0¸¹{|}&'( ). v9: Kº»QR3 V4 76v 77 Arellano, M., and S. R. Bond,. ¼ ¼. ,½Some Tests of Specification for Panel Data : Monte Carlo Evidence and an Application to Employment Equations¾ , Review of Economic Studies, Vol.78, ¼ W. pp. W W Baghestani, H., and R. McNown,. ¼ ¼ 4 ,½Do Revenues or Expenditures Respond to Budgetary Disequilibria ?¾ , Southern Economic Journal , Vol.¿. , pp.v. v. Barro, R. J., ¼ W¼ ,½On the Determination of the Public Debt¾, Journal of Political Economy, W. . Vol.8 W, pp.¼ 4 ¼ Buchanan, J. M., and R. E. Wagner,. ¼ W W , Democracy in Deficit, New York : Academic Press. Carneiro, F. G., W ,½The Oil Cycle and the Tax-Spend Hypothesis : The Case of Angola¾ ,. 4 7. Applied Economics Letters, Vol.. 4, pp.. v ¼. Chowdhury, A. R.,. ¼ 88 ,½Expenditures and Receipts in State and Local Government Finances : 8 7. Comment¾, Public Choice, Vol.7 ¼, pp. W W Dahlberg, M., and. E. Johansson, ¼ ¼ 8 ,½The. Revenues-Expenditures. Nexus : Panel. Data. Evidence from Swedish Municipalities¾ , Applied Economics, Vol.v , pp. vW¼ v8¿. Dickey, D. A., and W. A. Fuller,. ¼ W ¼ ,½Distribution of the Estimators for Autoregressive Time Series with a Unit Root¾ , Journal of the American Statistical Association, Vol.W4, pp.4W4v . Dickey, D. A., and W. A. Fuller,. ¼ 8. ,½Likelihood Ratio Statistics for Autoregressive Time.

(276) ――. +,-./0123453'67896:; Series with a Unit Root , Econometrica, Vol. , pp. . Doi, T., and T. Ihori,.

(277) , The Public Sector in Japan, Edward Elgar.. Elliott, G., T. J. Rothenberg, and J. H. Stock,

(278) ,Efficient Tests for an Autoregressive Unit . Root, Econometrica, Vol. , pp. Ewing, B. T., J. E. Payne, M. A. Thompson, and O. M. Al-Zoubi,

(279) ,Government Expenditures and Revenues : Evidence from Asymmetric Modeling , Southern Economic Journal , Vol. . , pp. . Friedman, M.,

(280) ,The Limitations of Tax Limitation , Policy Review, Summer, pp. . Hamilton, J. D.,

(281) , Time Series Analysis, Princeton University Press. .

(282) . !" #$%$&$'()

(283). Holtz-Eakin, D., W. Newey, and. H. S. Rosen,

(284) ,The. Revenues-Expenditures. Nexus :. Evidence from Local Government Data , International Economic Review, Vol., pp. . Hoover, K. D., and. S. M. Sheffrin, .

(285) ,Causation, Spending. and. Taxes : Sand. in. the. Sandbox or Tax Collector for the Welfare State ? , American Economic Review, Vol. , pp.. . * Johansen, S.,

(286) ,Statistical Analysis of Cointegration Vectors, Journal of Economic . Dynamics and Control , Vol.. , pp.. . Johansen, S.,

(287) ,Estimation and Hypothesis Testing of Cointegration Vectors in Gaussian Vector Autoregressive Models , Econometrica, Vol. , pp. . Joulfaian, D., and. R. Mookerjee,

(288) ,The. Government. Revenue-Expenditure. Nexus :. Evidence from a State , Public Finance Quarterly, Vol. , pp. . Kwiatkowski, D., P. C. B. Phillips, P. Schmidt, and Y. Shin, .

(289) ,Testing the Null Hypothesis of Stationary against the Alternative of a Unit Root , Journal of Econometrics, Vol., . pp. Lütkepohl, H.,

(290) ,Asymptotic Distributions of Impulse Response Functions and Forecast Error Variance Decompositions of Vector Autoregressive Models, Review of Economics and. . Statistics, Vol.. , pp. MacKinnon, J. G.,

(291) ,Numerical Distribution Functions for Unit Root and Cointegration . Tests, Journal of Applied Econometrics, Vol. , pp. Marlow, M. L., and N. Manage,

(292) ,Expenditures and Receipts : Testing for. Causality in. State and Local Government Finances , Public Choice, Vol., pp. . Marlow, M. L., and N. Manage,

(293) ,Expenditures and Receipts : Testing for Causality in.

(294) ― ―. . . . State and Local Government Finances : Reply, Public Choice, Vol., pp. . McCarity, T. A., and S. T. Schmidt, .

(295) , Dynamic Patterns in State Government Finance , . Public Finance Review, Vol. , pp.. Meltzer, A. H., and S. F. Richard,.

(296) , A Rational Theory of the Size of Government , . Journal of Political Economy, Vol. , pp.. Miller, S. M., and. F. S. Russek,.

(297) , Co-Integration. and. Error-Correction. Models : The. Temporal Causality between Government Taxes and Spending , Southern Economic Journal , . Vol. , pp. Musgrave, R. A.,

(298) , Principles of Budget Determinations, in H. Cameron and W. Henderson. eds.

(299) , Public Finance : Selected Readings, New York : Random House. Osterwald-Lenum, M.,.

(300) , A Note with Quantiles of the Asymptotic Distribution of the Maximum Likelihood Cointegration Rank Test Statistics , Oxford Bulletin of Economics and . Statistics, Vol. , pp. Owoye, O., and O. A. Onafowora, .

(301) , The Relationship between Tax Revenues and Government Expenditures in European Union and Non-European Union OECD Countries, . Public Finance Review, Vol. , pp. Payne, J. E.,

(302) , The Tax-Spend Debate : Time Series Evidence from State Budgets , Public . Choice, Vol. , pp.. Payne, J. E.,

(303) , A Survey of the International Empirical Evidence on the Tax-Spend . Debate, Public Finance Review, Vol. , pp.. Peacock, A. T., and J. Wiseman,.

(304) , The Growth of Public Expenditure in the United Kingdom, Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press. Peacock, A. T., and J. Wiseman,

(305) , Approaches to the Analysis of Government Expenditure . Growth, Public Finance Quarterly, Vol., pp. Phillips, P. C. B., and P. Perron,.

(306) , Testing for a Unit Root in Time Series Regression , . Biometrika, Vol. , pp. Ram, R.,

(307) , Additional Evidence on Causality between Government Revenue and Government Expenditure , Southern Economic Journal , Vol., pp.. Saunoris, J. W., and J. E. Payne, .

(308) , Tax More or Spend Less ? Asymmetries in the UK Revenue-Expenditure Nexus , Journal of Policy Modeling, Vol., pp.. Tijerina-Guajardo, J. A., and. J. A. Pagán, .

(309) , Government. Spending, Taxation, and. Revenues in Mexico , Review of Development Economics, Vol., pp. .. Oil.

(310) . !". ――. Young, A. T., ,Do US Federal Revenues and Expenditures Respond Asymmetrically to Budgetary Disequilibria ? , Applied Economics Letters, Vol. , pp.

(311) . Zapf, M., and J. E. Payne,

(312) ,Asymmetric Modelling of the Revenue-Expenditure Nexus : Evidence from Aggregate State and Local Government in the US , Applied Economics Letters,. . Vol. , pp.. .

(313)