無限なものを語るということ論理学と形而上学の間をめぐって

全文

(1)!". .

(2) .

(3) . . . t,vw^_OP&""QBQfD. )A,>BCDEF)*+,GHIJKL2MNO. &-./01+23456789:;<)=>?@8. !" #$%&' ()*+,

(4).

(5) . ´³ ³ µ ³² ¶ ·¸² ¹ º·¶ · ³ » ¼µ ² ¹ º! D_½)*+,fpBfDZ. ª«2¬Z?)®"¯°HB"fDQB, ±² ³. D\ ¨D¢~,UVW"

(6) )g,^_OP. O6fg£,Q"h.§.¦ O6XBf. S,QB, D_B,UVWB"^s_fQ. ,Q")¤¥t,B"f Q2¦. . PQR DS,UVW"XYZ[\XY+6]S,^ \. ¾¿t, ^À)[D6ÁÂ,. Q)@Ã Äa. D_s_) ¡ZPbB¢~,U^vwfg£. D_à_b)cd,Nd36eVHf"PgN_b. 6%}~,Uxy zy"D)~X\2ZPb. ÍZgÐ?ÏÉ,^ BGeVlm O6ÑKZg-. 34,lm2ÊËÁ%ÌÍZgfgÇÊÎÏHÌ. VWª« O6s?Q>ÇÈÉg,"

(7) 2. ©!. )hi)jkflmnopBD,^ 2qNr?)Os_ t. 234,lm)[D6]Å2Æ56D,U. ,URn^ %2PR, D. ÒO6D,ÍB,U^_OPÓÔ"

(8) lmÕÖ. T!. ,Utfdb "uivwxy zya{| O. QO"B, D_s_)&2Os_. S, t,)t,^ )[fn,U. .

(9)

(10)

(11)

(12). .

(13) . . cd¾¿ÀÁÂÃÄMN2+. !"#$%&'()*

(14) +,-./01. -2+34 56789:;<=>?@ABC DE 0+

(15) FG+HIJKLMN6OPQRS. ÅcPÆ2+rsz

(16) *ÇÈÉ,. 0+3rsR\5*pÊ6/2job©Ë. . YZ[FE*\]56^_à]-b+cd. O

(17) -+ÌÍ/¹E.b

(18)

(19) ,ÎoÏj. TUV 5*WX0+3 Ref0+ghi

(20) .-j /kl*+4 mn. ¦Ò. ÓÔ rs ÕD4 /)bÖ×#+4 /. 2+3. 7ØÎ5*Ù.. £©Ñz

(21) *. 6

(22) 3o6Epq !)+rs!"#r. Î*F6Ê*\h2Ê*. 1ß. . ¸Ûy).b+ /. 4 /)bÖÚFj/2+. Ð. sU0+tuvPSwxy)^_z

(23) *{j<|+3 }

(24) ABC!)+~!"#c Vu E+^_z

(25) *D+3 Y/ 0+6E%B. ¾.b*

(26) +3. Ü5*Ý-6bÞ

(27). /

(28)

(29) v1Ref0+z

(30) * ¡¢2+£¤¥+/z

(31) *¦!)+§¨!. . " # © . © ª « 0 + « ¬ ® ¯ °¯ ± ¯ ² ²³¯ °¯ ´ ±µ . . àRà-.

(32) Ê*cdRáâ0+" rsE+. .b

(33) 4 +àã -34,z

(34) *}äz. ¬ ® ¯ °¯ °µ 5*¤¥+/°²°´¶ ¯ ·¬ z

(35) * ¸o¹º!"#rs» 5*¼½-.{j<|*S. PQ O

(36) -+Ý-z6./¹E. T0+3. ,-.å^æ0+çèR2+3pqé\ÒÓrs. 0+/Rrs0+ êj -zSë)bÖ.

(37). .

(38) !. "

(39) #$%!&'()*+,.

(40) . . 5!_)7 !.

