The Society of Crop Science and Breeding in Kinki, Japan
The Society ofCropScience and Breeding in Klnki, Japan'
J.CropRes.55:13-
17
!!=
Research
Article
(2010)
Species
diversity
ofthe
genus
Echinochloa
(Poaceae),
nativeto
easternAustralia:
afocus
ontheir
habitat
andthe
threat
of exotic speciesEijiTanesakai),[bmoko ohno2)and
Hirofumi
Yamaguchi2)
ODepartnrent
ofAgricultural
Scienceand 7lechnotogMFbcuttyofAgriczalture,
KinkiVnivensity(3327-204Nakamachi,Nara631-8505,Japan)
2)
Graduate
SchoolqfLifeand EnvironmentalSbience,OsakaPrefectureUhiver:sity(1
m
1
Gakt]ericho,
Nakaku,
Sakai
599-
ss31,
Jqpan)
Summary: Thenaturai hal)itatof theEchinochtoaspecies growingineastern Australiawas investigatedinMay 2008.Inthissurvey, fourannual native species, E dietrichiana,E inundata,E.telmatophila,and E,tumeriana, and threeexoticspecies,E.colona, E.6rus-galli,and E polystachya,were observed. The native species clear]y
have
separatehabitats:
permanentstagnant poolsfbrE.
dietrichiana,inlandfioodplainsfor
E.inunclata,in
or besidestreams forE,telmamphila, and inlandwaterceurses forE turneriana.Whilethehabitatof theexotic species greatlyoverlap thatof thenatives, especially perennialE,polystachya,which formsmonospecific stands instagnant poolsand inorbesidefioodrivers duetoitsremarkable productivity,and E.crus-galli, which hasthepotentialtoadapt to scveral moisture conditions. We predictthattheinvasiveexotic Et:hinochloaspecies wil] become more and more threateningcausing serious
damage
tothenative species withinthe
same genus,Keywords: Echinochtoa,eastern Australia,habitat,native species, threat
lntroduction
The genus Echinochtoa,cemprising nearly
50
species,is
distributedworldwide under differentclimatic conditions oftemperature and precipitation
(Michael
1994,
2001).
Thisgenus ishighlydiverseinthe levelofpolyploidy, growinghabit,and reproductive traits,facilitatingadaption toseasonal or temporalclimatic
fiuctuations
(Ylabuno
1966,
Tlanesaka1986,
Aoki andYamaguchi
2oo8).
Overall,the climatic conditiens ef theAustralian
eontinent are characterized as aridtosemi-aridin
inlandareas and tropicaltosubtropical monsoon climate in northem coastal areas, Exposureof plantson thisgeographically isolatedconiinent tosevere droughgsudden fireor fiooding,has yietdedunique speciation of many taxa,Here,nearly twenty
Echinochtoaspecies have been recorded including
8
native species:E.
dietrichiana
Michael,
E elliptica MichaeletViekery, E. in"nclataMichaelet Vickery,E.kimberlayensisMichaeletVlckery,E,lacunaria
(Muell.)
MichaeletVickery,E macrtmdra MichaeletVickery,E,tetmatophilaMichaeletVickery,and E.turneriana
(Domin)
Black.Ib show thedistributionof each species, a detailedmap of thecollection site isavailable on theAustralianPlantCer;suswebsite
(http:/twww.anbg.gov.aulchahl
apcD orthePlantNet,NSW FIoraOnlinewebsite(http://plantnet,
rbgsyd,nsw.gev.auf).All
theabove
species are considered tobeannual
(Michael
1975,1980a).Acccepted :April 16,2elO
Correspondingauthor : EljiIhriesaka
([email protected])
Tbappreeiate thespecies diversityof Echinochloarelated to
natural habitatand reproductive habit,a
field
surveyin
easternAustralia,New SouthWalesand
Queensland
was carried out in May2008;
fortunatelMan effective rainfaIl fe11thatsummer after several yearsofsevere clrought.ProfessorPeterWilliam
Michael(Sydney
University)accompanied us duringthistripto cenductthesurvey. Thisreport
documents
anddiscusses
Echinochloaspecies observed inthistrip,Here,we elucidated a threatto
natives under competition
between
species within the samegelnus. Natlvespecies
E.dietrichianaR WLMichael
This species is annual, distributedin coasta1 areas of
Queensland
and theNorthernTbnitory(Michael
1999).