(41) D(01

(42) Z 4#>1! Y. 5()OPQRST#%=_. , |Y3U_JKOPQRST}~F. 5 5

(43) 8w1Fx@ 61Fyz

(44) #{. .

(45) -./, %! !&'() #01. a5!. )=_

(46) D(*Z`4#.. ()F. )# =(.

(47) 2345 6()7 "

(48) # 5 5 "

(49) #. =. . 89:!;5<=>!. . ? @AB&'()=C5 @AB#. )5)uD(*

(50) ED |() () . DE

(51) ! 1FGH(<IJK:

(52) LM. . F 5 |# Z 4<7>^N . NOPQRST ! U,5VF#(. ,F<7>( "4# w)F. ED . |4510|ED N.

(53) `. WXF1F! 5#Y5Z [5\]^_4# 4#N >a3,b<_)7(

(54) KcE)F. 1X4dE)!)7X4. 4VF>(

(55) #. OPQRST d(*efgh

(56) +F!510@A. 4. |. dE)! 4VF(!

(57) ,F IE)F. . BAKijk0lm )#n \]4 s. >op

(58) !. . 5)D<(7OPQRST#

(59) $% _. (). . 5 "

(60) qFr)510It "

(61) #GH n 1F DE1N ! 1Fqu'JK 5v\E)F. . .

(62)

(63) . 4F

(64) BZ

(65) :

(66) . . . M

(67) 2(B2; 4F ¡1. . @8A" &B"CD. ¢£¤"¥^¦ZR

(68) Z§¨

(69) 1. .

(70) !"#$

(71) % &'( ) * +,-./0'12345678

(72) 9. &(E67'123 4FGHIJKLMNOPQ. "©vªz BZ

(73)

(74). 2%:; 8%<" =>;8?. RSTUVR1WXYZ[\]-]^_`-]^. «V"iW'¬2(;. r. 1Ma;Vb

(75) R[\]-]^Zcd. % 4F&:x® ¡x¯"°`±,;. q. &ef67_`-]^ZE&ghBVi. B&

(76) M

(77) '¥^¦b

(78) %A&(. r. W2& 8jkZlm1noZp1 q. /0Z} 2B'M2(%. }'2"(BB ~+,-.. B u" z'; st1&g{|2. v

(79) (

(80) EwX xyEBst1.

(81) ¿"&BZ671(R¿.

(82) 2&BZ671. "& 2':. XZ1'"(1)°`±,Á&3 . ¸¹· ¹µº ¶ » ¼½· ¶ ¾ r V¿

(83) R¿Nqµ¶ ·À¹µº ¶ » ¼½· ¶ ¾ r V. EE°`±,z<

(84) RNqµ¶ ·. ²³

(85) B&

(86) M5A(´. 123 UMz<P~') . É É · ¹É » ¼ÊË ¾µ· ÌÍÎÏ¶ ½rQRUqÐÊÉ . JÇUMqÈ¶. fz1 S';&Bv &'(. NVRNVÂ«ÃÄÅÆ<;Uf2. u. . noZ &BCD'. A+,-./0'123 8st. %A'

(87) 2(. . .

(88) + ,-./ +0,.1"234567. !"#$%&'()*.

(89) . A B CD B "@89$Pz{/M!. ?@"@89$5F/*Ny @ . &&"89$YZZ)*iI"#n*. !S=9$%. i"#$/. Ouvwx)*&NOi. A B 89$% &&"):,;<=9> ?@ . //)4i$ #$¡^¢=J!k£¤6. . CD E /5FGHI/#$/ J$-.K. . LM!7$&/MNO%. ONOi ©§/ª«¬"#$. !)YZ/Z. ®¯]8°*#$. ¥9M!I*uvwx ¦§^*?¨6. #$%h6. /]* F_. )±²³´*/. \8]

(90) Î_I6`=P

(91) Oab]9!. . c>µ¶#$h/·¸¹nº$NOM!Sg$ . )»º/). . . ]8"#$%P&/_. !)uvwxoq* Z)&NOM!*Á

(92) . ¾M!¿iI")#nÀi. "#n*o8ô8oq"r g$%stNOM!uv. Z)*iI¾M!µÈ$/. %PO")ik!*. ONOM!*YZi. $&/. =9!#$F_

(93) ^À$NOi*ÂÃiÄÅ B . I¾M!r µÈ$")i. /M!. wxVW*XYZ"#$&/[Oa)*

(94) *dZi8. . Æ OaÇn±_")i. O&OM>)>8. O)*5Ë o 8 o q. ****. !r =9$")ik*o8oq"o8^r g$% YZ. B Ê "#$/ . iI)P9J*o8^g$/. O*&OM>I. Z6 YZiI^lJm! k)>8 É . . yP9^lJm! k&/*Nyr / Oz{6|}8. ]8IS=9$%. /j`$&/ik*dZ^lJm! k%

(95) =9>I). . 9$%~eg&/*

(96) =9>I)*INc. &&/Nn*o86P9"#$/&pI")iki$. Ji %i¼i8*PIPIYZ/Z)½. . &NOM!

(97) =9! $I)*PNOidZOa. $&/Nc!dZ=9! $*/ O&/êfg$%h6*. PIPIQR@STUVW*XYZ"#$[/ O&/)*. . Bi"#c!*YZiI)P9 oq*Z"#$ /. . .

(98) . 7"¦!8'"%A(=>?@§¨;Z. . . .

(99) . .

(100) . . !#. {|iA3«¬®DE9¯°±²%. ¦7¯°. !«nRNOPQ. ±°DE. $W"4XI. "R4(Y&'+9©ª3. . . ' + . ,-. ./. /.

(101) . 012345$6 %#)*&'+78'"%9:;<. 5!¦#"¸"4¯7¦G%¹. . !)BCBJ<DE. . . / -y.

(102) . I#pefOgVqrstz "9I<O. ){|i)}~i<(RH5!. /-. vw . x. / , y. z no5IpefOgVqrstu. \]7^_àbcdefOghijklm !. F&'+BCDE=>?@YZ[2345<. U;7(5BV !W"4X:;H5$6%. @pÑZVzA3ÒÓ°. ÅÆ>nÇÈÉÊ$ÈÉ9ËG]IÌÆÍ@ÎÏÐ. )¯9ÁÂ!ÃA!Ä. Ä.

(103) x / -. / x-. . 7BCDEF(5%:;"oIYBCDE#. 5$"#¦G%$. 8'"%BC:;=>?@(%$(&'+RY. 4]$7´µ7"o4#(7"¦!. ¾%F¿3R8'&'9("DE%. t. . !ÔÒ"4(. IBVÀ9"<. A)BC. v. . - /R45#8. qÕÖ"Ö|³7×"FNOPQ{|iØÙ. %7(:;!%B4K9<#$. I# )&' Ý. ÞIßeàá7 /. /.

(104) R&'âãA3. ¬·. !¬·. W"4XNOPQR(io4 !. . &'+9¡¢£ !¤37"R¥o#(. $$)&'ÈÉD. . '"%7;U;98<'FA!7:;H5%. º<$6%7¦G%. º<7I4». !|³<$R´µ"o¶oR·¤. =>?@A3BCDE"FGH$ I%. 9¼½3FB4R¹. . . °ORØÚ9ÛÜ$7"#. . (K(%RH57"# 68'". . $()B4J<KL-M .

(105) . /NOPQR. . !"#$"% !&'$()*&. . ST$6%#. . .