Theepithet comrnernorates Amalie Dietrieh
(1821-1891),
a skillfuI collector in the1860s,
for two of her specimens frem Rockhampton and near MackayOvlichael
1999).The numbers ofdocumentson thisspecies hasbeenvery few
based
on awebsitesearch frorn1926 to the
present
(Australian
New CrepsWeb Site,http:11www/newcrops.uq.edu,aul),In thissurveM ina perrrianeniswamp at Yeppoon Wetlandsbeyond
Capricornia
InternationalResort,Queensland,
a few slender paniclesandleaveshadernerged above thewater surface toward thebank.
Almost
al1
parts of the procumbent eolumn up to2
m long, branchingfromnedes with adventitious roots, were submergedThe Society of Crop Science and Breeding in Kinki, Japan
NII-Electronic Library Service
TheSociety ofCroP'Science and Breeding in Kinki) Japan
J.CrepRes.
55(2010)
rather small
due
tolowerdensityofpanicle branchescompared withE crus-galli er E,telntatophita,suggestingthis
species tobe
pseudo-allr;uag.The habitatof thisspecies lookssimilar tothat
oftheexotic E.polystuchya.E.inundataR VVLMichae}etVickery
This species isannual, distributed
in
New Seuth Wales,Queensland,
and SouthAustralia(Michael
and Vickery1975),
The plantgrows
in
or near watercourses or lakesusually followinginundationafterflood
rains.In thissurvey, beside NarranLake,Nonh WesternPlains,New SouthWhles,about10
plantswere grewinginancl besidea marsh with a depthlessthan 40cm. Plants were erect or erectly spreading up to 160cm tal1,often with shoots
branching
upwardfrom
submergedlower
nodes with adventitious roots. Seed sets were good on any individualplant,Here,sorne aquatic plantswere alsogrowingin marshes
(i.e.,
dyriophyllum
sp., Seshaniacannabina(Retz.)
Pers,,and
dyperus
sp,) and on moist bedsoftextured soil(i,e.,
1[tz)lygonumsp.,fortulacasp., and OxalisperennansHaw,),The climate of Narran Lake issemi-arid with an average annualrainfa11 of
358-425
mm. Themonihly rainfalt isyariable, with a 1argersummer, butalso a winterpeak.Conditionsof lessthan250
mm of rain often occur over a three-yearperiod,causing droughtconditionsOfcGann
etal.2co1),
Vickery(1975)
citedanote bearingon a collection by CaptainShortat theBritish Museum
(1835-1836),
about aboriginal use of itsseeds forfoodin
theNorthWest
Interier
and theabundance ofthe plantsinthis area,Prof
Michael
toldus thatnativepopulationsalso use thetuberous root of C]xalisperennans, suggesting thatfloodplains would befavoritesites tofindfoodplantsforthegatherers.
E.tehnntophila R
W.
MichaeletVickeryThis species
is
annual,distributed
in
New South Wales,Queensland,
and WesternAustraHa(Michael
and Vickery1975,
Vickery
1975),
Itgrewsinor besidepondsand streams. Inthissurvey, Nindigully,
Queensland,
indensestands along banksof'
irrigation
channel,plants
hademerged fromslighrlybelow
water'
level.Here,some aquatic
plants
grew
togetherjust
belewthe water surface(i,e,
Ecliptasp.) and on moist banlcsjust
above water(Le.,
Altemantherasp,, Chlorissp. and Cyperussp,), In Urbenville,New South Wales, thisplantgrew}forming a compacg densepopulationon moist sediment of streams, Boththe
habitat
and themorpholegy ofthisspecies resembled thatof exoticE.erus-galli,E turnehana
(Domin)
J.M. BlackThisspecies isannua1, distributedinNew SouthWalesand
Queens]and
(Michael
and Vickery 1975,Vickery 1975).Theplantgrowsinornear watercourses. In
this
survey,thisspeeies was observed on Mr,and Mrs,Pagett'ssheep-graxing property,"Winrae:
near Barringun,N'ew South Wales, Only ene
individual
grewin
abore
drain
subjected toflooding
in
the
last
sunimer rainfa11, Mr.Pagettsaid thathe
had
not seen.th,lfi. plant
along the drainsince big rains seven yearsearlien His observation indicatedthattheburiedseeds ofthis plantcould be viable atleastseven yearsinsemi-arid conditions. Alongthis
drain,
oneindividuatofE crus-galli was also found.Exotic
speciesE.colona
(L.)
LinkThisspecies
is
annual, natiyetotropicalregionsin
theOld Wbrld,butnow widely distributedarollnd Australieqfoundin abundance on grasslandand disturbedsites such as roadsides anddry
creeks subjecttopergodicfiooding
in
summer rainfa11(Vickery
1975).
The plantusually growssingly ordiffusively,
witha
few
individuals,on rather drysoil inAustrali4tropicalAsia and the UniteciStates,but occasionally forrning monospecific compact stands en wet soil sediment fotmedatthe mouth of smal1 streams intofloodrivers; thelatterstandswere observed inPapua New
Guinea
in
partofthis
prejectin
October2oo8.
E.crus-gaUi
(L.)
BeauvaThisspecies
is
annual, considered tobe
nativetoEuropeandAsia,butnow widely distributedintemperate reglens of the
world includingAustralia.Thisspecies hasbeenestablished as a
common summer-growing weed ofrice
fields
and otherdisturbed
orenriched moistsitesin
nature(Vickery
1975).
In
this
trip,near asubtropical rainforest inLegume,New SouthWlaEes,theplant grew on riverside sediments together with ether aquatic plants such as fotygon"tnhydmpiperL,,Comrnelinasp. and Clyperussp,
The
vegetation surrounding thisplantissimilar tothosein
orbesidestreams er abandoned rice fieldsinJapan,
'
'
'
'
E.craspavonis
(Kt!irth)
Schult.Thisspecies isaiiarmual toshort-Iived
perennial,
native to SouthAmerica,extending northwards intothesouthern United Statesas a weed of r{ce fields(Vickery
1975,
Michael2003).
It was introducedintoAustralia,naturalized inNew SouthWales,
Queensland,
Victoria,and WesternAustralieq
found
as anoccasional weed of cultivation
(Vickery
1975).
Althougl!this plantwas not observed on thistrip,Prof Michaeldonateda specimen ofE. crusy)avenis collected atCam,den(near
Sydney), New SouthWales,inJanuary1970,
with thecQmment thatthis specimen matches thetype material collected inSouthAmerica, A photoof thisspecimen hasbeen attached as an appendix,showing theconspicuous characteristics of thisspecies, which hasa lemma with
3-
teiO-mm
Iongfiexueseawn. VVlethereforededucedthatsome speeimens identifiedas E.cniszpavonis that we examined
in
Mississippi,USA, and plantmaterials collected 14The Society of Crop Science and Breeding in Kinki, Japan
TheSociety ofCrop Science and Breeding in Kinki, Japan
Speciesdiversityof thegenusEchinochtoa
(Poaceae),native
toeastern Australia:afocuson theirhabitatand thethreatefexotic speciesas E,crus:pavonis fromLouisiana,USA, inpartof thispreject
in
August2oo7
(Sago
etal
2008,
Ihnesaka
etal2008),
weremisidentified,
because
these collections were characterized ashavingrather straight or tapered
long
awns up to20
mmlong.
E polysincltya(Kunth)
Hitche.(syn.
E.praestans
R WLMichael)This species isperennial, native to tropicalto subtropical regions of SouthAmerica.It
has
been
introdueed
toPapuaNew
Guinea,Queensland,
Northernferritoryand New Sou,thWalesand was
described
asE praestansbyMichac1(1980b).
IntheAmazon
floodplains,
thisplant
shews afloatinghabit,growing
up to
10
m ta11,with a heightcorresponding totherising
flood
water level,and steady elongation atI.1
mper
month; itachieves an annual net productionof dry mass exceeding99
Mgtha(Piedade
etal1991).
Thefloatingability ewing totheremarkab]eproductivityof
this
species isequal to thatof thehexaploid Africanstrains ofE,stagnina(Retz,)
Beauv. butismuch higher thanthatof the tetraploidtropicalAsianstrainsofE.stagnina and the 14-ploidE. picta(Koen.)
Michael(Yhbuno
I966,
1lanesaka1986,
1991).This
plant was irrtroducedintoQueensland
in
the1ate
2orh
century asapotentialpondgrassfor
use
by
the
grazingindustry.