(106)

(107) . ]:]-] anByz!"67yz~. c+]-`-]: J !. A !yzc]-def7. . UVcZn]-W]+. " {7::c`-. $56-: ,- !=>?@. &'()*+,- . /0 . /. 1 23456789"#. yz7~c K:],[a. !"#$%. ABC . /0 . /. 1 23#$D: ;/. E F1. J Z6- !. . J K56-:. yz ZA: ¡ "]¢£. ;/. E F1LG 3 1 . MM1 <. <. J "7NO !PQ. ¤¥"bJ¦N56- !. ;. 7. <. RSTUVWXK56-:. ;. J,YZZ6-[B 7"6\]P^_TU. "§§ ¨gyz7§§]c:. G /HI . E F< . V`]-:abc!defg. ©# 6C§§ª«}JJ:. <. p¬56- "A®56- !. Sp¹¼]6"oJ½¾]||¿ÀÁ. 6C[»¥-J,J:JaB+!c|o5"]. ¶]®]+ def·y¸T¹ºcZ. "]Sp¯°D:SA±²X³´µ. ;. D: Sp +:,qr. h+:ijklmnZ6 abco. /0 . /. 1 23. a7B-Æ:ZC"]#¡Z6 Çª. . +:st7 abc!

(108) . . ""def7¸TA¿UVu-[»¥. «}JJ:"`]-ÈÉA. -ÂÃklmnÄ¥ ÅB7 B ! 89un v8wx: yz7{|-.

(109). . }Zc~B :]b} :. . . .

(110)

(111) . 2. . M#. !"#$%&'()*+,-. 2#uM"2. !c LM. " ./$0"123. Y. "

(112) "#ul. "u# kLMl2[\#^'. e. O. 4 56789:;<=>9() $#"*. $a. [\. àbcA#. STUT VR S WXYZ #NO PQR. '#N ¡2¢$!". kd[\#t[\2 Y. lu#"£. Y. kLMl[\]^bc4~#¸. O. #k¹bcOº» S T¼ S ºS W{ ¼ U½TUz ¼ Q TXS Yl. O. @$kLMl k!rstu,[\*vwA. "A kLMl*¤;<=>. O Y. "vwOXQ x S TS y S Uz QQ yU{S TS VXQ x S TS Q Tz Yl. 9(). en~ª«¬5®¯9:. p|}~""#u#kLMl!

(113). °±²³´=9µ¶#·4B. !" kLMLM

(114). O Y. OTUT VR S WX Q z yTUT VR S WX WV{ TUT. #kLMl!¡À kÁÂÃÄ. ¾¿u. kLMlr'e2 !#. ÅÃÄ#tÆÇ$". . ÃÄOQ z z Q Ty S V» W{ Q z z Q Ty S VYle k. !k l2£#$. An[\ kLMl#uvw$"# Y. . M~ M#. . [\!" kLM. O. VR S WXYlu#h$kLMl". ¥¦7§¨©w. ]Â #!rsvwA$. kLMOTUT VR S WXYlmnop(q2?. [\#]^*_. Bàbcd* efg#hAij. ?@A4BCDEFGHI#JKLM. . u. . u#rvwA# r'. . . .

(115)

(116) . . . ./0R SBJM-¡JR¢st£/0. ("#$%&6¤¥6ijD¦§!¨©YNC6J.. DSS!. 'TUBJVDVWJXR()*. 9:BKLMN12'(E-56OPQ!3JRI. 6D?E6F . G 56C6HI6H'BJ. R656:³!3JRàB:_°:BC6-.. 6EW±²QC66(5HCB3(9:BKLMY. e(12'9:BKLMHI:_(°:BC6YR. 0!C®Wz¯'ND7VD"#$%&W. RWz56«¬60!:ª. ªJ0 '(ªQC6-56«¬!YNDX. /0. +,YR6E-78 -Z[VJ06H'B. TU°:BC656C6'I\SHC12´786µ¶·. D. 6. J50H'B\R(]!BY^:_HàB:_b\. !I6HIXR(¸BJ¯J0/0!(¹Nºª6. 0YN. /0cdBeBBJ6HIf6gh'( 6/0B. ~!/XRYWrQ^BJ6'56»_HIn0VD(. HI. ij!kl\C6YR,mQHIn0?o@AB. . C6pJ0qr'(+,stuYRvw!XRx. SQ!9:BKLMYR6I_60!(Wz56786. . yzVHB\(E6F{JF-/_|}B~H. 'N60!°:BC6s6»¼D½WRJ(J0. CÁSRJJ06H. 60!'. ¾-"#$%&'<=®Wz¯J0. 0YNqr!3JR(/_OPB !. J0. . ¿À!®WNBJ¯J0. . 3/0!YRMN!YRT5C5. I°:-Â9:BKLM678'(®Wz¯® DTU/0W. WNBJ¯62!ÃNÄ62HÅÆJRJ6VJ . 0. C(@ABC6'61MN62HY . . . G . J0C6HIXN. 6F. RJN6VD(56!RJNF'M6. . N!xyz6HIXR(W\YRE'(o@ABC6p. 123/4567869:;-<=>'?@ABC. !"#$%&'()*+,-./0. . . 60!'(R.{JC6-WYR'X_. . . .