In
Australia,
seeds were often completely sterilebuttheplantvigorouslypropagates
bynodalshoots, rhizomes, or fragrnentsof shoots or rhizomes. Inthis survey, on the cattle-grazing propertM"Eden GarTy",near Marlborough,
Queensland,
ff.polystaclryagrew formingdensestands
in
artificially ponded pastureswith wateg at thetimeofinspection,
60
cm or moredeep,
Here,Brachiariamutica(Forssk.)
Stapfgrew adjacent toor sometimes mixed with thestands, and Ilymenachne amplexicaulis
CRudge)
Nees grewseparatelyat
the
centerofthepond,also
forming
monospecificstands. E.polystachyaisas a
high
prioritythreattonorthern Australiadue to itsinvasivecharacteristics as pointedout elsewhere(Humphries
et al1991,
Csurhesand Edwards1998).
Infact,on theFitzroyRiverinRockhampton,thisptarrtoecupiedfiooded
laggons,forrningmonospecific stands thatappear to exceedthe
competingBrachiaria,
Threat
ofinvasive
Ebhinochtoa
Figure
1
shows a schematic representation of habitatofEchinochloa species in eastern Australia related tomoisture conditions. The native species havehighlyspecialized toadapt to
localenvironmenta1 fluctuationscausing semi-arid conditions over several years,
fires,
and suddenflooding.
CensequentlM
the native species are more clearly separatedfrom
each otherin
theirhabitatbutoverlap with thatof exotic species
(Fig.
1).
Inthe longterm, thenative species isguaranteed
to withstand anyenvironrnenta1fluctuationonthiscontinent,However,byehance,
favorable
cenditions may allow exotic species tequicklyspreadbeyond theirnatural populationand outcompete thenative species, atleastintheshort term.
Inthissurvey, E.polystachyaformeddensestands on stagnant poolsftworedbynative E
dietrichinna,
and on floodriversidesfavored
by E, temiamphila and E. inundottt.InthecentralAmazon, E.polystachyacommonly formsmonospecific stands, suggesting thatitoccupies a niche thatno other plantcan
occupy; this
habit
has
been
deduced
from
theobservation thatthis
planthas
remarkable productivityand acapacity toinvest
rnest of itsenergy intoshoot growtli
(Piedade
et al1991).
Humphrieset al(1991)
listedthisspecies as ene ofAustralia'stopenvironmental weeds and recommended urgent action of its control and a review of thecurre/nt plantingpolicy,Sevenyears
lateg
Csurhes
andEdwards
(1998)
statedthat
"total eradication may nolonger
be
feasible,
and action shouldbe
taken topreveat7-continued spread
.
Insouthem partsof the UnitedStates,this planthas been established as one of the most troublesomeinvasiveweeds inricefields,especially inthoseintendedfor second-crop productionafter resprouting inpermanentpaddy conditions
(Webster
et al2007,
Sagoet al2008,
Tanesakaetal2008).
The widespread E. crus-gatti isalso invasive.E.cnts-gaUi
E.crus-galli'
<e--->
E,polystachya"
-<f----L-TTH"---"---ii----J---F"m->floodusual
E,
inundata Fig.1 aWatercourse
Stagnant
HabitatsotEthinochroa species related to soil moisture and floodingevents ineastern Australia.
The Society of Crop Science and Breeding in Kinki, Japan
NII-Electronic Library Service
The Society ofCrop Science and Breeding in Kinki, Japan
J.CropRes.55(2010)
growthclosely overlaps E,telmatophita inmoist coasta1 areas,
and occasionally also
E,
tumerianain
much drierinlandareas.E,
crns-gatli ishexaploidand consists of two subspecies, themore
temperate E,crus-galli ssp.crus-galli and the more tropica]E crus-galli ssp. hispiclata
(Retz,)
Honda(Michael
2001).
The formersubspecies intemperateAsiaconsists ofthreevarieties: var. crus-galli which grows inshallow water or moist soil, vai:,formosensis
Ohwi
whichgrows
inpaddy
fields,and var.pn ticolaOhwi
which growson moist orratherdry
soilindisturbedareas(Yahuno
l975,
1983).
In
addition,there
is
acultivatedderivative,
E,
esculenta(A.
Braun)H,Scholz;
syn,E
utilisOhwi etYabuno,ineastern Asia
(Yabuno
1962,1%6, 1987,Scholz1992).
Such a 1argediVersity
inthisgenome setsuggests aremarkable potential toadapt toamuch wider range of environmental conditiens. Thisspecies or species group islikelytocontinue te spread and threatenAustraliannatural populationsby supplying new
genotypesfromthesource poolofthe Eurasiancontinent.
TheAustratianEchinochtoareminded us ofDarwin's histerical
ti
insight:Asthespecies ofthe sarne genususually have,thoughby
no means
invariably,
much similarityin
habits
and constitutioq and always instructure,the
strugglewill generallybemore severe betweenthem, iftheycome intocornpetjtion with each other, thanbetweenthe species of distinctgenera"
(Damin
1855;
inChap III).Some exotic Echinochloaare invasivedue to higher productivityand plasticity,and totarger
geneticdiversity
compared to native species. They threatenserious damage, especially tothe native Echinochloapopulations,becausethey tendtocompete forslmilar resources within thesame genus.
Acknowledgement
We thankProfessorPeterWilliamMichac1and hisdaughteg Diana,forpinpointguidanceen thefieEdwerk duringthissurvey
trip.We are again gratefulto Pro£ R WL Michael forhiskind
commenis
including
his
new opinions on Echinochloaspecies onthe
manuscript.This
research was supported bythe
Japanese MinistryofEducation, Culture,Sports,Scienceand Technology, Grant-in-AidforScientificResearch,Ne, 19405017(supervised
byH.YainaguchD.References
Aoki,
D.and Yamaguchi,H.2008,
Geneticrelationship betweenEchinochioacrus-gatli and Ebhinochloaoryzicola accessions inferredfrominternaltranscribedspacer arid chloreplast DNA
sequences. IligedBiol.Mdnag. 8,233
-
242.Csurhes,S.and Edwards,R. 1998, "Potential environmental weeds inAustralia,Candidatespecies forpreventativecontrol" http:1/www.weeds,gov.au.lpublicationstbookslpotential.html Darwin,C.1859.71heorigin qfthespecies,
1993
Modern LibraryEdition,Randem House,Inc.,New Ybrk,pp.
87
'
106,Humphries,
S,
E,
andStanton,
J.
P,
1992.
Weed
assessmentin
thewet tropicsworld
heritage
area of nenhQueensland.
Reportto
the
SM:t
Tropics
Management Agency,McGann, T.D.,Kingswood,R.and Bell,D,
2001,
VegetationofNanranLake NatureResearves,North WesternPlains,New
SouthWales,Cunninghamia7,43
nt
63.
Michael,E W, and Vickery,J.WL 1975.IXvonew species and a
new combination
in
Echinochloa.
felopea
1
,44
-
48,
Michael,P.W,
1980a.
Threenew armual species of Echinechloa fromNonhernAustralia,7lelopea2,
25
r
29.
Michael,R W, 1980b,A new peremialspecies of Echinochloa
fromNew Guinea.
Mopea
2,
31
-
33.
Michael, R W,1994,Distributienand taxonomy ofEchinochJoa
A world view withkey
tothespecies occurring inChina.In:Proceedings
of
the5th
lligedScienceConjbreneeof
C7tina
(Kunming,
Chjna,25
L
30
November 1994).Weed SocietyofChina,Kumming, China,161
'
166.
Michael,R W,
2oo1.
Plantlinksbetweeneastern Asiaand eastern Australia.IiigedBiel,Mduag.I,
157
-
163.
Michaet,R WL
2oo3,
EchinochloaP.Beauv.In:Fleraof
IVbrthAmerica,IVbrth
of
Mlexico,Nbl.25
(ed.
by Barkworth,M. E,,Capels,
K, M,,Long,
S,
&
Piep,
M
B,)
Oxford
UniversityPress,Oxford,
390
-
403.
Piedade,M. T.F.,Junk,W, J,and Long, S, P.
1994.
Theproductiyityof the C4grassEchinochtoapolystachyaon the Amamn floodplain.Ecology72,1456
-
1463.Sago,
R.,
Tbnesaka,E.
and Yamaguchi,H,2008.
[Barnyardgrasses
growingpaddy ricefields
inthesouth central UnitedStates,and theirprotection.]IVbgyouoyobi Engei
83,
10
-
14
(in
Japanese),
Scholz,
H. 1992,Echinochtoa escutenta, comb. nov.-
thecorrect narne oftheJapanesebarnyardmillet(Gramineae),
7ttxon,41,
522
-
523.