(117) (X.". JArcsOtuDvwxyHRzD{|}A~o. . qD{HcplJA +|H. (Y.Z[\]^_àbcdefghHijklmnopq . . . . .

(118)

(119)

(120) . hHcghH( . .

(121) .+y{D. cgN|}ADD{xJ. . & "#' % %. N|HcgyRrcpl Ey¡GcJA.

(122) ! " # $ " ()*+,-.. ¢£¤E¡D¥x¦§GH+yr+ghÄ. ©c¦ª«¤¦ªghH+¬|H®¯ghHR. ± 5 9 . . ± ²

(123) . . °.

(124). 0 ("'"23"4.. .

(125) 0 .

(126) &1 %" "/ 5

(127) 6 78 . . . . . 8 . ; :. HR zJA §ßc£ÞgàáâkãcäÎåOæç. ~oqcyÛÜcÙOÝ¨ÕQx£Þxy. ÐÑÒ`ghH¸ÓÔÕbÖ×»cØgÙYOÚ. (¼.ÇjÈÉlJ>¼UXÊËbÌDÁ\jÍoÎÏbg. (Å.2Æ. ¼½¾XA¿{¸ÀÁÂqpq»SW½¾UOÃÄR. (¶.B·DGHcDyxJ[\]Â ¸¹º»W. "#'´#µ24& "= .

(128) . . . ³

(129) /²

(130) .

(131) 0.

(132) & .

(133)

(134) . 8 .

(135)

(136) .

(137)

(138) . 0 8 9 & "# 4 2. 78 . +,-..

(139) 0 < 8 . 0 8 " # == (

(140) . (>.?@ABCDEFGHIDJKLMNOPQHR (U.VKR. (S.TKR (W. '4 =2 2 R. .

(141) .

(142) !"#$%&'()*+,-.. .

(143)

(144) . C·VQ'(IB/JKUH/Y¸¹. ®¯/a'E

(145) C°±&'²³

(146) K?/´

(147) µ¶. 8#º8E

(148) CK?/¿&HI1'. º8E

(149) C»¼/S7/½¾&'

(150) . &8>?@ABCD&E

(151) FE#@A. /012 345678

(152) 9: ;<5=. .. ËÌ

(153) ÍÎÏÐÑÒÓÔ. QK³EÀÁ/ÂÃI1Q'(ÄÅÆ=9:. ÈÉÊ.

(154) HÇ ugwÙp u. BCG&E

(155) FHI1'(J

(156) 0K8E

(157) . .

(158) 9:/LMNO?PQRSTQ'(

(159) QOYJ

(160) WZ[&'0K/9:\]'. . ÕÖ××y×Ø(. i j f WC^'_à'(bc d. e. ff gh . ÍÎÏ

(161) êë@Aìa'JF

(162) íî\. nd. ne f r m g. m p qji tj f s c d. . ý cr . d m j j f. j h d nr j fm f m d . ür cjm ým. fg þ . d. d m k j p d j . ©Ïùú

(163) û

(164) ®¯

(165) °³OBªQ'(. øU

(166) ABA

(167) ß8'E

(168) /YQ.

(169) ïQÐ ðñòëóôõÕöÖ÷×y÷Ø(. Ä.. QKàá7âã.ä

(170) Y/åªU(æçèé. 'ABA

(171) ß8'E

(172) cmq m . m r tm d. . J

(173) ³/YQ

(174) ÚÛÄÎÜ¦ÇÝÐ/Þ. t p.A/0'(. t p.A/0'(. b d cklm. ngopqi r fp gst. f. u v v wgt m p. . UVLM

(175) WC

(176) E

(177) X'E/J

(178) W/

(179) . w xyw o p zw g{ u p|}~&U?

(180) E E

(181) >#8Q'( yogw yvp zog{ ( ( (. g w p.A/0'( uu. ¡¢£¤¥

(182) ¦§C$¨©ª«¬/aZ.

(183) ./0'

(184) H

(185) K?/. . .

(186) $. $. .

(187) .

(188) .

(189) .

(190) .

(191) !. "# # &;<=><?/@ABC. $. % ®¦ ¯. . ! . . i . . ¯ ¯ ¯ .

(192) . ® ! . . $ % . $ %°±XwuQ²³v´µ¶·ú>r¸´¹ºcXu5. DEFGH0IJAKLJMNOP5;Q@NRST/. %01234567859: @A*+5UVHBWXYZU[\]^5_`JASR. »¼J£SRHB*+5UV]½¾¿¾@ÀÁ5c°u. ¦ ¤. ¦.

(193) . .

(194) . . ,-./Í¨Î . " É. Ë i. ®. P5JAT³v´µ¶·ú5¡¢J£SRH*+. ¥ # "Ì¾OB@T. Ê . È

(195) . ¤ . Ë# . § ! ¨. È. É. . . . 4JÂÃRÄÃaUÅRST/ÆÇ ©. . . GH@aBbc3d5I,efgTh. i. jJk lgT_mh. i. j5_`JASRCnb43o \5Q. pqrstucvwu5xyJz@TQ{RST/|} ~B U5_. B\B'&B'('')/ %&)/. $ %&&')/ $ %)/. §¤Î

(196) Í

(197) .

(198) ©. . $. « $ % . . ªª"«. +,-./¤ ¥ .

(199) ¦ § ¤. ¨.

(200) .

(201) . $. % Ì. % "ª. ¬ . ©. ¥ # ª ª «¬¬. %0@TP5;JAT p5¡¢J£SRH*. $ % $.

(202). $ %&'()*+,-./ . . .

(203)

(204) . !"#$%&'()*+, , . /01 2 , 3 4 5, 602 7 809, 62 0, * :03 ;< =2 > ?6@, . , A6@ @03. , 60 ?A. , 0*E1 72 6 ?AFA3 2 6A B< =2 46 @, . 3 * CD02 8*RO Q SRN T 4U, 3 *R PP L L *. G. AF, 60 H=7I03DA3 06A3 4J. 06KL A. 20*M*NOPQ4. . , 1 A< , 3 < 026WA. , 62 UA3 *. A2 6 93 7 2 0IWA0I 6 9. 0, < 3 7. - 0, 6FI02 ,. 3 , @667I60U1 ,67I, 6 :, -9. 796WAA3L FA. 0. , 4. 676 3 71 AI A2V0I 67U33 , . V. ,0@ 9. 6< 9AI4. :,676 01 A@46*QC@,1 -676 01 A@ 3 F6L < 02 AI. . . 0A3b, 6=0. @4 XYZ[ \]^_`(a1 cA. U, . 1 , L , . A6F @, 3H, d2 , 3 46C;K71 0A3aA, 3 * fghi jklmnopqr. 48*N eSR P4U, 3 *NeL * :,676 01 A@*;< =2 306@, . , 3. . . .

(205) .

(206)

無限なものを語るということ 論理学と形而上学の間をめぐって

無限なものを語るということ論理学と形而上学の間をめぐって