Thnesaka,E.
1986,
Floatinghahitofthe
perennialspecies ofEbhinochloastagniua
(Retz.)
Beauv.and E picta(Koen.)
Michael.iligedRes.,
ipn
31,
136
-
142
(in
JapanesewithEnglishsummary),
Tanesaka,E.
1991.
PolyploidyinEbhinochtoapicta(Koen.)
Michael.I-leedRes.,
ipn
36,
183
-
186,Tbnesaka,E.,Sago R. and Yamaguchi, H.
2oo8.
HabitatofEthinochloaspecies inthesouth central U,S,A.Memoirs Ric, Agric..KinkiUitiversity.
41,
169ul75
(in
Japanesewith Englishsummary),Yabuno,T.
1962.
Cytotaxonomlcstudies on the two cultivatedspecies and the wild relatives in thegenus Echinochloa.
dytologia
27,396-
305.Ybuno, T,
1966.
Biosystematic study of the genusEchinochloa.lpn.
X Bot.19,
277
-
323.Yabuno,T.1981.
[Taxonemy
and geographical distributionof16
The Society of Crop Science and Breeding in Kinki, Japan
The Sooiety of Crop Soienoe and Breeding in Kinki
厂
JapanSpecies diversity ef the genus Ecゐinochtoa(Poaceae)
,
na 恒ve to eastem Austra監ia:a focus on their habitat and the threat of exotic speciesthe genus Echinochloa
.
]Sh∬seib ”tugakukenkyu
5
,86 − 89
(in
japanese)
.
Yabuno
,
T.
1987.
Japanesebamyard
millet (Echinochtoa
utilis ,Poaceae)
in Japan
.
Econ,
Bon41,
484 − 493.
Yabuno, T
.
2001.
匸Taxonomy and phylogeny of the genusEchinochl・a
.
]In: Naturat History・f
σ enUS Echin・chl・ α,(superv量sion by Yabuno, 工 and ed
.
by Yarnaguchi, H.
).
Ze okyQ Shuppan Publ
.
,
Tokyo , pp.
1−
10 (in Japanese).
Vickery
,
J.
W.
1975.
Echinochloa Beauv.
ln:Ftora of NewSouth
陥 ’es
,
No,
19.
Gramineae
, Supplement to Part1
, Part2
(ed.
ByVickery
,J.
W
) NewSouth
WalesDepar
仁ment ofAgricuhure , pp.
189−
211.
Webs
重er,
E.
P,
Gri
笛 n,
R,
M.
and Bounin,
D.
C.
2007,
Management of Echinochtoa polystachya in
dri11
−
seeded rice.
doi:
10.
1094
!CM−2007・
0816−01−
RS.
http:〃www
.
plantmanagementnetwork.
org ! pub〆cm !research !
20G71drill1
Appendix l Specimen of E
.
crus・
・
pav()nis colleCted at Camden (near Sydney },
New SouthWales in January 1 970
,
Note the 3−
to 10−
mm longflexuose
awn.
(Specimen kindly donated by P.
W.
Michael>東 部
オ
ー ス
トラ リ
ア
に
自生
す る
ヒ
エ属
植物 (
イ
ネ科 )
の
種 多様性
:特
に
そ
の
生
息
地 と
外来種
の
脅威
に
つ いて
種 坂 英 次 D・
大 野 朋 子 2}・
山ロ裕 文 2) 1> 近 畿 大学 農学部 農 業 生 産 科 学科 (奈良 市 中 町3327− 204
) 2〕 大阪府立大学 大学院生命環境科学 科 (堺市学 園 町1 − 1
) 要 旨 :オー
ス トラリア東部に生 育す るヒ エ 属植物の生 息状 況につ い て,
2008年3月に現 地 調 査 を 実 施 し た,
本 調 査におい て
t4
種の1
年生 在 来種,
E.
dietrichiana,
E.
inuncinta,
E.
te{matephila,
およ びE.
turneriaua,
およ び3
種の外 来 種,
E.
cotona
,
E.
crUS−
galli,
お よ びE.
polystachya,
を観 察 し た.
在来種は 互いに生息地 を 異にしてお り,
E.
dietrichianaは 常 時 冠水 状 態 に あ る 沼 地